When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.
I had Straub / Smith but did not like their manufacturing tolerance and sent them back. Straub blamed it on the rocker tolerance. I measured the rockers and there was significantly less variability than their bushings. Got Che and they fit perfect.
After following this post, I had to look in my journal to see when I last did my springs, 10 years ago. Wow, how time fly's. Engine builder said every 3-4 years, cheap insurance if revving high a lot. I did the Comp trunnion kit at the time. So going to order up the CHE's, springs, plugs, wires, etc and put it on the to do list when warmer. Curious and can't wait to see if there's a wear pattern on the Comp trunnions like so many others had, 10 years will be a good test. I noticed the looseness of the comp trunnions in the support and had to hold back on the rocker to keep it aligned with the valve stem when tightening. I remember thinking this is insane. Never did it before, so didn't know the difference and there is. Might get some new rocker supports too, dirt cheap, incase the Comps did something to the originals, start fresh. I'll post up some pics in a month or two, if there's wear to see.
There is a good chance Comp fixed the issue? No one ever mentions that.
When mine failed I switched to the BTR V2. They have a true hardened shaft.
I’m just not a fan of the bronze stuff.
How did the BTR V2 fit in the rocker supports? Tight or wiggly like the Comps I have, probably original version. They even came with a set of different length rocker bolts that had to be used. The thing that worries me with the CHE's is what if the rocker casting is ugly, not a factor with the pressed in bearing or bushing. All I know is, it's time for the original Comps to be retired.
There is a good chance Comp fixed the issue? No one ever mentions that.
When mine failed I switched to the BTR V2. They have a true hardened shaft.
I’m just not a fan of the bronze stuff.
Ron, I don't know what grade of bronze CHE, Straub, etc, are using. But, if it's AMPCO 18 bronze, that's some mighty tough, hard bronze. When you try filing it, the file tries to slide on it with a mild "shriek." Endmills and carbide cutters make a Helluva racket. If they're using AMPCO 18, or pretty much any AMPCO grade, they should last a LONG time. Especially with the constant oil splash feed from the pushrods. My .02......
Ron, I don't know what grade of bronze CHE, Straub, etc, are using. But, if it's AMPCO 18 bronze, that's some mighty tough, hard bronze. When you try filing it, the file tries to slide on it with a mild "shriek." Endmills and carbide cutters make a Helluva racket. If they're using AMPCO 18, or pretty much any AMPCO grade, they should last a LONG time. Especially with the constant oil splash feed from the pushrods. My .02......
The BTR website sells the Smith Bros kit and states C932 bronze. I have no clue how that rates. I found the info below on the net…
Just to contribute here... I just installed a BTR kit in my LS6 Rockers. The trunions were very dirty and needed soaked in Acetone and cleaned with a brush. That kinda surprised me. The bearings were soaked in 5W-30 and installed correctly (I've done this before) with an Arbor Press. When I spin them they feel 'notchy' - not smooth at all. Also surprising. I guess I'll see what happens once it's all back up and running. My cam is a BTR Stage 3 PD Blower cam - BIG lift so they will get lots of exercise. I'm not taking them out and replacing them with Bronze.
Just giving my opinion here. FWIW
I am picking up parts to upgrade for a super charger install and a trunnion upgrade is one of them. I am leaning towards the CHE, but was curious if anyone has any experience with the BTR LS1 Shaft Rocker Kit?
I might have gone with the CHE trunnions, but at the time I was going through this, CHE only offered an "exchange program", where you sent your rockers to them, and they installed their kit, and then sent the rockers back. Why didn't I go with this? A) it was a little "pricey", I seem to recall $300, possibly a little more; B) it would have meant the car being "down" for an extended period of time, and C) I don't know if it's was a valid concern, but on the possibility that rockers and valve tips establish a "wear pattern", I wanted my OE rockers to remain in their original positions.
Impressive! This second version of the BTR roller trunnion has some great features, including higher grade of steel, oiling holes drilled in the trunnion body, and end washers covered by HD snap rings.
I'm just about to start a valvetrain refresh on my car. Previously installed the Comp Cam trunnions some years ago, but with all the issues and failures I decided to buy the BTR V2 "TK002" kit and replace them while I was there already, doing springs and pushrods and whatnot. Seems to have only good reports so far, crossing my fingers.
I want to believe that there is a 'upgrade' available.
However, I am sitting on 620rwhp with .550 lift and OEM rockers that have over 200,000 miles on them, with 35,000 of those miles at 500-600rwhp.
And its a little hard to reach in and change a part that seems to be working fine...
I might try to keep using the OEM units just protect them < 6200rpm and < .580 lift might do the trick
Big issue here with these type of upgrades and failures is, once you start finding metal in the pan that could be the end of the engine permanently. No coming back from metal splattered all over the insides IMO. Whether a factory rocker fails or an aftermarket fails, end result could the same.
Bronze scares me a little but I like the kit that includes new bolts and anything with new rocker materials seems it would be 'okay' or at least give an edge over the factory stuff. Still, I've seen 1000rwhp on the OEM rockers. Just always a question of longevity. Not everybody reports or understands the root cause of a failure and such. I want to believe the 'weak cam' (slow ramp & low lift) will protect them. For reference I used TFS-30602001 which has a very slow ramp rate
Last edited by Kingtal0n; Mar 4, 2022 at 10:52 AM.
You touched on an interesting point. Perhaps there is a good reason wrist pins are either pressed or free floating, but not needle bearing.
The two reasons wristpins float are because floating pins supposedly reduce friction, but the big reason is should the wristpin gall and seize, you still have a slip fit in the other "bearing", be it the rod or piston, so the rod won't come out the side of the block!! Caged needles are most often used on two cycle engines wristpins, due to less oil being available to lube them properly.......
I'm just about to start a valvetrain refresh on my car. Previously installed the Comp Cam trunnions some years ago, but with all the issues and failures I decided to buy the BTR V2 "TK002" kit and replace them while I was there already, doing springs and pushrods and whatnot. Seems to have only good reports so far, crossing my fingers.
I’d be interested to hear your observations on the quality and fit of the components, and of course how they run.
The TK002 looks like a very well thought out kit. BTR has definitely gone beyond their first design, and ahead of the Comp needle trunnions. Also, now that it’s become evident the bushing styles are more sensitive to oiling than the needles, it’s looking even better for the BTR design.
One of the issues brought up on the comp rollers was the diameter of the trunnions not fitting snug in the the trunnion stands. Might be worth a verification.
I’ve not heard of issues with BTR’s first kit. I installed one in my buddy's turbo 6.0. It was different from the Comp kit.
It’s a little hard to pull a rocker and check. The needles fall out.
The V2 kit with the hardened race makes them just like any typical roller rocker. Should last a long time.
It will be interesting to see how all these bronze bushed rockers hold up over the long haul.
I’ve not heard of issues with BTR’s first kit. I installed one in my buddy's turbo 6.0. It was different from the Comp kit.
It’s a little hard to pull a rocker and check. The needles fall out.
The V2 kit with the hardened race makes them just like any typical roller rocker. Should last a long time.
It will be interesting to see how all these bronze bushed rockers hold up over the long haul.
Indeed, I had not heard of it failing either, but the V1 kit looked like a twin(to me) of the Comp kit and that made me skeptical. From you’re experience it appears that was not the case.
From the BTR website:
“The V1 kits have stood up to an enormous amount of abuse, but we decided to upgrade them to a pressed inner race comprised of 52100 heat treated bearing steel, over the more commonly used 8620 carburized steel found in our V1 kits and many OEM applications. Additionally, these feature a self oiling axle with priority feeding to the trunnion itself.”
Evidently, BTR is putting time and money into bringing a higher standard with these trunnion upgrades.