Best R-12 Replacement?
#21
Guest
Posts: n/a
Thanx Guys...
I think my leak is the Hose Assy' that connects to the back of the Compressor..one side to the Accumalator then routes to the Condenser.must be expensive..but it is 21 Years Old.Any suggestions on where to get mine either repaired or a New one..?
I'll try GM as well.
I think my leak is the Hose Assy' that connects to the back of the Compressor..one side to the Accumalator then routes to the Condenser.must be expensive..but it is 21 Years Old.Any suggestions on where to get mine either repaired or a New one..?
I'll try GM as well.
#22
Instructor
Member Since: Aug 2004
Location: Wentzville MO
Posts: 111
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
freeze 12
I have an old Suburban with dual air that is 134a converted and works great. I also used Freeze 12 and the correct oil in a street rod and it has been trouble free as well.
#23
Burning Brakes
Originally Posted by 1989redvette
i think your asking for problems.. as an ex ac tech ect in teh garage buisness we would not touch your car after you used these so called replacement refridgerants.. they are dangerous and not worth a hoot. at least in this case its not flammable.. don't be cheap fix it right...
a) it's hard to get R12 (illegal without a license, though they're easy to get) so you can't do your own work.
b) R12 won't be around forever.
c) R12 in a car is environmentally irresponsible because car AC systems leak over time.
d) If I'm looking for a leak, I need to keep adding refrigerant with dye until I find it. In the meantime, nice unhealthy R12 that's SUPPOSED to be captured is leaking to the atmosphere.
e. I have yet to meet someone who's satisfied with a 134a conversion in terms of system effectiveness.
What's so dangerous about these products and why are they not worth a hoot? Instead of just spouting off, TELL US WHY. That's why we're asking, and you so far are the only admitted AC-certified person to speak up here.
[RICHR]
#24
Safety Car
I've checked the outlet temperature of both my 2002 Ford Ranger with R134a and my '92 Corvette with R12 -- they are the same at 40 degrees in Florida on a 92 degree day.
So, I don't believe a system designed for R134a is any less efficient than a system that was designed for R12. Now, a system that was designed for R12 that is converted to R134a may not work as well.
I decided to look ahead for my '92 (since I intend to keep it). In case GM decides to discontinue the parts, I bought most of the parts for a '95 LT1 A/C system (a '95 system is designed from the ground up for R134a) -- and these parts are a "drop in" fit in my '92 -- I'm talking the entire system here.
When I no longer can put R12 in my existing '92 system, it will have a new, properly designed (hoses, evaporator, condenser, compressor, expansion valve, control switches, accumulator, and hose connectors) R134a system in it.
But, in the meantime, I'm still running the original R12 (with no leaks at this time) in the system after 13 years, and I have about 40 small cans and half of a 30 lb can of R12 left.
As far as other R12 conversions....I don't like ANY of the "blends." The molecules of the different components in a blend are a different size, and they can leak at different rates. Then the "blend" no longer has the same percentage of components in it and is not the same blend.
The best way to "add" to a blend is to completely evacuate the system and recharge it to maintain the same blend.
Tom Piper
So, I don't believe a system designed for R134a is any less efficient than a system that was designed for R12. Now, a system that was designed for R12 that is converted to R134a may not work as well.
I decided to look ahead for my '92 (since I intend to keep it). In case GM decides to discontinue the parts, I bought most of the parts for a '95 LT1 A/C system (a '95 system is designed from the ground up for R134a) -- and these parts are a "drop in" fit in my '92 -- I'm talking the entire system here.
When I no longer can put R12 in my existing '92 system, it will have a new, properly designed (hoses, evaporator, condenser, compressor, expansion valve, control switches, accumulator, and hose connectors) R134a system in it.
But, in the meantime, I'm still running the original R12 (with no leaks at this time) in the system after 13 years, and I have about 40 small cans and half of a 30 lb can of R12 left.
As far as other R12 conversions....I don't like ANY of the "blends." The molecules of the different components in a blend are a different size, and they can leak at different rates. Then the "blend" no longer has the same percentage of components in it and is not the same blend.
The best way to "add" to a blend is to completely evacuate the system and recharge it to maintain the same blend.
Tom Piper
Last edited by Tom Piper; 01-23-2005 at 11:03 AM.
#25
i have used freze12 in one of my vehicles and found it to work just as good as r12. the nice part is there is no expensive retrofiting, all you do is add it to your r12 system. it is totally compatable with the r12 if there is any left. as far as any other products i dont know, but i personally prefer to use freze12 over converting over to 134a. This is just information i have gathered in personal experience and through working in the ac industry for awhile.
for your hose any shop that specializes in ac system repair should have the equipment to either repair your hose or even to just make a new one using yours as a pattern.
for your hose any shop that specializes in ac system repair should have the equipment to either repair your hose or even to just make a new one using yours as a pattern.
#26
Melting Slicks
Originally Posted by rrubel
You know, I kinda resent your statements. Nobody's trying to be cheap for cheap's sake from what I see here. The point is that
a) it's hard to get R12 (illegal without a license, though they're easy to get) so you can't do your own work.
b) R12 won't be around forever.
c) R12 in a car is environmentally irresponsible because car AC systems leak over time.
d) If I'm looking for a leak, I need to keep adding refrigerant with dye until I find it. In the meantime, nice unhealthy R12 that's SUPPOSED to be captured is leaking to the atmosphere.
e. I have yet to meet someone who's satisfied with a 134a conversion in terms of system effectiveness.
What's so dangerous about these products and why are they not worth a hoot? Instead of just spouting off, TELL US WHY. That's why we're asking, and you so far are the only admitted AC-certified person to speak up here.
[RICHR]
a) it's hard to get R12 (illegal without a license, though they're easy to get) so you can't do your own work.
b) R12 won't be around forever.
c) R12 in a car is environmentally irresponsible because car AC systems leak over time.
d) If I'm looking for a leak, I need to keep adding refrigerant with dye until I find it. In the meantime, nice unhealthy R12 that's SUPPOSED to be captured is leaking to the atmosphere.
e. I have yet to meet someone who's satisfied with a 134a conversion in terms of system effectiveness.
What's so dangerous about these products and why are they not worth a hoot? Instead of just spouting off, TELL US WHY. That's why we're asking, and you so far are the only admitted AC-certified person to speak up here.
[RICHR]
Tom Piper pretty much covered all the bases. If it helps the situation any I'm also certified, Master HVAC (VA),Universal Reclaim, and MACS.
What I didn't see mentioned was some of these products may contain butane. Yes, Butane...not something I would want in my car in a crash.
Also, if I were looking for a leak I would not use refrigerant. I would more than likely use nitrogen. If it was a small leak that happens over a long period of time (a season) then dye would be a good way to go.
I hope this helps a bit.
#27
Team Owner
Member Since: Sep 2002
Location: OBAMA IS HITLER
Posts: 22,209
Likes: 0
Received 11 Likes
on
10 Posts
When I was at Corvettes at Carlise last summer, I picked up a flyer from "The Freon Don", who sells this stuff called "ENVIRO-SAFE".......supposed to be 32% more efficient than R-12, and a direct replacement for R12, R134a, R22, R501/502/503. Its some sort of "non toxic" refrigerant, endorsed by Greenpeace.
Anyway thats what the flyer says. Their phone is (215)632-4470.
Anyway thats what the flyer says. Their phone is (215)632-4470.
#28
Le Mans Master
Originally Posted by CAJUN ZZ4
Money is not an issue...I don't have a liscense...R-12 Is so damned expensive..thought there might be an alternative...
Only a few dollars a can there.
Jake
#29
Le Mans Master
Member Since: Jun 2002
Location: High Plains Drifter Fayetteville, AR
Posts: 6,097
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by JAKE
Take a vacation to Mexico and bring back a couple of cases in your luggage. Two birds with one stone.
Only a few dollars a can there.
Jake
Only a few dollars a can there.
Jake
To the best of my knowledge, R12 is still manufactured, just not in the U.S./ Canada, or any other country that signed some treaty dealing with the ozone hole.
#31
Racer
Member Since: Feb 2001
Location: NORTH WEST PA
Posts: 330
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I had a local shop top off my R12 system with R414. This shop has been doing this for 2 years and he says it's compatible with R12 and he has not had any problems with it.
So far my system is colder then it's ever been ... but as for the long term I'll have wait and see.
Brian
So far my system is colder then it's ever been ... but as for the long term I'll have wait and see.
Brian
#32
Melting Slicks
Originally Posted by RED92LT1
I had a local shop top off my R12 system with R414. This shop has been doing this for 2 years and he says it's compatible with R12 and he has not had any problems with it.
So far my system is colder then it's ever been ... but as for the long term I'll have wait and see.
Brian
So far my system is colder then it's ever been ... but as for the long term I'll have wait and see.
Brian
I just wanted to chime in again.... I think this may be R409? Anyway, more than likely it's a blend. Please see Tom Pipers post. You're right, it's awesome
The problem is most auto units do leak around the compressor shaft seal. So, the correct way to re-charge the unit is to evacuate it and totally recharge it when you use a blend. I think what Tom was refering to was fractionalization.
I was just wondering about these guys using propane??? Thats a new one for me?
#33
Burning Brakes
Originally Posted by XFIRED
rrubel,
Tom Piper pretty much covered all the bases. If it helps the situation any I'm also certified, Master HVAC (VA),Universal Reclaim, and MACS.
Tom Piper pretty much covered all the bases. If it helps the situation any I'm also certified, Master HVAC (VA),Universal Reclaim, and MACS.
What I didn't see mentioned was some of these products may contain butane. Yes, Butane...not something I would want in my car in a crash.
Also, if I were looking for a leak I would not use refrigerant. I would more than likely use nitrogen. If it was a small leak that happens over a long period of time (a season) then dye would be a good way to go.
I hope this helps a bit.
I hope this helps a bit.
Ok, there. I finally used the "c" word.
Thanks for the info.
[RICHR]
#34
Melting Slicks
rrubel,
I personally would not want to change out coils. The reason why the coils have to be changed (larger) is because 134 is not as effective r12.
If it were me, I would not use R134 but use the R409 blend and take my chances. I'm using this stuff in my refrigerator and it works well. But, my refrigerator is hermetically sealed.
I'm not all that familair with all the new stuff hitting the markets these days. All I can say is most of Duponts stuff has a proven track record and would not have a problem using it. It usually goes by the "SUVA" brand.
If I can help you in any way, give me a yell.
I personally would not want to change out coils. The reason why the coils have to be changed (larger) is because 134 is not as effective r12.
If it were me, I would not use R134 but use the R409 blend and take my chances. I'm using this stuff in my refrigerator and it works well. But, my refrigerator is hermetically sealed.
I'm not all that familair with all the new stuff hitting the markets these days. All I can say is most of Duponts stuff has a proven track record and would not have a problem using it. It usually goes by the "SUVA" brand.
If I can help you in any way, give me a yell.
#35
Burning Brakes
When I got my '90, I called the dealer and asked if there was a kit to convert my system to R134a. They said the that there was no such kit and that GM said to simply recharge with R134a. There is also an EPA document that says that R134a works well in R12 systems. I recharged my system with R134a and it works flawlessly. It works much better than new A/C systems in some foreign cars I have experienced. I live in the SF Bay area where the temperature is rarely above 95F so it is possible that it will be marginal in some very hot areas. It works fine at 95F. Initially, I overcharged the system and I did have a problem. You need less R134a than you do R12. I ended up using about two cans.
#36
Le Mans Master
Get your R12 (608) license at www.epatest.com or any of the sites at the www.epa.gov site. Buy R12 at Autozone or check EBAY or do a Google search. If you haven't bought any R134 lately, it's now about half of what R12 costs - 6 bucks a can versus 12 bucks for R12 (the last avg price I paid at Autozone). In any event, gas should be the least of your concerns as your Vette's a/c probably needs a lot more work to make it right and the gas will be the least expensive item you replace.
As to hydrocarbons, they can be flammable and there's an outright ban in at least 18 States. You can find which ones on the EPA site.
Freeze 12 and some of the others are pretty much R134 so using them and creating a system that no one will touch doesn't make much sense.
As to hydrocarbons, they can be flammable and there's an outright ban in at least 18 States. You can find which ones on the EPA site.
Freeze 12 and some of the others are pretty much R134 so using them and creating a system that no one will touch doesn't make much sense.
#37
Melting Slicks
Originally Posted by SunCr
Get your R12 (608) license at www.epatest.com or any of the sites at the www.epa.gov site. Buy R12 at Autozone or check EBAY or do a Google search. If you haven't bought any R134 lately, it's now about half of what R12 costs - 6 bucks a can versus 12 bucks for R12 (the last avg price I paid at Autozone). In any event, gas should be the least of your concerns as your Vette's a/c probably needs a lot more work to make it right and the gas will be the least expensive item you replace.
.
.
#38
Safety Car
Anyone want to buy my stash (about 40 small cans and somewhere between 10 -15 lbs of a 30 lb can) of R12?
If I sell it, I will just switch my '92 to the complete '95 R134a system as I posted above.
Tom Piper
If I sell it, I will just switch my '92 to the complete '95 R134a system as I posted above.
Tom Piper
#39
Safety Car
Originally Posted by JAKE
Take a vacation to Mexico and bring back a couple of cases in your luggage. Two birds with one stone.
Only a few dollars a can there.
Jake
Only a few dollars a can there.
Jake
Tom Piper
#40
Melting Slicks
Originally Posted by Tom Piper
Anyone want to buy my stash (about 40 small cans and somewhere between 10 -15 lbs of a 30 lb can) of R12?
If I sell it, I will just switch my '92 to the complete '95 R134a system as I posted above.
Tom Piper
If I sell it, I will just switch my '92 to the complete '95 R134a system as I posted above.
Tom Piper