When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.
Accessory loss - unless your using lots of DC it should be minimal. Power steering is minimal down the drag strip or on the dyno. The water pump would be a drain, but I can't imagine more than a few HP, I would think using a lawn mower engine to run it would be overkill. Friction from the belts, now were splitting hairs.
How much do you guys think the accessories rob assuming minimal load on them? Again I would think a 5hp lawn mower engine would be enough to power everything.
From: Who says "Nothing is impossible" ? I've been doing nothing for years.
Originally Posted by 71CanAm
This percentage stuff has me wondering. I would say the HP loss through an Auto is static. I mean if I have a 500 HP motor and it loses 100 HP at the tranny then if I have a 1000 HP motor wouldn't the tranny still only eat 100 HP? Why would it now be a 200 HP slippage?
The tranny doesn't change. It's still has the same slippage...
Again we get back to heat and acceleration. If it takes a 500HP say 10 seconds to go from 3000RPM to 6000RPM on a chassis dyno the forces on the on the automatic and rotating parts are going to be X and Y amount of heat is generated.
f you put a 1000HP motor in the same car then this motor will spin the drum from 3000 to 6000RPM in say 6 seconds. More stress is put on the tranny and all rotating parts, X + ? therefore more heat is going to be generated Y + ? creating a greater loss in HP but essentially the same percentage HP is lost with the 1000HP as the 500HP motor.
But like I said, I don't think the percentage is perfectly linear either as you might lose a smaller percentage as the HP goes up.
I am not a mechanical engineer, these are just my own ideas, but it would be interesting to hear from a mechanical engineer if any of this makes any sense
Accessory loss - unless your using lots of DC it should be minimal. Power steering is minimal down the drag strip or on the dyno. The water pump would be a drain, but I can't imagine more than a few HP, I would think using a lawn mower engine to run it would be overkill. Friction from the belts, now were splitting hairs.
How much do you guys think the accessories rob assuming minimal load on them? Again I would think a 5hp lawn mower engine would be enough to power everything.
Really? I picked up 12 RWHP just be eliminating the mechanical fan..
Electric fuel pump and water pump will get you another 5 - 7 HP. Removing mufflers and running straight pipes with large tube headers can give you well over 30 HP...
On a 450 HP engine.. parasitic accessory loss can be EASILY 45++ RWHP!! That's 10%!! The exhaust is the biggest accessory loss!! If you are running stock exhaust manifolds and exhaust, you will be dropping OVER 40 HP on a 450+ HP engine!! I've spent plenty of time at dyno shops and I've seen a lot of before/after pulls and accessories (especially exhaust and mechanical fans) will cost you A LOT of power! That is a fact!!
Last edited by GrandSportC3; Nov 24, 2006 at 10:16 PM.
Again we get back to heat and acceleration. If it takes a 500HP say 10 seconds to go from 3000RPM to 6000RPM on a chassis dyno the forces on the on the automatic and rotating parts are going to be X and Y amount of heat is generated.
f you put a 1000HP motor in the same car then this motor will spin the drum from 3000 to 6000RPM in say 6 seconds. More stress is put on the tranny and all rotating parts, X + ? therefore more heat is going to be generated Y + ? creating a greater loss in HP but essentially the same percentage HP is lost with the 1000HP as the 500HP motor.
But like I said, I don't think the percentage is perfectly linear either as you might lose a smaller percentage as the HP goes up.
I am not a mechanical engineer, these are just my own ideas, but it would be interesting to hear from a mechanical engineer if any of this makes any sense
I am am mechanical engineer. You are almost exactly right. The primary heat generation in the fluid. ie shearing the fluid is linear with the acceleration. The faster you change speed the more power you lose.
Bearing and gear loses are also a function of the pressure applied to them more HP puts more force on the gears. I'm pretty sure that its linear also, but I would have to look it up. Its been a while since I've done gear computations. Bearing losses are a function of the pressure on the bearing, speed of rotation, and the acceleration
How much do you guys think the accessories rob assuming minimal load on them? Again I would think a 5hp lawn mower engine would be enough to power everything.
From what I've read, the water pump alone is about 12 - 15 hp. All together, you're probably losing 20hp. More if you have one of those fancy A/Cs hooked up!
From what I've read, the water pump alone is about 12 - 15 hp. All together, you're probably losing 20hp. More if you have one of those fancy A/Cs hooked up!
All those accessories cost you power but the main power loss occurs in the exhaust! A high performance engine likes to breethe and it it's choked with a restrictive exhaust will cost you SIGNIFICANT horsepower compared to flywheel dyno numbers on a crate engine. On one of my previos Vettes, I went from stock exhaust to open sidepipes.. It was UNBELIEVABLE how much power I gained.. Felt like I added a 50 shot of nitrous!
From: All humans are vermin in the eyes of Guru VA
Cruise-In IV Veteran
Cruise-In V Veteran
Oliver,
You should look into a burns stainless merge collector. They design them with a venturi to increase power. Their not cheap but if your looking for more power its another place to look.
Really? I picked up 12 RWHP just be eliminating the mechanical fan..
Electric fuel pump and water pump will get you another 5 - 7 HP. Removing mufflers and running straight pipes with large tube headers can give you well over 30 HP...
On a 450 HP engine.. parasitic accessory loss can be EASILY 45++ RWHP!! That's 10%!! The exhaust is the biggest accessory loss!! If you are running stock exhaust manifolds and exhaust, you will be dropping OVER 40 HP on a 450+ HP engine!! I've spent plenty of time at dyno shops and I've seen a lot of before/after pulls and accessories (especially exhaust and mechanical fans) will cost you A LOT of power! That is a fact!!
OK, I'm convinced, I try not to make it a habit of arguing with reality.
Open 4" exhaust, M-21, Frankland Rear end, all electrical except alt. and 1 fuel pump, dry sump pump, we are losing 9-10% as measured on an engine dyno vs. chassis dyno.
Last edited by 73-84 IMSA Widebody; Nov 25, 2006 at 01:02 PM.
Designer Imagines A Corvette That Looks More Like a Corvette Than the Corvette
Slideshow: A Jaguar designer's personal project imagines what a modern front-engined Corvette might look like if Chevrolet revisited the golden age of the Stingray.