Did my new battery maintainer ruin my battery
#1
Safety Car
Thread Starter
Did my new battery maintainer ruin my battery
Just bought a Schumacher SP2 battery extender/maintainer.......connected to my battery, which was low and in need of charging.......three hours later I read the instruction manual and found this:
Maintaining a Battery
The Schumacher SP2 is a battery maintainer that maintains both 6 and 12 volt batteries, keeping them at full charge. It can charge small batteries and maintain both small and large batteries. If you are maintaining a fully charged large battery, you are properly utilizing the battery charger. However, if you use the battery charger to charge a large battery, such as a marine deep cycle battery, that was not fully charged, you may lose some of the battery’s capacity. This would cause the large battery to be unable to hold a charge and become useless. Therefore, we do not recommend charging a large battery with this unit.
WTF you can ruin a battery by connecting a maintainer to it when it is not fully charged!!!
BTW the manual defines a "Large battery" as a normal size car battery, not just a deep cycle battery
Maintaining a Battery
The Schumacher SP2 is a battery maintainer that maintains both 6 and 12 volt batteries, keeping them at full charge. It can charge small batteries and maintain both small and large batteries. If you are maintaining a fully charged large battery, you are properly utilizing the battery charger. However, if you use the battery charger to charge a large battery, such as a marine deep cycle battery, that was not fully charged, you may lose some of the battery’s capacity. This would cause the large battery to be unable to hold a charge and become useless. Therefore, we do not recommend charging a large battery with this unit.
WTF you can ruin a battery by connecting a maintainer to it when it is not fully charged!!!
BTW the manual defines a "Large battery" as a normal size car battery, not just a deep cycle battery
#2
Race Director
A car battery is not considered a "large" battery. Have you ever seen a 100lb marine battery? That is a large battery.
#3
Safety Car
Thread Starter
#4
Generally speaking, for the health of the battery, you want to charge it as slowly as possible. I wouldn't think that a maintainer would be able to throw enough current to your battery to cook it, but you never know.
I always use the small/slow charge option unless it absolutely won't take a charge that way. If it won't I may kick it up a notch to get it started then back it back down, although if it won't accept the slow charge that is generally a symptom of a battery that is starting to go south.
I know that an alternator is not designed to charge a discharged battery, rather just maintain one. As such if you try to charge a "dead" battery with your alternator you may burn up the alternator. It's a matter of the battery trying to demand more than the alternator can put out. In your case, however, it would seem like even if the battery wanted more than the charger could put out that it would be the charger that would be in danger, not the battery. Maybe a battery expert knows, I certainly don't!
I always use the small/slow charge option unless it absolutely won't take a charge that way. If it won't I may kick it up a notch to get it started then back it back down, although if it won't accept the slow charge that is generally a symptom of a battery that is starting to go south.
I know that an alternator is not designed to charge a discharged battery, rather just maintain one. As such if you try to charge a "dead" battery with your alternator you may burn up the alternator. It's a matter of the battery trying to demand more than the alternator can put out. In your case, however, it would seem like even if the battery wanted more than the charger could put out that it would be the charger that would be in danger, not the battery. Maybe a battery expert knows, I certainly don't!
#5
Le Mans Master
I have used a Schumacher maintainer to charge mine quite a few times. It may take it a day to bring it up to full charge, but it has worked fine. No damage to the battery.
Not only didn't they damage the battery, but my maintainer has a desulfation mode that has improved a nearly dead battery that wouldn't hold a charge very well.
Not only didn't they damage the battery, but my maintainer has a desulfation mode that has improved a nearly dead battery that wouldn't hold a charge very well.
#6
Advanced
I agree with Nathan. I have always been told that it is better to slow charge a battery than rapid charge to maintain the life of the battery. I have an Optima Battery in my car and have a Battery Tender on it all winter. I am in the garage every weekend that I can get there and doing something to it that is requiring the hood and/or doors open for hours at a time. Although many people have had less than favorable opinions on the Optima brand I have had it for 4 years now and it has always been juiced up and ready to go when I turn the key.
I would my opinion that someone at sometime had an issue charging a large marine style battery and this was included with the paperwork to release them of any future liability.
I would my opinion that someone at sometime had an issue charging a large marine style battery and this was included with the paperwork to release them of any future liability.
#7
Melting Slicks
Member Since: Sep 2008
Location: Cherokee National Forest TN
Posts: 2,376
Likes: 0
Received 102 Likes
on
92 Posts
I have used a Schumacher maintainer to charge mine quite a few times. It may take it a day to bring it up to full charge, but it has worked fine. No damage to the battery.
Not only didn't they damage the battery, but my maintainer has a desulfation mode that has improved a nearly dead battery that wouldn't hold a charge very well.
Not only didn't they damage the battery, but my maintainer has a desulfation mode that has improved a nearly dead battery that wouldn't hold a charge very well.
Best little charger/maintainer I ever purchased. Cost (IIRC) was around 30bux at WallyW orld.
#8
Safety Car
Thread Starter
So I called the Schumacher Tech line......
1) The SP2 Maintainer I bought is rated 1 amp and is NOT reccommended for Corvettes because there is a continous current draw on the battery when the car is just sitting. I should have bought a maintainer with a 2 or 3 amp rating.
2) The lady I spoke with was very critical of the Owner's Manual and stated it should not have said what it said.
3) The Model SP2 is in a package labeled "Battery Extender...Maintainer". In fact all Maintainers are Extenders.....nothing different about this unit regarding being an Extender
4) You do get the longest life out of a battery by keeping it fully charged.
BTW I have been using a Schumacher 6 amp Automatic battery charger that is at least 25 years old...no microprocesser technology...I put it on the battery maybe once a month during the winter. I am only on my second battery, still good, in the almost 16 years I have owned my 96. So not sure what I am going to do except the unit I bought is going back for a refund.
1) The SP2 Maintainer I bought is rated 1 amp and is NOT reccommended for Corvettes because there is a continous current draw on the battery when the car is just sitting. I should have bought a maintainer with a 2 or 3 amp rating.
2) The lady I spoke with was very critical of the Owner's Manual and stated it should not have said what it said.
3) The Model SP2 is in a package labeled "Battery Extender...Maintainer". In fact all Maintainers are Extenders.....nothing different about this unit regarding being an Extender
4) You do get the longest life out of a battery by keeping it fully charged.
BTW I have been using a Schumacher 6 amp Automatic battery charger that is at least 25 years old...no microprocesser technology...I put it on the battery maybe once a month during the winter. I am only on my second battery, still good, in the almost 16 years I have owned my 96. So not sure what I am going to do except the unit I bought is going back for a refund.
#9
So I called the Schumacher Tech line......
1) The SP2 Maintainer I bought is rated 1 amp and is NOT reccommended for Corvettes because there is a continous current draw on the battery when the car is just sitting. I should have bought a maintainer with a 2 or 3 amp rating.
1) The SP2 Maintainer I bought is rated 1 amp and is NOT reccommended for Corvettes because there is a continous current draw on the battery when the car is just sitting. I should have bought a maintainer with a 2 or 3 amp rating.
#10
Safety Car
Thread Starter
Well I can tell you that much is BS. ANY modern car, not just Corvettes does have a power draw on the battery even when it's not running but I promise you it's in the milliamp range, IE 1/1000th of an amp. If you put a steady 1 amp draw on a car battery it would be dead VERY shortly. If your car has so much draw that a 1 amp charger can't still maintain it, then you have something wrong with your car.
....and I sure would not want a manual out there saying things my "tech rep" could not support
#11
Burning Brakes
Member Since: Dec 2008
Location: Morgan Hill and Marina California
Posts: 1,021
Likes: 0
Received 6 Likes
on
5 Posts
FWIW, my '87 has been on a Schumacher for many years. IIRC, the
prior battery lasted 11 years. And the current battery is getting close
to that.
But these "battery tenders" are designed to keep a battery charged,
not to recharge a dead battery.
Chuck
prior battery lasted 11 years. And the current battery is getting close
to that.
But these "battery tenders" are designed to keep a battery charged,
not to recharge a dead battery.
Chuck
#12
Race Director
Honestly I was not very impressed with the gal I talked with.......perhaps a tech rep in training, but not the person I would have wanted representing my company...but that is what she said
....and I sure would not want a manual out there saying things my "tech rep" could not support
....and I sure would not want a manual out there saying things my "tech rep" could not support
#13
Well at my company in tech service we've got a chick who is every bit as good as any of the guys in the department, although I admit that is the rarity.
One of the parts stores in town has the best 2 guys of any of the stores but the worst girl of any. I cringe when I go in there and she is behind the counter. When I walk in there and she asks "can I help you?" My first thought is always "I seriously doubt it."
One of the parts stores in town has the best 2 guys of any of the stores but the worst girl of any. I cringe when I go in there and she is behind the counter. When I walk in there and she asks "can I help you?" My first thought is always "I seriously doubt it."
#15
Safety Car
Thread Starter
what I was shocked about was the statement in the manual that putting this maintainer on a low battery could ruin it!!
I would not have expected that......I would have expected a very long time to charge a low battery, not ruin it!!