Positraction oil & shimming
#1
Pro
Thread Starter
Positraction oil & shimming
Hi guys!
2 questions,
1) who is using amsoil sever gear oil as posi oil? Some 'big names' say it's all they use ( gearhead is a name that springs to mind) others say it'll cause the apocalypse. Gm additive is no option, impossible to get here, the GM tech laughed in my face.
2) what would happen if you tune the posi as per Tom's guide on YouTube, and still add the spring? A super tight diff is what I think, absolutely unpleasant on the road.
cheers
2 questions,
1) who is using amsoil sever gear oil as posi oil? Some 'big names' say it's all they use ( gearhead is a name that springs to mind) others say it'll cause the apocalypse. Gm additive is no option, impossible to get here, the GM tech laughed in my face.
2) what would happen if you tune the posi as per Tom's guide on YouTube, and still add the spring? A super tight diff is what I think, absolutely unpleasant on the road.
cheers
#2
Had a 1976 L-82, 4-sp
Member Since: Mar 2011
Location: Some days your the dog and some days your the hydrant.
Posts: 5,338
Received 1,199 Likes
on
925 Posts
Royal Canadian Navy
Are you saying you can't buy any gear oil such as Royal Purple Max Gear or similar that does not require any additive, because it's already in the formula, anywhere in the EU? Unless your going to do a dozen laps at Nurburgring, don't worry about what the "big names" recommend.
The following users liked this post:
Jebbysan (11-14-2019)
#3
Pro
Thread Starter
Amsoil is the only oil wich is supposed to have the additive in that I can find
Sadly no royal purple etc (yet)
haha, would love to do a lap on the ring though! Will be going there, not sure if I ll do a lap, only takes one idiot to kill a restored car..
Sadly no royal purple etc (yet)
haha, would love to do a lap on the ring though! Will be going there, not sure if I ll do a lap, only takes one idiot to kill a restored car..
#4
Had a 1976 L-82, 4-sp
Member Since: Mar 2011
Location: Some days your the dog and some days your the hydrant.
Posts: 5,338
Received 1,199 Likes
on
925 Posts
Royal Canadian Navy
I'm sure someone will comment on the Amsoil or just give them a call or look up specs on their website. Good luck on the "ring". An opportunity I'll never have living in Canada.
#5
Burning Brakes
I have amsoil severe gear in my 12 bolt conversion. I would still use the gm positraction additive.
My unit was tuned by Mike Dyer and I had him test the severe gear in assembly. He was very impressed with
the film strength and lubricity of the amsoil but still feels you need the gm additive.
My unit was tuned by Mike Dyer and I had him test the severe gear in assembly. He was very impressed with
the film strength and lubricity of the amsoil but still feels you need the gm additive.
The following users liked this post:
Street Rat (01-19-2019)
#8
Pro
#9
Team Owner
I just regeared my vette . The super posi kit came with more steels to put more preload and of course really locking up both rear tires. I used the Lucas Oil product with posi lube in it. When I first ran it in reverse turning tight I could hear binding. So I added an additional tube of posi lube in retrospect it probably only needed some breakin time. But I put 300 miles on it and drained the fluid refilling it with Lucas oil with posi additive in it
it always leaves two big black marks 335 wide
it always leaves two big black marks 335 wide
#10
Tech Contributor
1- Can't help as I never used any oil other then a quality 90 or 85-140 gear oil with GM additive. The only time I didn't was 35 years ago and tried a well known oil that had the additive in it, it chattered badly until I added the GM additive. The additive has gone through some revisions since the old Whale oil days. I still have a case of the product used about 10-15 years ago and seems to work better then the current product when 1 bottle is used. With the new stuff, available from any dealer, summit, or jegs, use 2 bottles and it should be fine. You can use fancy names oils if you like but I never needed to. Some of the diff's out there I built have well over 100k miles on them now and going strong. Now what you can get over there I can't say or recommend.
2-A correctly tuned posi is balanced and has no lash. Springs are not required- if it is properly setup. The process is not new, it's been done for the past 40+ years that I know of. Proper spider prep and access to a surface grinder to dial in the shims is required as well, many times the standard shims will work as they come in 005 increments but to really get it right, not close - but right, I have to grind shims. A properly setup posi will also be radiused and polished more then just touching the windows. Once done the clutches are already seated since many, as in 800 revs both CW & CCW are applied to it. Tom's video covers it pretty good although we have a slight difference in assembly technique. They can be done by hand, I did 100's of them, but a machine works a lot better. Building a machine for one posi build probably is not worth it but if you know someone with a lathe that has low RPM in back gear then you can rig up a setup. I am doing one this weekend if you want to come to CT I'll show you how, yeah I know a bit more then an hours drive, lol.
Done correctly they will out perform and outlive any stock spring loaded posi, done wrong you will have an open diff.
2-A correctly tuned posi is balanced and has no lash. Springs are not required- if it is properly setup. The process is not new, it's been done for the past 40+ years that I know of. Proper spider prep and access to a surface grinder to dial in the shims is required as well, many times the standard shims will work as they come in 005 increments but to really get it right, not close - but right, I have to grind shims. A properly setup posi will also be radiused and polished more then just touching the windows. Once done the clutches are already seated since many, as in 800 revs both CW & CCW are applied to it. Tom's video covers it pretty good although we have a slight difference in assembly technique. They can be done by hand, I did 100's of them, but a machine works a lot better. Building a machine for one posi build probably is not worth it but if you know someone with a lathe that has low RPM in back gear then you can rig up a setup. I am doing one this weekend if you want to come to CT I'll show you how, yeah I know a bit more then an hours drive, lol.
Done correctly they will out perform and outlive any stock spring loaded posi, done wrong you will have an open diff.
The following 2 users liked this post by GTR1999:
jb78L-82 (11-14-2019),
sagebrush rebel (01-17-2019)
#11
tuned posi question
Hello,
I followed the tuned posi procedure but 4,000 miles later I have way too much clutch wear, approx. 0.030" on driver side and 0.015 on pass. side. The initial setup used the preferred all steel, new clutches from Tom's and I don't think it was setup too tight. I used 100 revs both ways to seat the clutches, would that have made this much of a difference? This is in a street driven vette and that is not driven too hard. Where did I go wrong?
I followed the tuned posi procedure but 4,000 miles later I have way too much clutch wear, approx. 0.030" on driver side and 0.015 on pass. side. The initial setup used the preferred all steel, new clutches from Tom's and I don't think it was setup too tight. I used 100 revs both ways to seat the clutches, would that have made this much of a difference? This is in a street driven vette and that is not driven too hard. Where did I go wrong?
#12
The person to send a PM to about your problem is GTR1999.
The following users liked this post:
jb78L-82 (11-14-2019)
#13
Tech Contributor
It wasn''t set up correctly. there is more to it then leaving the springs out, it has to be balanced or it not work. I will be holding a posi tuning seminar in CT this Summer if you are near by. I can't tell you what is wrong other then it's not right, I would have to check it to see.
#14
Race Director
The reason GM put a spring in it was for winter driving. If you have one wheel on ice and one not the wheel on ice will spin without the spring. With well-tuned clutches and no spring you'd most likely still lock it even in this situation although it's pretty academic as I don't think there are many C3's driving on winter roads anymore.
Note that a tuned posi without spring will fail the old mechanics test where you jack the rear up, put it in gear and turn one wheel. The other wheel will turn in reverse indicating a bad posi but it's not bad, it's just what it does without the spring. It needs a load to lock.
Note that a tuned posi without spring will fail the old mechanics test where you jack the rear up, put it in gear and turn one wheel. The other wheel will turn in reverse indicating a bad posi but it's not bad, it's just what it does without the spring. It needs a load to lock.
The following users liked this post:
69L46vert (11-14-2019)
#15
Le Mans Master
OP, do yourself a big favor and listen to GTR1999 who is an expert on these diffs and has not only MANY years of experience tuning them but has done 100's of builds....along the way. I will leave it at that comment............
Last edited by jb78L-82; 11-14-2019 at 06:21 PM.
#16
tuned posi question
Thanks for the feedback. If I was near Ct, I would definitely attend your seminar.
I used 0.055 shim on one side and 0.051 shim on the other, that allowed the crosspin to slide in freely instead of using the same shim thickness on both sides. Is that what you mean be being balanced? Also, when I set up this posi, I didn't debur the 10-17 c-clip spiders I bought from Tom's, does that make a big difference?
I used 0.055 shim on one side and 0.051 shim on the other, that allowed the crosspin to slide in freely instead of using the same shim thickness on both sides. Is that what you mean be being balanced? Also, when I set up this posi, I didn't debur the 10-17 c-clip spiders I bought from Tom's, does that make a big difference?
#17
Tech Contributor
When all is said and done. The cross shaft has to slide freely out of the case with the case in any position. Your shim size sound close but every posi case is machined differently and rarely are the same size shims used in each side. Yes I have had that happen but most times I am grinding shims on my surface grinder. I always radius the spiders and ring & pinion for that matter. 100 turns is not enough by the time I am done with a posi I have put in about 800 revs cw & ccw on both LH and RH sides. There will be no lash in the spiders or endplay in them and they will not bind in rotation, any change of the procedures will result in unsatisfactory operation. Sounds like you have to start over. You are using solid steels and not fiber coat junk so that is good.
#18
Melting Slicks
Member Since: Jul 2010
Location: perth western australia
Posts: 3,098
Received 599 Likes
on
533 Posts
To the O.P , are you sure you cant get the additive ? I can get it from a G.M dealer here (Holden) , Its a car yard that sells brand new cars and their spare parts counter guy looked it up and found 2 types , one you need to wear rubber gloves as it burns skin on contact ! , this was for the newer cars and another was the correct stuff for the old type diffs.
#19
Racer
Member Since: Nov 2019
Location: Canadian living in southern France
Posts: 321
Received 173 Likes
on
79 Posts
Hi Dusky.
It may be a little late, but I live in France and have bought #90 gear oil with the limited slip additive already in it from Direct Lub here in France. They have Dexron and most anything you might need. I also found bottles of limited slip additive on eBay, Ford and Mopar brand, but as far as I know, they're all the same.
It may be a little late, but I live in France and have bought #90 gear oil with the limited slip additive already in it from Direct Lub here in France. They have Dexron and most anything you might need. I also found bottles of limited slip additive on eBay, Ford and Mopar brand, but as far as I know, they're all the same.