[Z06] Why are the Stock Brakes "So Bad" ?
#21
Le Mans Master
Member Since: Feb 2000
Location: Bedford NH
Posts: 5,708
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
Cruise-In II Veteran
I think DJWorm stated it well. The best statement I have heard is they are overkill for the street and way bad for the track. As far as pure street goes, we found that that with the small pads that have a roughly 1:1 aspect ratio, the pads rotate into the rotor and the "worse than worthless" holes act like a cheese grater and really eat the pads fast. I found that I could not go to the supermarket and back with the stock rotors without having to clean the wheels again. With our rotors, it was about 2 or 3 times less dust due to the lack of cheese grater effect. On the track, the small pads do not have the thermal mass necessary and one VERY well known brake company has stated they will not make pads because they consider the stock design so bad they are worried about liability. I ran our rotor (that does fit the stock caliper and is a full 10 pounds+ less each) with the stock caliper for a while in testing but one of biggest issue is cost of the very thin pads. It simply got to be an economic decision to go with a caliper that not only has 21mm thick pads that are $300/axle, but works infinitely better. The PFC zR33 Grand Am caliper we use cost about 4 stock pad changes. I still wonder why GM did not use the Brembo off of the CTS-V. It is not as good as the zR33 caliper but it would have been better than the pure junk that PBR supplied.
Normally in all engineering trade studies there are pluses and minuses to all decisions, but this PBR "system" has no positive aspects (well I guess it looks cool). The rotors are all left side, have mass in areas that have no benefit, holes to eat pads, and heavy, flexy calipers that have thin, expensive, limited availability pads, but besides that it is fine.
Normally in all engineering trade studies there are pluses and minuses to all decisions, but this PBR "system" has no positive aspects (well I guess it looks cool). The rotors are all left side, have mass in areas that have no benefit, holes to eat pads, and heavy, flexy calipers that have thin, expensive, limited availability pads, but besides that it is fine.
#22
Instructor
Thread Starter
Ok
Thanks for all the great info guys now here is where the rubber meets the road or should I say the pads meet the rotors.
How much
Stop Tech Kit
Front $
Rear $
Hardbar
Front $
Rear $
Brembo if Avail
Anyone Others
How much
Stop Tech Kit
Front $
Rear $
Hardbar
Front $
Rear $
Brembo if Avail
Anyone Others
#23
Melting Slicks
Just as a point or interest, Porterfield has just reduced the price on the ST 43 raybestos Pads they are less than $500.00 for a full set. Short Throw had very good luck with these compared to stock pads and the price before was over 750.00 a set. Porterfield says that they are now in production and that is why the price drop, talk to Tim at Porterfield. I have been running them on the street for the last two weeks and I like them and plan on running them at the Musieum event is SC. They are a little more sensative than the stock set up. According to Mike they were much better than the std. pads. JD
#24
Team Owner
Originally Posted by JDIllon
Just as a point or interest, Porterfield has just reduced the price on the ST 43 raybestos Pads they are less than $500.00 for a full set. Short Throw had very good luck with these compared to stock pads and the price before was over 750.00 a set. Porterfield says that they are now in production and that is why the price drop, talk to Tim at Porterfield. I have been running them on the street for the last two weeks and I like them and plan on running them at the Musieum event is SC. They are a little more sensative than the stock set up. According to Mike they were much better than the std. pads. JD
Price probably dropped from competition and who wants to pay 750 for some pads. Doubt they sold many at that price.
The street and track are two different worlds. The you get two different people on the track and that could be two different extremes also.
For the rest of the car the brakes are :o From a engineering stand point the backward rotor is something you may expect on a Yugo. That would drive me wild on truck never mind a High Performance 200 MPH vehicle. Kind of like having you underware on backwards, still works but not well. I am sure Porsche is laughing their brains out over this.
They built a street car not a race car so if you take it to the track and do 165 MPH to 30 MPH stops at a track constantly it just won't cut it.
No brainer for a track person to save money in pads to help pay the cost of BBK and then sell your Z brakes to a blinger. Can't wait to see what the Blue Devil has for brakes with 650 HP, better be better
#25
Team Owner
Member Since: Mar 2001
Location: Virginia Beach
Posts: 25,889
Likes: 0
Received 5 Likes
on
5 Posts
CI 3-5-6-7-8 Veteran
My $0.02... buy the full Stop-Tech kit as it will end up performing better and paying for itself in consumables, then sell your mint oem setup to the blingy C6 or C5 crowd who wants the looks.
#27
Le Mans Master
Member Since: Feb 1999
Location: Vilano Beach FL
Posts: 7,121
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I suspect a caliper that uses 30 padlets the size of chicklets that are $50/each
Originally Posted by John Shiels
Can't wait to see what the Blue Devil has for brakes with 650 HP, better be better
#28
I would be curious to hear an experts comparison of the C6 base, Z51, and Z06 brakes. If the Z06 is the best and were to score 100 points what would score would you assign to base and Z51? I know some are saying that Z06 are poor brakes but my question is relatively speaking how much better are they than base and Z51?
The goal with the C6Z brakes was to go to a bigger rotor, stiffer caliper, and increased thermal capacity. The issues outlined in this email show that while the intent was there, the execution was not. Therefore, I'd say that for the street, the C6Z brakes could be superior in terms of bite / feel. Although I haven't driven them, fixed calipers typically have a more solid feel than a slider (less flex), and the drilled rotors should give some nice bite on the pad. That said, the only obvious benefit of the C6Z brakes is that they look better.
For track duty, I'd take the C5Z or C6 setup all day. It has more race friction options, non-drilled, proper directional rotors, no finicky pad retention bolts to strip out, less expensive replacement components, etc. Honestly, the only benefit I clearly see of putting a C6Z brake kit on your C5 or C6 is aesthetic. That may be worth $1600 to some people (the going street price), but it's a nice chunk of change.
If you're taking the car to the track, you'd be better off keeping the stock C5 or C6 rear brakes, and upgrading to our front kit for a slightly higher price (for example, $2395 for our four piston front setup). You'd have a much more capable system.
#29
Former Vendor
Member Since: Jul 2006
Location: Lightwater UK
Posts: 889
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by JRitt@StopTech
GM provided a large directional rotor, but they put one rotor on the car spinning in the wrong direction! That means that on the right side of the car, airflow is not optimized through the rotor. The relevance of this situation becomes greater at track speeds. More heat is generated when slowing from a high speed, and you need as much airflow as possible on the ensuing straights after those types of stops to cool the system back down. Turbulence in the rotor does not allow heat to dissipate through radiation. In simple terms, the hot air "hangs around," rather than being drawn out through the wheel, etc.
Also others who reported uneven rotor wear have had problems with their left one so it's not just me!
I remember looking at the internal vanes and they go the oppposite direction to the pattern of the cross-drilled holes so I'm pretty sure it is the left hand one that is "wrong" as the hole pattern is / way at the top of the left rotor, which means the internal vanes are \ way, i.e. wrong.
Last edited by David_Yu; 10-22-2006 at 06:50 AM.
#30
Originally Posted by JRitt@StopTech
This is probably the single most common response I get from our customers after adding our kit. They tell me that they can focus on driving and enjoying the car, push as hard as they want without worrying, etc. I've found the same thing on my cars. To anyone that's had a finicky coilover setup that they couldn't dial-in, less than adequate brakes, or a supercharger that throws belts...there's not much better than a great day at the track when your car performs flawlessly. With all the prep, money spent, and limited track time, there's a lot to be said for simplicity and reliability.
Thanks Geoff
#31
Instructor
Member Since: Aug 2006
Location: schiedam ZUID-HOLLAND
Posts: 138
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Why doesn`t i read about other brake company`beside Stop Tech?
What are the expirience`s with AP or brembo`s.
I have on my old car a subaru wrx a big brake kit from AP.
I am a little bit disapointment by this kit with the ferodo ds 2500 brake pads.
After useing pagid bleu (are they avalebel in the US?) they feld better.
But the story here is that the caliper is bending out under hard breaking.
Does people driving with those big brake kits the same experiece on there z 06?
Wat can you recommend me for a big brake kit?
I do a lot of track day`s and i don`t want to wurry about my brake`s
Grtz,Hans
What are the expirience`s with AP or brembo`s.
I have on my old car a subaru wrx a big brake kit from AP.
I am a little bit disapointment by this kit with the ferodo ds 2500 brake pads.
After useing pagid bleu (are they avalebel in the US?) they feld better.
But the story here is that the caliper is bending out under hard breaking.
Does people driving with those big brake kits the same experiece on there z 06?
Wat can you recommend me for a big brake kit?
I do a lot of track day`s and i don`t want to wurry about my brake`s
Grtz,Hans
#32
Team Owner
I just did 42 hard laps at Road America on my OEM Z51 brakes. Aside from some odd discoloration on the rotor's I experienced no issues.
I did leave the safety nannies engaged and ABS and AH kicked on several times.
Can someone tell me how my rotor's look after this hard use?
Before
After
I'm going back to RA in April with new found confidence in me and the car and I suspect I'll push it even harder. Any tips or suggestions on brake tweakes etc?
Tom
I did leave the safety nannies engaged and ABS and AH kicked on several times.
Can someone tell me how my rotor's look after this hard use?
Before
After
I'm going back to RA in April with new found confidence in me and the car and I suspect I'll push it even harder. Any tips or suggestions on brake tweakes etc?
Tom
#33
Tech Contributor
Member Since: Mar 1999
Location: Northern VA
Posts: 10,127
Received 3,891 Likes
on
1,178 Posts
"Ask Tadge" Producer
Originally Posted by Geoff17
Jeff, Stop Tech's products are always great. The kit sounds great for the track. What is the impact on daily driving?
Thanks Geoff
Thanks Geoff
jas
#34
Former Vendor
Member Since: Jul 2006
Location: Lightwater UK
Posts: 889
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I asked in another thread but nobody replied: is there a C6 Z06-specific BBK or are they all C5 kits?
I haven't found any Brembo GT kits listed for the C6 at all, so is everyone fitting C5 ones?
Also, how come no one has produced a 6 pot front caliper yet?
I know the number of pistons doen't necessarily dictate brake performance, but a car like the Z06 deserves at least a 6 pot set-up IMO (and obviously in the opinion of GM's marketing dept. too!).
I haven't found any Brembo GT kits listed for the C6 at all, so is everyone fitting C5 ones?
Also, how come no one has produced a 6 pot front caliper yet?
I know the number of pistons doen't necessarily dictate brake performance, but a car like the Z06 deserves at least a 6 pot set-up IMO (and obviously in the opinion of GM's marketing dept. too!).
#35
Tech Contributor
Member Since: Mar 1999
Location: Northern VA
Posts: 10,127
Received 3,891 Likes
on
1,178 Posts
"Ask Tadge" Producer
Originally Posted by David_Yu
Also, how come no one has produced a 6 pot front caliper yet?
I know the number of pistons doen't necessarily dictate brake performance, but a car like the Z06 deserves at least a 6 pot set-up IMO (and obviously in the opinion of GM's marketing dept. too!).
I know the number of pistons doen't necessarily dictate brake performance, but a car like the Z06 deserves at least a 6 pot set-up IMO (and obviously in the opinion of GM's marketing dept. too!).
jas
#36
Former Vendor
Member Since: Jul 2006
Location: Lightwater UK
Posts: 889
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by jvp
The StopTech kit is a 6-pot front/4-pot rear. I don't think it's a "C6 Specific" kit, other than the bracket required to attach the caliper to the spindle. Calipers are calipers are calipers. :-)
jas
jas
Question for Jeff: I presume Stop Tech's kit is a proper street kit, i.e. includes dust seals on the pistons etc.?
I ask as I have owned AP Racing 6 pot kits that didn't.
Also how much would a set of Pagid (yellows) cost for your set up? Does it use a fairly common pad size?
#37
Tech Contributor
Member Since: Mar 1999
Location: Northern VA
Posts: 10,127
Received 3,891 Likes
on
1,178 Posts
"Ask Tadge" Producer
Originally Posted by David_Yu
Question for Jeff: I presume Stop Tech's kit is a proper street kit, i.e. includes dust seals on the pistons etc.?
Also how much would a set of Pagid (yellows) cost for your set up? Does it use a fairly common pad size?
jas
#38
Former Vendor
Member Since: Jul 2006
Location: Lightwater UK
Posts: 889
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Thanks for the info. Well it looks like a four wheel set will run to nearly as much as my LPE 616bhp kit, but there's no point in going fast if you can't stop!
BTW, Pagids may be a little cheaper here as they are a Euro co.
We don't need TUV parts in the UK.
I know you're not Jeff, hence why I said: a question for Jeff!
BTW, Pagids may be a little cheaper here as they are a Euro co.
We don't need TUV parts in the UK.
I know you're not Jeff, hence why I said: a question for Jeff!
#39
I'm getting confused here. On this thread, it is stated that the Z runs LEFT hand only rotors and in the other one I started, I stated that it runs RIGHT hand only ones as it was my left one that was shot!
AFVETTE,
Your rotors look fine. I don't see any major cracking. The concentric grooves (rings around the rotor) are typical for a drilled rotor.
I asked in another thread but nobody replied: is there a C6 Z06-specific BBK or are they all C5 kits?
Calipers are most definitely not JUST calipers!
Also, how come no one has produced a 6 pot front caliper yet?
Question for Jeff: I presume Stop Tech's kit is a proper street kit, i.e. includes dust seals on the pistons etc.?
Also how much would a set of Pagid (yellows) cost for your set up? Does it use a fairly common pad size?
Also how much would a set of Pagid (yellows) cost for your set up? Does it use a fairly common pad size?
We sell those Pagid Yellows for our front calipers for $375.
Click on the numbers at the top of that page to see more details on all of the kit components.
I'm not Jeff and I don't play him on TV (or the Internet). But, yes, dust seals, etc. The brake lines included with the kit may NOT be TUV-compliant though. I'm not sure about that one. Do you need TUV-compliant parts in UK?
For the current owners chiming in, thanks for the nice comments about our products...much appreciated.
Last edited by J Ritt; 10-26-2006 at 07:13 PM.
#40
Thanks for the info. Well it looks like a four wheel set will run to nearly as much as my LPE 616bhp kit, but there's no point in going fast if you can't stop!