What's worse?.....

I would think that the "narrow" one would be the worst, since it would tend to roll over onto the sidewall more than the overly wide tire would.
Am I right or wrong here?

The reason I ask is I just got done having a 255/35 18 tire put on an 18x9.5 wheel, which is the smallest recommended size for the wheel, and it is obviously smaller than what the wheel can take.
The tire manufacture doesn't offer a 265/35 tire but does offer a 275 (which is at the max recommended size for the wheel).
Since I can't get a 265 for the wheel (in this brand), I was wondering if I should have gone with the 275 and which would have been the worst handling of the two in cornering ability....the 255 or the 275?
Yeah, I know, I ask the dumbest questions.
The reason I ask is I just got done having a 255/35 18 tire put on an 18x9.5 wheel, which is the smallest recommended size for the wheel, and it is obviously smaller than what the wheel can take.
The tire manufacture doesn't offer a 265/35 tire but does offer a 275 (which is at the max recommended size for the wheel).
Since I can't get a 265 for the wheel (in this brand), I was wondering if I should have gone with the 275 and which would have been the worst handling of the two in cornering ability....the 255 or the 275?
Yeah, I know, I ask the dumbest questions.




