TH400 2nd Grear Shift Problem
I checked fluid level and it was right on the money.
Took it out again and same thing but eventually it shifted into 3rd OK. 2nd seemed to be slipping. Then I took it out on road and gave it some gas and it shifted fine through all the gears but when I got back into neighborhood at low speeds it didn't want to go into 2nd again ... just slips with engine rev's but doesn't want to hook up. I did hear some squealing noise which I think came from tranny. Didn't sound good.
In the process of solving some of the leaks I had, I've dropped the pan several times. Changed the filter & fluid the 1st time and then just added new fluid after that. Never had a problem before but I'm wondering if the tranny fluid which was supposed to be compatible with Dextron II could be the issue.
Any thoughts on what to start checking?
dugsgms74 ... thanks for input ... I hope it's not the sprag or anything internal but the symptoms you described does sound like what I experienced today. If checking vacuum line & modulator doesn't turn up anything and I don't get anything else that's easy to check I may need to start looking for a good repair shop.
The Best of Corvette for Corvette Enthusiasts
Good luck
I don't hear the kickdown switch clicking when depressing accelerator to floor with ignition switch on. If it's not working would this have anything to do with normal driving?
This coming week I'll try to actually check the amount of vacuum at Modulator and check for a switch under dash to see what's up with that.
It rained a lot last week so I didn't take the Vette for a spin until today but I got some different symptoms today .... ARGH
Last time it was 2nd gear that was slipping under light throttle. Today reverse was fine but it started slipping right away when I put it into Drive (3rd), to start driving. When I manually shift it ... it seemed to shift fine but wanted to delay and get to a higher speed/rpm before it shifted. When I decelerate or down shift it manually, I can feel the engine braking in all gears.
Since I only fooled with the vacuum lines and orientation of the Modulator since the last test drive, I'm getting very suspicious of Modulator or vacuum.
Any more advice from what I found?
How does the Trans fluid look/smell?
How does the Trans fluid look/smell?
He can try every guess fix and maybe get lucky but my money is with a rebuild.
Easiest thing to check, just reach up on the driver side of the Trans and unplug the kickdown solenoid, go for a drive.. You'll know by the end of your street if that is the problem or not.. If this doesn't fix it, it's likely an internal issue... Just check all the easy stuff first.
Not saying his trans isn't smoked but....I'd check this first.
pull that wire. You'll have normal up shifts but no kick down unless you do it manually. The modulator usually will give you a warning before it goes completely. A tell tail sign is getting it up to 30mph in first and let off the gas and it will grab 3rd gear. Sometimes if you play with the gas pedal or up shift manually it will pop into 2nd. Checking the diaphragm is good but a modulator is very cheap and it's 1 bolt to change it. Most guys don't even mess with it and just replace it.
Today I checked the amount of vacuum at manifold and at both ends of the steel line that runs from a tee at manifold to the modulator ... it was 12" at all places. Article I had said it should be 20" but I've got an LT-1 engine from a 70 Vette so I'm thinking the 12" is about right. I also pulled 20" of vacuum on the modulator and it held rock solid and didn't loose any vacuum.
Then I pulled that wire on drivers side of transmission and took it for a drive ... just got back and no change from previous symptoms when I let it shift automatically. When I manually shift it ... it drives fine except for the delay in shifting ... maybe 3 or 4 seconds to shift from 1st to 2nd and from 2nd to 3rd. It really bugs me that it doesn't have any slipping issues when out on the road ... just at low speeds i.e. 30 & under and also when I start out with shifter in 3rd (auto).
The symptoms dugsgms74 posted in his reply is the closest to what I'm experiencing ... he said it was a bad sprag in his case. If I can figure out how to get a new modulator (the right one ... I'm not sure this one is stock as the tranny has a shift kit in it), I'll try that as a last resort before planning to get it rebuilt.
Thanks again for all the ideas!
I'm getting close to pulling it!I ordered a new modulator and that will be the last thing I’ll try before pulling it, if that doesn’t fix it. Since my last post I found a ’74 Service Manual and it actually lists some of what I’ve been experiencing as being associated with a bad modulator. I figure I might as well try everything external that I can first.
1974 Chevrolet Service Manual info.:
A defective vacuum modulator can cause one or more of the following complaints.
· Harsh upshifts and downshifts (Don’t have this symptom.)
· Delayed upshifts (I have this symptom.)
· Soft upshifts and downshifts (Don’t have this symptom.)
· Slips in low, drive and reverse (Have had slip in low & 2nd)
· Transmission overheating (No signs of this)
· Engine burning transmission fluid (No signs of this)
While waiting for the new modulator, I hooked a volt meter up to the wire that connects to the right side of transmission for the internal kick-down solenoid. I turned the ignition switch to run position and meter read 0v. I figured that at least means tranny issn’t stuck in the gear kick-down mode all the time. I depressed accelerator pedal and still nothing on meter. I think that means either a bad or mis-adjusted kick-down switch under the dash on gas pedal, a blown fuse or a broken wire somewhere along the line.
I can’t find a kick-down relay listed in any auto parts stores and so far I can’t find anything in the wiring diagrams from a Chevy ‘74 Service Manual about the Kick-down circuit at all.
Does anyone know if the wire at transmission supplies 12 volts directly from kick-down switch or if the switch engages a relay somewhere that might also be the problem with no signal at tranny?
ajrothm … BTW … fluid looks perfect with no smell or indication of being burnt.
Also got the new modulator and installed it today but no change in drivability.

Looks like diehrd & others that thought it needed an overhaul were right so I’m working on finding a reliable place to get it overhauled … wish me luck on that.
If possible I’ll pull it myself and let someone else rebuild it. Not in any rush at this time of year but I’ll update this thread after I get to check out the results of rebuild.
Thanks again for everyone’s input … I now know more about the TH400 than I knew when I started this thread.














