When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.
I find the shifter to be quick clunky and notchy compared to most other manuals I have driven, this transmission also seems to have a personality all its own. Anyone care to chime in?
The ZF is an unique animal. It is noisy, and the stock shifter is weird. The ZF is one strong son-of-a-gun, change the oil with motor oil 5W30 or Amsoil Synchromesh, and it will serve you for a long time.
I find the shifter to be quick clunky and notchy compared to most other manuals I have driven, this transmission also seems to have a personality all its own. Anyone care to chime in?
Sure. My ZF shifts better than any manual trans car I've owned, except for an Integra. If you're having issues, I'd be checking the hydraulic clutch linkage, and changing the oil.
Sure. My ZF shifts better than any manual trans car I've owned, except for an Integra. If you're having issues, I'd be checking the hydraulic clutch linkage, and changing the oil.
Agreed. Check the fluid level. You'll have to lift the ecm to get to the resevior, also check color. If it's black, you should change it. Bleeding is a pain, or you could use the 'ranger' method.
The slave cylinders in these cars won't last forever, and this could be the cause of notchy shifting as well. The last slave I bought I got from NAPA and it help up better the previous two from Advanced Auto. But i wouldn't change it unless it's leaking.
Another possibility is the pivot stud for the clutch fork could be wearing out. These tend to groove on the sides and will cause the fork to hyper-extend, may nit be getting a full clutch release.
Worst case is bad synchros.
I would start with new hydraulic fluid and new oil in the trans. Amsoil Synchromesh was my favorite.
The shifter may have an overly mechanical feel and be audibly clunky, but should shift up and down like butter when the trans oil is warm.
As others said check the clutch hydraulics and maybe the oil. I am also in the Amsoil camp as they sell a 5w-30 equivalent viscosity replacement oil (the synchromesh oil). I understand the original oil fill was of the same weight.
Others like the BMW 10w-60 oil as ZF recommended it when the GM oil became no-longer-available from the dealer. I found the 10w-60 took a lot longer to warm up and was sensitive to being notchy going into 3rd unless you really really pushed the clutch to the floor and shifted at exactly the right time (the synchros didn't work as fast basically). The upside is the heavier oil will probably last a little longer before it would need to be changed, but the Amsoil feels like stock (I've driven a few of these cars and know what they should feel like).
Last edited by mike100; Apr 13, 2015 at 10:03 AM.
Reason: typos
Yeah I agree. I would check the hydraulics out on it and see if they are good to go. Then service the fluid; the Castrol BMW oil is trick oil but in my opinion not the oil you want in the ZF S640....especially if it's cold outside...ask me how I know...lol Just my .02
I find the shifter to be quick clunky and notchy compared to most other manuals I have driven, this transmission also seems to have a personality all its own. Anyone care to chime in?
Don't forget about CAGS one-to-four forced shift if you're driving it wrong !! Be Well !!
I find the shifter to be quick clunky and notchy compared to most other manuals I have driven.
Strange that you would say "Quick" and "Notchy". When my ZF had the "Stock" shifter, it was a very long throw, but was smooth as anything and definitely NOT notchy. After I changed the shifter to a B&M, THEN it bacame very short throw "Quick" and notchy where I could very distinctly feel each detent as I go into the next gear. I like it short and quick like that, but it definitely isn't what you'd call smooth. It's a very "CLICK-CLICK"notchy going through neutral to the next gear.
Are you sure you don't have an aftermarket shifter or do you know it is the original still in there?
The ZF is an unique animal. It is noisy, and the stock shifter is weird. The ZF is one strong son-of-a-gun, change the oil with motor oil 5W30 or Amsoil Synchromesh, and it will serve you for a long time.
I can use just plain old 5w30? I have access to a ton of it for free. Maybe this is the easiest route to take first, before I start dropping dollars at something that may not make a differece.
And yes it has a very long throw, I really only feel the pass through "gate" into 3rd, everything else feels normal its just a very long throw and like I said feels kinda clunky, not like a little honda shifter thats like butter.
I can use just plain old 5w30? I have access to a ton of it for free. Maybe this is the easiest route to take first, before I start dropping dollars at something that may not make a differece.
And yes it has a very long throw, I really only feel the pass through "gate" into 3rd, everything else feels normal its just a very long throw and like I said feels kinda clunky, not like a little honda shifter thats like butter.
No, it has to be a transmission grade oil because you need the additive for the synchros. It isn't like Honda lube where you just pour in $2 10w-40. A lot of parts stores carry GM Synchromesh for $8-$10 a qt. you might try that, otherwise using the Amsoil or BMW oil is gonna cost you $50. it takes 2.2 qts so you have to buy 3 bottles.
A lot of parts stores carry GM Synchromesh for $8-$10 a qt. you might try that, otherwise using the Amsoil or BMW oil is gonna cost you $50. it takes 2.2 qts so you have to buy 3 bottles.
How much does AMSoil cost there? it's about $10 per quart here.
No problem, I can get AMSOIL for about 10 a quart or I can get the GM Synchromesh for around the same price. I always was a believer that new oil is always better than old.
When I bought my 1991, the trans was very notchy/clunky. I changed to fresh oil and things got much better. When the engine was out, we converted it to crash through and put a hurst shifter in it and refilled it with synchromesh. Now it's much closer to what I expected it to be in the first place. The shorter shifter feels less clunky than the original did with old oil in it (or I'm guessing it was old oil, I don't know for sure).
How much does AMSoil cost there? it's about $10 per quart here.
I think I paid $11-12-ish per bottle, but I had to pay for shipping for 3 bottles and probably the job cost around $40. Probably I got confused with my truck and mustang which use a little more oil... I'm using 4 qts Amsoil in my OBS(old body style) F-150 to replace the mercron atf that was the original fill.
I'm actually curious to try the GM Synchromesh because the Carquest franchise down the street stocks it and I bet I can get them for $9 a bottle. I only have 10k miles on this Amsoil lube though so I'm gonna go another year or two on it.
No problem, I can get AMSOIL for about 10 a quart or I can get the GM Synchromesh for around the same price. I always was a believer that new oil is always better than old.
you won't get too much argument on that philosophy.
One other thing I forgot to mention is sometimes it wont go into first unless I depress the clutch all the way and let it out a tiny bit, I can feel it go into first, same thing with reverse sometimes. Doesnt always happen just here and there.
One other thing I forgot to mention is sometimes it wont go into first unless I depress the clutch all the way and let it out a tiny bit, I can feel it go into first, same thing with reverse sometimes. Doesnt always happen just here and there.
Mine will do that every once in a while mostly for reverse. I just bump any other gear first and then it will go right in. I think it lines up the synchros on the gear shaft and lets things slide together better.
Mine will do that every once in a while mostly for reverse. I just bump any other gear first and then it will go right in. I think it lines up the synchros on the gear shaft and lets things slide together better.
Yeah I have noticed you really need to shift into 2nd to get into first if your at a light, and if you are rolling and try to put it into first it will make a god awful crunch sometimes, never had that issue before this car.
[QUOTE=lt4obsesses;1589404545]Agreed. Check the fluid level. You'll have to lift the ecm to get to the resevior, also check color. If it's black, you should change it. Bleeding is a pain, or you could use the 'ranger' method.
By far the easiest way is the 'reverse bleed' method, I did mine in a matter of minutes, you have to get under there anyway, so you might as well pump it in through the slave, guaranteed no air bubbles! why push the air down through the system when it wants to rise naturally..