Battery replacement recommendation?
Will the factory battery be sufficient or should I replace it with something like an Optima? I do not want the problem of a dead battery.
Also I am reading about others just jumping their dead batteries. I did the same in the past when ever I had a dead battery and never had a problem with any of my cars.
I have recently read that "if possible" it is best to fully charge a dead battery rather than jump and use the alternator to charge it as the alternator is not designed for this purpose.
It will work of course if a charger is not available but puts added stress and heat on the alternator.
Also I have always heard to fully charge a new battery before installation if possible.
John





Rule of thumb...never trust a Delco battery.
Rule of thumb...never trust a Delco battery.

Also, a trickle charger is practically worthless for an Optima as these batteries requires significant amperage to charge. Most trickle chargers are low amerpage by design and can't overcome the internal resistance inherent in the spiral cell/gel Optima design.
Also, a trickle charger is practically worthless for an Optima as these batteries requires significant amperage to charge. Most trickle chargers are low amerpage by design and can't overcome the internal resistance inherent in the spiral cell/gel Optima design.


The battery tender others referred to is fine and certainly doesn’t hurt. If you live in North Dakota it would be a wise thing. Florida, I don’t think you need it. I recommend you try it without the trickle charge and see what happens.
The Best of Corvette for Corvette Enthusiasts













Also, a trickle charger is practically worthless for an Optima as these batteries requires significant amperage to charge. Most trickle chargers are low amerpage by design and can't overcome the internal resistance inherent in the spiral cell/gel Optima design.


Red top Optimas are not deep-cycle. The yellow ones are.

I, too, recommend the red tops for your cars.
Most trickle chargers made now-a-days have the capacity to charge deep cycle batteries since they are becoming so popular. Even the Battery Tender has a charger for deep cycle batteries. I have 3 of them. If you aren't sure what you are buying and you have a deep cycle battery, just read the box, it will say it on there. I can't think of any place that sells battery chargers that doesn't have one capable of trickle charging a deep cycle battery.
1) I'm not sure how you came to the "1597 CCA" number you are quoting. CCA is the number of amps output at zero degrees F for 30 seconds without the voltage falling below the recommended minimum (usually ~10.5v). Perhaps you meant CA (cranking amps), but your number is still way too high.
2) Deep cycle batteries (such as the Optima yellow top) have thicker plates and as such are able to withstand "deep" discharge/recharge cycles without excessive sulfination. These thicker plates translates to a heavier battery, and in some cases the weight increase is significant (~35-40%). These thicker plates don't come free, and one can expect to pay the same % increase for a deep cell at retail. Also, deep cycle batteries have LESS CCA than a comparably sized starting battery.
3) It is true that deep cycle batteries provide more AH, and as such will remain usable for a longer period of time in the presence of a constant drain, but the difference is only 15%. In the same drain scenario, the yellow top will remain viable for 138 hours versus the red top at 120 hours.
4) It is BAD for a deep cycle battery to be discharged to <10% SoC (State of Charge). The rule for deep cycle is "more than 10%, less than 20%". Starting you car will not meet this rule and will greatly shorten the life of a deep cycle battery. This rule (and the need for greater CCAs in some locales) is the very reason why "starting" batteries were developed. They can take the <10% SoC, but >10% will kill it just as fast as a deep cycle @ <10%.
Sorry for being long winded...either battery will work in the Vette just fine, I just wanted everyone to realize exactly what that extra $50 and 5-7lbs is REALLY getting you.
Here is a handy Optima chart:






Last edited by _Nomad_; Dec 25, 2004 at 12:50 AM.
















