HANS or ???
#1
Safety Car
Thread Starter
HANS or ???
I don't race but regularily do HPDE's at a small local track - Mission Speedway, Seattle - Pacific Raceway and Portland. I have pretty bad degenerative disease in my cervical spine. I put my BMW M3 into the wall at Mission w/o any physical injury but don't want to test my luck again and don't want to give up HPDE's....should I go to a HAN's set-up or would a simple "horse collar" pad be sufficent ????
#3
Safety Car
Thread Starter
Thanks ....of course I do wear a helmet and since I use my street car I also have the airbag for the nose into the wall collision (my BMW wreck was a sliding backwards drivers side slap the wall move concrete dividers 6 in. affair)...given that the HANS role is to keep my skull from sliding off my cervical spine it may not be necessary
#4
Race Director
You might consider this:
http://www.safetysolutionsracing.com...p=587#more-587
The Hutchens or R3 Device does not need a harness or race seat. I saw forum member JDillon wearing his while instructing last weekend in various cars that didn't have a harness system.
The unit straps to your body to provide the foundation for support and uses tethers to your helmet the same as a HANS.
I know I'm considering one for use in my car with the OE 3-point belt.
Bob
http://www.safetysolutionsracing.com...p=587#more-587
The Hutchens or R3 Device does not need a harness or race seat. I saw forum member JDillon wearing his while instructing last weekend in various cars that didn't have a harness system.
The unit straps to your body to provide the foundation for support and uses tethers to your helmet the same as a HANS.
I know I'm considering one for use in my car with the OE 3-point belt.
Bob
Last edited by BEZ06; 04-08-2009 at 04:01 PM. Reason: Corrected spelling of Hutchens
#5
Former Vendor
I don't race but regularily do HPDE's at a small local track - Mission Speedway, Seattle - Pacific Raceway and Portland. I have pretty bad degenerative disease in my cervical spine. I put my BMW M3 into the wall at Mission w/o any physical injury but don't want to test my luck again and don't want to give up HPDE's....should I go to a HAN's set-up or would a simple "horse collar" pad be sufficent ????
I don't mean to insult you, but you must be kidding. You have a degenerative disease in your spine, have already put a car in the wall, and are wondering about a HANS. Put a harness bar in your car, get a race seat, get a set of 5 or 6 point belts, and a HANS with sliding tethers. This is the best money you will ever spend!!!!! Live to tell your grandchildren about your days on the racetrack.
#6
Paul,
I don't mean to insult you, but you must be kidding. You have a degenerative disease in your spine, have already put a car in the wall, and are wondering about a HANS. Put a harness bar in your car, get a race seat, get a set of 5 or 6 point belts, and a HANS with sliding tethers. This is the best money you will ever spend!!!!! Live to tell your grandchildren about your days on the racetrack.
I don't mean to insult you, but you must be kidding. You have a degenerative disease in your spine, have already put a car in the wall, and are wondering about a HANS. Put a harness bar in your car, get a race seat, get a set of 5 or 6 point belts, and a HANS with sliding tethers. This is the best money you will ever spend!!!!! Live to tell your grandchildren about your days on the racetrack.
1- Active Airbags in helmets are not a good idea. Theory goes bag deploys and traps in the eye port and causes damage. So make sure visors are down. Open helmets trap on the bag during deployment and rip your head off. peaks and visors on helmets encourage bags to rip into the eyeport.
2- HANS is most effective in fore aft collisions and effectiveness decreases as the primary or secondary collision is off angle.
3- Therefore, full containment seats and seats with sidenets are a critical part of any safety system.
4- 7pt belts work better than 6 which is better than 5 and rally type ASM 4pts are just not that good at all
1-4 is just a start.
So now how committed to your safety system do you want to be or should you be?
#7
Safety Car
Thread Starter
Paul,
I don't mean to insult you, but you must be kidding. You have a degenerative disease in your spine, have already put a car in the wall, and are wondering about a HANS. Put a harness bar in your car, get a race seat, get a set of 5 or 6 point belts, and a HANS with sliding tethers. This is the best money you will ever spend!!!!! Live to tell your grandchildren about your days on the racetrack.
I don't mean to insult you, but you must be kidding. You have a degenerative disease in your spine, have already put a car in the wall, and are wondering about a HANS. Put a harness bar in your car, get a race seat, get a set of 5 or 6 point belts, and a HANS with sliding tethers. This is the best money you will ever spend!!!!! Live to tell your grandchildren about your days on the racetrack.
My BMW was heavily modded and I had a 4 point harness in place that I could use with the M3 seats. Can the standard seats in a 99 FRC be modded ????...I recall seeing a thread that said the cut-outs for the shoulder straps were already in the seat.
I'm relatively new to this vehicle and see no need for "power mods" , my focus will be handling, braking and safety. If safety can be achieved with modest and less expensive changes then money is available for other purposes
#8
Race Director
No insult taken.....
My BMW was heavily modded and I had a 4 point harness in place that I could use with the M3 seats. Can the standard seats in a 99 FRC be modded ????...I recall seeing a thread that said the cut-outs for the shoulder straps were already in the seat.....
My BMW was heavily modded and I had a 4 point harness in place that I could use with the M3 seats. Can the standard seats in a 99 FRC be modded ????...I recall seeing a thread that said the cut-outs for the shoulder straps were already in the seat.....
Harnesses – Restraints must be the same for driver and passenger. A driver cannot use a harness unless there is an equal one for the passenger. Harnesses must pass through the seat and not around it and be installed as per manufacturers guidelines. Installation accuracy is the responsibility of the student.
However.....some of the groups that sponsor track events have gone even farther and said that if you're using a harness, you must have a race seat that was manufactured with harness pass throughs, and not a modded seat.
So....check with the groups you track with to make sure you comply with their tech requirements.
Bob
#9
Safety Car
Thread Starter
So if we are talking race seats.......I don't race so minimum weight isn't necessary and the car is my daily driver. In addition to swapping wheels, brake pads, and changing fluids will I be swapping out seats as well or can I get a comfortable "race seat" for under $600 ???
#10
Racer
Member Since: Mar 2007
Location: Whiteville NC
Posts: 347
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Skip an HPDE, and buy a real seat with the money that you were gonna spend on that event... hell, after adding in gas, brake pads, and fluids... you're well on your way to a HANS device. I manage to make it to about 2 events per year because of being out of the country for my job, but i still run a proper seat, 6 pt harness, HANS device , 5lb hand held halon extinguisher AND a 10lb car mounted Halon system along with battery cut-off... I also run a multi-point cage . Overkill? Perhaps, but i plan to make it to the "next" event every time.
Oh yeah, forget getting a comfortable dual purpose seat.. takes less than an hour to swap them out before each event.
Horse collar just keeps your neck from getting sore from G-forces as far as i know of... i wouldn't trust my "healthy" neck with one... you already said you have a degenerative issue with yours... Just my opinion.
Oh yeah, forget getting a comfortable dual purpose seat.. takes less than an hour to swap them out before each event.
Horse collar just keeps your neck from getting sore from G-forces as far as i know of... i wouldn't trust my "healthy" neck with one... you already said you have a degenerative issue with yours... Just my opinion.
Last edited by GreyGT-C; 04-08-2009 at 07:39 PM.
#11
Safety Car
Thread Starter
Skip an HPDE, and buy a real seat with the money that you were gonna spend on that event... hell, after adding in gas, brake pads, and fluids... you're well on your way to a HANS device. I manage to make it to about 2 events per year because of being out of the country for my job, but i still run a proper seat, 6 pt harness, HANS device , 5lb hand held halon extinguisher AND a 10lb car mounted Halon system along with battery cut-off... I also run a multi-point cage . Overkill? Perhaps, but i plan to make it to the "next" event every time.
Oh yeah, forget getting a comfortable dual purpose seat.. takes less than an hour to swap them out before each event.
Horse collar just keeps your neck from getting sore from G-forces as far as i know of... i wouldn't trust my "healthy" neck with one... you already said you have a degenerative issue with yours... Just my opinion.
Oh yeah, forget getting a comfortable dual purpose seat.. takes less than an hour to swap them out before each event.
Horse collar just keeps your neck from getting sore from G-forces as far as i know of... i wouldn't trust my "healthy" neck with one... you already said you have a degenerative issue with yours... Just my opinion.
OK...next question which seat ???
#12
Burning Brakes
Member Since: May 2001
Location: Coto de Caza CA
Posts: 1,163
Likes: 0
Received 13 Likes
on
10 Posts
You might consider this:
http://www.safetysolutionsracing.com...p=587#more-587
The Hutchens or R3 Device does not need a harness or race seat. I saw forum member JDillon wearing his while instructing last weekend in various cars that didn't have a harness system.
The unit straps to your body to provide the foundation for support and uses tethers to your helmet the same as a HANS.
I know I'm considering one for use in my car with the OE 3-point belt.
Bob
http://www.safetysolutionsracing.com...p=587#more-587
The Hutchens or R3 Device does not need a harness or race seat. I saw forum member JDillon wearing his while instructing last weekend in various cars that didn't have a harness system.
The unit straps to your body to provide the foundation for support and uses tethers to your helmet the same as a HANS.
I know I'm considering one for use in my car with the OE 3-point belt.
Bob
You can never be to careful
#13
Burning Brakes
Member Since: May 2001
Location: Coto de Caza CA
Posts: 1,163
Likes: 0
Received 13 Likes
on
10 Posts
#14
Race Director
Butt....the car in your picture doesn't look like it sees the street much!
My car is a daily driver GT car that sees many thousands of miles driving around the country every year.
I'll drive 650 miles up to VIR (visiting family along the way) and then 650 back.
Then I'll drive 1,000 miles up to NJMP (and visiting family in Trenton area) then 1,000 back down.
That means I'll be running those events on street rubber, but I'll run a moderately aggressive alignment and some race pads on the track.
Most race seats aren't compatible with the OE restraint belt, and a harness probably doesn't meet DOT/NHTSA requirements or those of many states for driving around on the street. Besides, I like the stock seats!!!
I could probably use a cage, fire supression system, helmet, containment seat, and full nomex body coverage for the street as much as the track, but I'm just not going to put that stuff into a GT road car that just sees a few track events per year.
So....I will probably get an R3 device that will work with my stock 3-point belt to add a degree of protection. I'm just not gonna turn my car into a track only wannabe race car and trailer it around to a few HPDEs per year.
I like the idea of the Corvette as a car that can be driven on the street everyday, driven to the track, thrashed on the track, and then driven home.
Bob
#15
Burning Brakes
Member Since: May 2001
Location: Coto de Caza CA
Posts: 1,163
Likes: 0
Received 13 Likes
on
10 Posts
Yes, you're right!!!
Butt....the car in your picture doesn't look like it sees the street much!
My car is a daily driver GT car that sees many thousands of miles driving around the country every year.
I'll drive 650 miles up to VIR (visiting family along the way) and then 650 back.
Then I'll drive 1,000 miles up to NJMP (and visiting family in Trenton area) then 1,000 back down.
That means I'll be running those events on street rubber, but I'll run a moderately aggressive alignment and some race pads on the track.
Most race seats aren't compatible with the OE restraint belt, and a harness probably doesn't meet DOT/NHTSA requirements or those of many states for driving around on the street. Besides, I like the stock seats!!!
I could probably use a cage, fire supression system, helmet, containment seat, and full nomex body coverage for the street as much as the track, but I'm just not going to put that stuff into a GT road car that just sees a few track events per year.
So....I will probably get an R3 device that will work with my stock 3-point belt to add a degree of protection. I'm just not gonna turn my car into a track only wannabe race car and trailer it around to a few HPDEs per year.
I like the idea of the Corvette as a car that can be driven on the street everyday, driven to the track, thrashed on the track, and then driven home.
Bob
Butt....the car in your picture doesn't look like it sees the street much!
My car is a daily driver GT car that sees many thousands of miles driving around the country every year.
I'll drive 650 miles up to VIR (visiting family along the way) and then 650 back.
Then I'll drive 1,000 miles up to NJMP (and visiting family in Trenton area) then 1,000 back down.
That means I'll be running those events on street rubber, but I'll run a moderately aggressive alignment and some race pads on the track.
Most race seats aren't compatible with the OE restraint belt, and a harness probably doesn't meet DOT/NHTSA requirements or those of many states for driving around on the street. Besides, I like the stock seats!!!
I could probably use a cage, fire supression system, helmet, containment seat, and full nomex body coverage for the street as much as the track, but I'm just not going to put that stuff into a GT road car that just sees a few track events per year.
So....I will probably get an R3 device that will work with my stock 3-point belt to add a degree of protection. I'm just not gonna turn my car into a track only wannabe race car and trailer it around to a few HPDEs per year.
I like the idea of the Corvette as a car that can be driven on the street everyday, driven to the track, thrashed on the track, and then driven home.
Bob
#16
Race Director
You're gonna end up talking me into doing more than I ever wanted to do!!!
This thread reminds me of the cowboy after OSHA regulations:
Bob
#17
Wow, a 4 pt? From what I understand that is next to useless and more dangerous that the factory three point. A five point is just nuts - you will end up with two lumps in the back of your throat Most folks suggest a six-point since you have the anti-sub and, in a wreck, the leg straps will keep the lap-belt low and tight across your pelvis rather than you soft squishy innards.
If the restraints are not mounted properly they are probably more dangerous than the stock 3 pt. It always amazes me how many folks spend crazy cash on modding their cars but skimp on safety. Like the folks above said, get a good seat first, then build your restraint system around that. A cage is even better - I am saving for one of those.
If the restraints are not mounted properly they are probably more dangerous than the stock 3 pt. It always amazes me how many folks spend crazy cash on modding their cars but skimp on safety. Like the folks above said, get a good seat first, then build your restraint system around that. A cage is even better - I am saving for one of those.
#18
Melting Slicks
Question on sizing
I'm a 17" neck ( with no plans to go larger since I stopped using steroids )
web site lists the following
Large at 16" to 20"
medium at 13.5" to 17"
I'm 6 ' 185-190 lbs. I'm leaning towards a large, btu I like my performance gear to fit snug ( I.E. SkI Boots)
Any suggestions guys?
web site lists the following
Large at 16" to 20"
medium at 13.5" to 17"
I'm 6 ' 185-190 lbs. I'm leaning towards a large, btu I like my performance gear to fit snug ( I.E. SkI Boots)
Any suggestions guys?
#19
Le Mans Master
Wow, a 4 pt? From what I understand that is next to useless and more dangerous that the factory three point. A five point is just nuts - you will end up with two lumps in the back of your throat Most folks suggest a six-point since you have the anti-sub and, in a wreck, the leg straps will keep the lap-belt low and tight across your pelvis rather than you soft squishy innards.
If the restraints are not mounted properly they are probably more dangerous than the stock 3 pt. It always amazes me how many folks spend crazy cash on modding their cars but skimp on safety. Like the folks above said, get a good seat first, then build your restraint system around that. A cage is even better - I am saving for one of those.
If the restraints are not mounted properly they are probably more dangerous than the stock 3 pt. It always amazes me how many folks spend crazy cash on modding their cars but skimp on safety. Like the folks above said, get a good seat first, then build your restraint system around that. A cage is even better - I am saving for one of those.
#20
Racer
Member Since: Mar 2007
Location: Whiteville NC
Posts: 347
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
a properly installed 5 will never allow the anti-sub belt to touch your special place in a wreck. It's to keep the lapbelts from riding up your body which prevents you from sliding down and under them in a wreck.