idea for 85-87 ac compressor extra brace location, thoughts?
#1
Oil Producer
Thread Starter
idea for 85-87 ac compressor extra brace location, thoughts?
need slightly longer head bolt possibly longer ac bolt. get tube stock and crush ends flat and drill holes through. ive had two broken ac compressor brackets.
#2
Team Owner
Member Since: Sep 2001
Location: Athens AL
Posts: 59,663
Received 1,401 Likes
on
1,017 Posts
C7 of the Year - Unmodified Finalist 2021
C4 of Year Finalist (performance mods) 2019
In addition to the rear that goes to the exhaust manifold, yes that might work.
I never cracked my 86's mounting, only the 88s, the real fix though is the whole bracket being made out of something besides the cheap pot metal they used.
I never cracked my 86's mounting, only the 88s, the real fix though is the whole bracket being made out of something besides the cheap pot metal they used.
#3
Oil Producer
Thread Starter
i figured it was aluminum. was going to grind a v out and mig weld aluminium then grind down on one of my broken ones. if its pot metal that may not be effective
#4
there is a single brace that connects to the forward most RH exhaust manifold mounting hex-stud. the other end of the brace connects to the outer-right bracket/compressor mounting bolt (#6). if properly installed, no additional bracing is needed.
and , they are aluminum. one thing I might add - I modified my bracket so the one bolt (#7 in the diagram) that comes in from the rear is now reversed. it will make any future compressor removal a bit easier --
edit - let me add this when I say "properly installed." i'm thinking it's all about the sequence of events. I've spend some time trying to visualize how the AC mounting bracket and compressor was installed at the bowling green assembly line. the best I figure, the compressor was first set in the bracket with two bolts, #6 and #7, along with the exhaust manifold brace, and installed in finger snug. since bolt #7 comes in from the rear, I doubt the assembly line removed the RH valve cover on an already completed engine assembly to install that bolt, so the bracket and compressor had to be mated prior to installation on the engine. the bracket/compressor was fitted to the engine with the two nuts to the water pump studs, along with the lower compressor mounting bolt (that funny hex bolt with the torx recess). the exhaust manifold brace, fitted with bolt #6, was now fitted to the exhaust manifold stud - finger snug. with everything properly positioned, the lower mounting bolt and the two water pump nuts were now evenly torqued to spec. this should minimize any stress on the bracket. next, the #6 and #7 bolts were now torqued, and finally, the exhaust manifold nut was tightened and torqued. tightening the water pump nuts and the lower mounting bolt first should minimize any external stresses on the AC bracket. the final tightening on the exhaust manifold nut should stabilize the assembly without adding any additional stress to the bracket assembly. finally, the belt tensioner was installed.
any manufacturing engineers out there - comments?
and , they are aluminum. one thing I might add - I modified my bracket so the one bolt (#7 in the diagram) that comes in from the rear is now reversed. it will make any future compressor removal a bit easier --
edit - let me add this when I say "properly installed." i'm thinking it's all about the sequence of events. I've spend some time trying to visualize how the AC mounting bracket and compressor was installed at the bowling green assembly line. the best I figure, the compressor was first set in the bracket with two bolts, #6 and #7, along with the exhaust manifold brace, and installed in finger snug. since bolt #7 comes in from the rear, I doubt the assembly line removed the RH valve cover on an already completed engine assembly to install that bolt, so the bracket and compressor had to be mated prior to installation on the engine. the bracket/compressor was fitted to the engine with the two nuts to the water pump studs, along with the lower compressor mounting bolt (that funny hex bolt with the torx recess). the exhaust manifold brace, fitted with bolt #6, was now fitted to the exhaust manifold stud - finger snug. with everything properly positioned, the lower mounting bolt and the two water pump nuts were now evenly torqued to spec. this should minimize any stress on the bracket. next, the #6 and #7 bolts were now torqued, and finally, the exhaust manifold nut was tightened and torqued. tightening the water pump nuts and the lower mounting bolt first should minimize any external stresses on the AC bracket. the final tightening on the exhaust manifold nut should stabilize the assembly without adding any additional stress to the bracket assembly. finally, the belt tensioner was installed.
any manufacturing engineers out there - comments?
Last edited by Joe C; 06-14-2018 at 08:58 PM.
#5
Oil Producer
Thread Starter
Thnx Guys.
Joe i saw an earlier lost where you modded that bolt. great idea.
Now, ive had two of these crack ac brackets break where the secret bolt is, and both of those air compressors had a vibration when operational.
so im not sure about the " ot needed if factory braces" comment. n
have you guys had trouble free ac brackets? its possible that mine broke from impacts or fender benders on my cars. i hadnt considered that really. i thought it was a weak inherent design.
thnx for feedback guys, im going to install factory bracing now and if i have time later ill fab ine up using that metal conduit and a vise and grinder.
Joe i saw an earlier lost where you modded that bolt. great idea.
Now, ive had two of these crack ac brackets break where the secret bolt is, and both of those air compressors had a vibration when operational.
so im not sure about the " ot needed if factory braces" comment. n
have you guys had trouble free ac brackets? its possible that mine broke from impacts or fender benders on my cars. i hadnt considered that really. i thought it was a weak inherent design.
thnx for feedback guys, im going to install factory bracing now and if i have time later ill fab ine up using that metal conduit and a vise and grinder.
#6
Team Owner
Member Since: Sep 2001
Location: Athens AL
Posts: 59,663
Received 1,401 Likes
on
1,017 Posts
C7 of the Year - Unmodified Finalist 2021
C4 of Year Finalist (performance mods) 2019
No it is aluminum, but its cheap **** metal and a bad design for all l98 cars if you ask me. They wouldn't have needed to add so much bracing later on if it was a good design, and the design actually got much worse in 88. It should've been steel from the start with how its designed.
#7
Burning Brakes
I added a brace in that place because I had a vibration problem with the a/c on at idle. It really helped. I also reversed the bolt for easy access.
#8
Thnx Guys.
Joe i saw an earlier lost where you modded that bolt. great idea.
Now, ive had two of these crack ac brackets break where the secret bolt is, and both of those air compressors had a vibration when operational.
so im not sure about the " ot needed if factory braces" comment. n
have you guys had trouble free ac brackets? its possible that mine broke from impacts or fender benders on my cars. i hadnt considered that really. i thought it was a weak inherent design.
thnx for feedback guys, im going to install factory bracing now and if i have time later ill fab ine up using that metal conduit and a vise and grinder.
Joe i saw an earlier lost where you modded that bolt. great idea.
Now, ive had two of these crack ac brackets break where the secret bolt is, and both of those air compressors had a vibration when operational.
so im not sure about the " ot needed if factory braces" comment. n
have you guys had trouble free ac brackets? its possible that mine broke from impacts or fender benders on my cars. i hadnt considered that really. i thought it was a weak inherent design.
thnx for feedback guys, im going to install factory bracing now and if i have time later ill fab ine up using that metal conduit and a vise and grinder.
running my 85's original compressor mounting bracket (33 years/163K miles). no cracks to date. IMO, an adequate design. if anybody is having bracket failure due to compression vibration, it's not the bracket's so called poor design, that's the issue, but something with the compressor that needs addressed -
Last edited by Joe C; 06-14-2018 at 09:22 PM.
#9
#10
Burning Brakes
#11
Oil Producer
Thread Starter
rwd, awesome.
what did u use as a stock and did you simply mash the ends flat with a vice and grind into rounded ends and paint black?
what did u use as a stock and did you simply mash the ends flat with a vice and grind into rounded ends and paint black?
#12
Burning Brakes
#13
Oil Producer
Thread Starter
ac compressor related vibrations dissapeared after doing this?
#14
NO FLAMES -- adding a brace is not going to hurt anything, but have you looked into what's causing the compressor vibration? if anyone is having vibration issues bad enough to cause mounting bracket failure, personally, i'd look into what's causing the vibration, and not adding a "band-aid" to fix the problem. if you've had two bracket failures, IMO, somethings not right....
Last edited by Joe C; 09-07-2018 at 02:50 PM.
#15
Oil Producer
Thread Starter
hey Joe, not sure what you mean about the flames. I get what you're saying about checking for the source of the vibration. Thing is, I thought The source of the vibration was a lack of racing. Some kind of isolation or something from lack of support. The two braces I have had broken arm from two separate cars both of which had functioning AC but a vibration.
#16
hey Joe, not sure what you mean about the flames. I get what you're saying about checking for the source of the vibration. Thing is, I thought The source of the vibration was a lack of bracing. Some kind of isolation or something from lack of support. The two braces I have had broken arm from two separate cars both of which had functioning AC but a vibration.
vibration issues are most always caused by something being out of balance. not a lot in or within the compressor that could cause "abnormal" vibration unless it's a bearing or clutch issue - ??? does the vibration change when the compressor clutch engages or disengages, or is it all the time?
Last edited by Joe C; 06-16-2018 at 07:58 AM. Reason: added "abnormal" to my post
#17
Compressors produce a vibration from the valves opening and closing in sequence as the compressor rotates. Just like the engine creates torsional vibration on the crankshaft as the cyls fire. The higher the RPM, the higher the frequency. Occasionally, the compressor "buzzes" from the refrigerant flowing through the cycling valves.
Last edited by Joe C; 06-16-2018 at 07:56 AM.
#18
Burning Brakes
#19
@ Joe C: I thought about this a little bit. I discovered a crack in mine (way down low, by the tensioner mounting location) in 2006 after I got it out of 12 years of storage and began to prep it for the NCRS campaign. I welded the crack, and put it back together. No biggie. 12 years and 15,000 miles I haven't looked at it recently, maybe it cracked again. During the above discussion I attributed the crack to "normal" vibration from the compressor.
My original compressor was noisy when engaged. And it leaked. During it's NCRS campaign I would charge it up, go to the meet and pass Operations, then upon my return recover the R-12 and put the car away until the next event. For my Performance Verification I installed a new Service Replacement compressor. Then took it off and reinstalled the original for the next two events where originality was necessary. Then in 2009 I installed the Service Replacement again, and it has been on there for most of those 15,000 miles since I welded the bracket.
So yes, the compressor may have been "vibrating" because it was noisy, and cracked the bracket.
Sorry for the TLDR. But your thought makes sense.
My original compressor was noisy when engaged. And it leaked. During it's NCRS campaign I would charge it up, go to the meet and pass Operations, then upon my return recover the R-12 and put the car away until the next event. For my Performance Verification I installed a new Service Replacement compressor. Then took it off and reinstalled the original for the next two events where originality was necessary. Then in 2009 I installed the Service Replacement again, and it has been on there for most of those 15,000 miles since I welded the bracket.
So yes, the compressor may have been "vibrating" because it was noisy, and cracked the bracket.
Sorry for the TLDR. But your thought makes sense.
VT3 - where were the locations the cracking on your two AC brackets? same place?
Last edited by Joe C; 06-16-2018 at 02:21 PM.
#20