Help!! lifters coming apart??
#1
Melting Slicks
Thread Starter
Help!! lifters coming apart??
Two and a half yrs ago I replaced the upper end on my 82 Corvette with Edelbrock heads, cam, rockers, lifters ect. and have about 1000 miles on them. Still the Crossfire setup. So the other day I drove it and noticed a slight lifter noise, came home pulled the valve covers and gave the rockers (Comp roller tip 1.6) a quarter turn and left for work. Today I get the valve covers put back on and as soon as I started it it was very noticeable lifter clatter. I drove it around the block hoping it would go away but did not.
Tonight after work I pulled the valve covers and #4 intake rocker was extremely loose so I pulled the rocker off and the ball end of the pushrod was gone. Ended up pulling the intake and found the pieces but the lifter retaining ring was gone and when I used a magnet to retrieve the lifter it pulled the guts out but was able to remove the whole lifter. After checking the others I noticed #1 exhaust was the same way?? Removed the pushrod and the ball end was still stuck in the rocker and the lifter was also coming apart?? What's causing this??
I found all the pieces except the retaining rings the holds the lifter guts together so I'm assuming it's in the pan. First I need to know why and second what needs to be done? Would the cam still be ok and if the retaining rings are not in the pan then what?
I can post pictures if needed. Please help. Thanks!
Tonight after work I pulled the valve covers and #4 intake rocker was extremely loose so I pulled the rocker off and the ball end of the pushrod was gone. Ended up pulling the intake and found the pieces but the lifter retaining ring was gone and when I used a magnet to retrieve the lifter it pulled the guts out but was able to remove the whole lifter. After checking the others I noticed #1 exhaust was the same way?? Removed the pushrod and the ball end was still stuck in the rocker and the lifter was also coming apart?? What's causing this??
I found all the pieces except the retaining rings the holds the lifter guts together so I'm assuming it's in the pan. First I need to know why and second what needs to be done? Would the cam still be ok and if the retaining rings are not in the pan then what?
I can post pictures if needed. Please help. Thanks!
#2
The why is, you did not upgrade the pushrods to handle the extra lift and spring pressure when you installed heads with the 1.6 rockers.
The snap rings in the pan wont hurt anything.
Replace the lifters and all of the pushrods with good one piece hardened push rods, (not stock) Check your rockers for damage and replaced accordingly. Hopefully this will be all that is screwed up and you will be good to go.
Good luck.
The snap rings in the pan wont hurt anything.
Replace the lifters and all of the pushrods with good one piece hardened push rods, (not stock) Check your rockers for damage and replaced accordingly. Hopefully this will be all that is screwed up and you will be good to go.
Good luck.
Last edited by 76Rat; 02-04-2017 at 10:37 AM. Reason: spelling
#3
Melting Slicks
Thread Starter
The why is, you did not upgrade the pushrods to handle the extra lift and spring pressure when you installed heads with the 1.6 rockers.
The snap rings in the pan wont hurt anything.
Replace the lifters and all of the pushrods with good one piece hardened push rods, (not stock) Check your rockers for damage and replaced accordingly. Hopefully this will be all that is screwed up and you will be good to go.
Good luck.
The snap rings in the pan wont hurt anything.
Replace the lifters and all of the pushrods with good one piece hardened push rods, (not stock) Check your rockers for damage and replaced accordingly. Hopefully this will be all that is screwed up and you will be good to go.
Good luck.
#4
Race Director
Member Since: Apr 2007
Location: South Western Ontario
Posts: 11,061
Received 845 Likes
on
721 Posts
Check the bottom of the lifters. If they are still convex then the cam should be OK. If they are flat or concave then the cam needs to be replaced.
They could have come apart because they didn't have the proper preload.
They could have come apart because they didn't have the proper preload.
#6
Melting Slicks
Thread Starter
The why is, you did not upgrade the pushrods to handle the extra lift and spring pressure when you installed heads with the 1.6 rockers.
The snap rings in the pan wont hurt anything.
Replace the lifters and all of the pushrods with good one piece hardened push rods, (not stock) Check your rockers for damage and replaced accordingly. Hopefully this will be all that is screwed up and you will be good to go.
Good luck.
The snap rings in the pan wont hurt anything.
Replace the lifters and all of the pushrods with good one piece hardened push rods, (not stock) Check your rockers for damage and replaced accordingly. Hopefully this will be all that is screwed up and you will be good to go.
Good luck.
#7
Melting Slicks
Thread Starter
Yep that's what Comp Cams said. Bottom of the lifters are flat but they were when installed. ?
#11
Race Director
Member Since: Jan 2000
Location: Corsicana, Tx
Posts: 12,616
Received 1,877 Likes
on
915 Posts
2020 C2 of the Year - Modified Winner
2020 Corvette of the Year (performance mods)
C2 of Year Winner (performance mods) 2019
2017 C2 of Year Finalist
Those little wire clips in the pan can definitely cause trouble. Most likely they will end up inside the oil pump and lock it up instantly. You need to find them. I've seen it happen more than once over the years.
JIM
JIM
#12
Safety Car
Ended up pulling the intake and found the pieces but the lifter retaining ring was gone and when I used a magnet to retrieve the lifter it pulled the guts out but was able to remove the whole lifter. After checking the others I noticed #1 exhaust was the same way?? Removed the pushrod and the ball end was still stuck in the rocker and the lifter was also coming apart?? What's causing this??
Last edited by CanadaGrant; 02-05-2017 at 12:27 AM.
The following users liked this post:
alconk (02-05-2017)
#13
Pro
I would pull the pan and have a look at everything.
Last edited by cooper9811; 02-05-2017 at 07:43 AM.
#14
Le Mans Master
Member Since: Oct 2002
Location: Las Vegas - Just stop perpetuating myths please.
Posts: 7,098
Received 373 Likes
on
356 Posts
Yes you need to pull the lifters and inspect. But I expect the worse now.
I don't know how to say this w/o insulting you but blindly adding lifter preload tells me you really don't know what can happen to the entire valvetrain when you bottom out the plunger in the lifter. I now suspect you didn't adjust the preload correctly to begin with. Broken push rods and broken lifters blamed on bad parts is possible but usually just an example of denial.
But please prove me wrong and show us pix of the lifters still in convex shape. I can't preach proper methods for setting preload on this forum enough. I'm sure others are just as tired of my rants as I am.
I don't know how to say this w/o insulting you but blindly adding lifter preload tells me you really don't know what can happen to the entire valvetrain when you bottom out the plunger in the lifter. I now suspect you didn't adjust the preload correctly to begin with. Broken push rods and broken lifters blamed on bad parts is possible but usually just an example of denial.
But please prove me wrong and show us pix of the lifters still in convex shape. I can't preach proper methods for setting preload on this forum enough. I'm sure others are just as tired of my rants as I am.
#15
Team Owner
Member Since: Oct 2004
Location: altered state
Posts: 81,242
Received 3,043 Likes
on
2,602 Posts
St. Jude Donor '05
Get some Manleys no more pushrod problems. They make good stuff.
They could have come apart because they didn't have the proper preload.
Sure wish GM made their good flat tappet lifters still.
Last edited by cv67; 02-07-2017 at 06:24 AM.
#16
Melting Slicks
Thread Starter
Yes you need to pull the lifters and inspect. But I expect the worse now.
I don't know how to say this w/o insulting you but blindly adding lifter preload tells me you really don't know what can happen to the entire valvetrain when you bottom out the plunger in the lifter. I now suspect you didn't adjust the preload correctly to begin with. Broken push rods and broken lifters blamed on bad parts is possible but usually just an example of denial.
But please prove me wrong and show us pix of the lifters still in convex shape. I can't preach proper methods for setting preload on this forum enough. I'm sure others are just as tired of my rants as I am.
I don't know how to say this w/o insulting you but blindly adding lifter preload tells me you really don't know what can happen to the entire valvetrain when you bottom out the plunger in the lifter. I now suspect you didn't adjust the preload correctly to begin with. Broken push rods and broken lifters blamed on bad parts is possible but usually just an example of denial.
But please prove me wrong and show us pix of the lifters still in convex shape. I can't preach proper methods for setting preload on this forum enough. I'm sure others are just as tired of my rants as I am.
I spoke with Comp Cams and told me stock pushrods will eventually fail with a aftermarket cam and higher valve springs. When I told him about the lifters he said he wasn't surprised and have seen the same scenario and explained why and made sense to me.
I pulled all of my lifters and they are flat on the bottom with no markings, I asked three different Comp Cam Techs and every one told me they are suppose to be flat. All that happen to the lifter was the retainer spring came out.
Thanks for your input though that's why I post questions.
#17
Melting Slicks
Thread Starter
#18
Melting Slicks
Thread Starter
With the Comp wire type retainers in the lifter, if you get any sort of slack in the setup due to wear or adjustment problems (premature wear in your case) the lack of downward pressure on the pushrod cup will pound out the thin wire retainer in just a few miles. With the lifters adjusted correctly the pushrod cups don't even touch the wire retainers so your lifter retainer failure was caused by pushrod failure. You should check the pan for those retainers or worse, retainer pieces....
#19
Race Director
If the lifters are not slightly convex they will not rotate and take out the cam lobes and likely all the bearings with them in a very short time.