[Z06] Talked to Rich at WCCH today...
#41
Team Owner
Member Since: Apr 2001
Location: Elmhurst, IL (West Suburb of Chicago) & Home of MEGA Horsepower
Posts: 26,714
Received 584 Likes
on
399 Posts
St. Jude Donor '06
Here is what you need to know right now to assess whether you are individually at risk. If you have excessive valvetrain noise or oil consumption you should have it looked at. If you are in warranty and your engine is not modified it will be covered. If you have an aftermarket cam it will not be covered. I'm not sure of what other aftermarket modifications dictate whether or not it will be covered, but we should know more about that soon. Further info is coming soon.
The proper fix if the vehicle is out of warranty or modified is bronze guides with Ti/Mo intake valves and OEM exhaust valves such as Katech has been doing all along. It was our experience in the C5-R and C6.R racing programs and the bronze guide/molybdenum coated intake valve which brought us to this conclusion. C5-R heads with 15,000 race miles showed virtually no measurable wear on the valve guide.
The proper fix if the vehicle is out of warranty or modified is bronze guides with Ti/Mo intake valves and OEM exhaust valves such as Katech has been doing all along. It was our experience in the C5-R and C6.R racing programs and the bronze guide/molybdenum coated intake valve which brought us to this conclusion. C5-R heads with 15,000 race miles showed virtually no measurable wear on the valve guide.
Also, Jason provides great info above as to what the warning signs are if you think your Z is going to have an issue, thanks Jason.
Last edited by Mopar Jimmy; 08-31-2012 at 12:04 PM.
#43
#45
So, I take this as Katech is officially saying that THERE IS A PROBLEM.
The important thing is not what Katech can do to solve the problem. It's what GM can do to solve the problem. Give a customer the same engine after the first one is blown is a joke. Eventually, the customer runs out of warranty, then what happens. Everyone lines up outside Katech after their warranty is out with their credit cards in hand?
The important thing is not what Katech can do to solve the problem. It's what GM can do to solve the problem. Give a customer the same engine after the first one is blown is a joke. Eventually, the customer runs out of warranty, then what happens. Everyone lines up outside Katech after their warranty is out with their credit cards in hand?
#46
Le Mans Master
Here is what you need to know right now to assess whether you are individually at risk. If you have excessive valvetrain noise or oil consumption you should have it looked at. If you are in warranty and your engine is not modified it will be covered. If you have an aftermarket cam it will not be covered. I'm not sure of what other aftermarket modifications dictate whether or not it will be covered, but we should know more about that soon. Further info is coming soon.
The proper fix if the vehicle is out of warranty or modified is bronze guides with Ti/Mo intake valves and OEM exhaust valves such as Katech has been doing all along. It was our experience in the C5-R and C6.R racing programs and the bronze guide/molybdenum coated intake valve which brought us to this conclusion. C5-R heads with 15,000 race miles showed virtually no measurable wear on the valve guide.
The proper fix if the vehicle is out of warranty or modified is bronze guides with Ti/Mo intake valves and OEM exhaust valves such as Katech has been doing all along. It was our experience in the C5-R and C6.R racing programs and the bronze guide/molybdenum coated intake valve which brought us to this conclusion. C5-R heads with 15,000 race miles showed virtually no measurable wear on the valve guide.
#47
Race Director
Here is what you need to know right now to assess whether you are individually at risk. If you have excessive valvetrain noise or oil consumption you should have it looked at. If you are in warranty and your engine is not modified it will be covered. If you have an aftermarket cam it will not be covered. I'm not sure of what other aftermarket modifications dictate whether or not it will be covered, but we should know more about that soon. Further info is coming soon.
The proper fix if the vehicle is out of warranty or modified is bronze guides with Ti/Mo intake valves and OEM exhaust valves such as Katech has been doing all along. It was our experience in the C5-R and C6.R racing programs and the bronze guide/molybdenum coated intake valve which brought us to this conclusion. C5-R heads with 15,000 race miles showed virtually no measurable wear on the valve guide.
The proper fix if the vehicle is out of warranty or modified is bronze guides with Ti/Mo intake valves and OEM exhaust valves such as Katech has been doing all along. It was our experience in the C5-R and C6.R racing programs and the bronze guide/molybdenum coated intake valve which brought us to this conclusion. C5-R heads with 15,000 race miles showed virtually no measurable wear on the valve guide.
#48
Safety Car
Thread Starter
Thanks for commenting Jason. Too much uncertainty to move to SS valves. What people who accuse you of covering for GM don't realize is you build engines with the same oem exhaust valves. AND put a warranty behind it.
#49
Race Director
Here is what you need to know right now to assess whether you are individually at risk. If you have excessive valvetrain noise or oil consumption you should have it looked at. If you are in warranty and your engine is not modified it will be covered. If you have an aftermarket cam it will not be covered. I'm not sure of what other aftermarket modifications dictate whether or not it will be covered, but we should know more about that soon. Further info is coming soon.
The proper fix if the vehicle is out of warranty or modified is bronze guides with Ti/Mo intake valves and OEM exhaust valves such as Katech has been doing all along. It was our experience in the C5-R and C6.R racing programs and the bronze guide/molybdenum coated intake valve which brought us to this conclusion. C5-R heads with 15,000 race miles showed virtually no measurable wear on the valve guide.
The proper fix if the vehicle is out of warranty or modified is bronze guides with Ti/Mo intake valves and OEM exhaust valves such as Katech has been doing all along. It was our experience in the C5-R and C6.R racing programs and the bronze guide/molybdenum coated intake valve which brought us to this conclusion. C5-R heads with 15,000 race miles showed virtually no measurable wear on the valve guide.
#51
Yes, there have been intake failures as well, just less of them.
I'm sort of surprised that some above drive a car at this price point but balk at the cost of Ti/Mo valves. They are a little pricey I guess. However, I would think if you're really set on not spending much, maybe only have bronze guides pressed into your exhaust valves and replace those valves with OEM units. Not sure if there is a downside to this, but I just did it all with bronze, OEM exhaust and katech Ti/Mo intakes. I drive my car hard and don't think about it anymore, well worth a few grand to me. To each their own.
I'm sort of surprised that some above drive a car at this price point but balk at the cost of Ti/Mo valves. They are a little pricey I guess. However, I would think if you're really set on not spending much, maybe only have bronze guides pressed into your exhaust valves and replace those valves with OEM units. Not sure if there is a downside to this, but I just did it all with bronze, OEM exhaust and katech Ti/Mo intakes. I drive my car hard and don't think about it anymore, well worth a few grand to me. To each their own.
#52
Here is what you need to know right now to assess whether you are individually at risk. If you have excessive valvetrain noise or oil consumption you should have it looked at. If you are in warranty and your engine is not modified it will be covered. If you have an aftermarket cam it will not be covered. I'm not sure of what other aftermarket modifications dictate whether or not it will be covered, but we should know more about that soon. Further info is coming soon.
The proper fix if the vehicle is out of warranty or modified is bronze guides with Ti/Mo intake valves and OEM exhaust valves such as Katech has been doing all along. It was our experience in the C5-R and C6.R racing programs and the bronze guide/molybdenum coated intake valve which brought us to this conclusion. C5-R heads with 15,000 race miles showed virtually no measurable wear on the valve guide.
The proper fix if the vehicle is out of warranty or modified is bronze guides with Ti/Mo intake valves and OEM exhaust valves such as Katech has been doing all along. It was our experience in the C5-R and C6.R racing programs and the bronze guide/molybdenum coated intake valve which brought us to this conclusion. C5-R heads with 15,000 race miles showed virtually no measurable wear on the valve guide.
However in doing that, then keep the stock exhaust valves, but change the intake valves to ti/mo coated.
So was it the valve guides which were causing the exhaust valves to fail?
I ask that question because you're not saying throw out the exhaust valves themselves, but you are saying throw out the stock (exhaust) valve guides (as well as the stock intake valve guides)and go from there.
This all would imply that there was a problem with some bad guides.
Also with regard to the part in bold above, would you please clarify:
"The proper fix if the vehicle is out of warranty or modified is bronze guides with Ti/Mo intake valves and OEM exhaust valves such as Katech has been doing all along."
Is this also the proper fix for a car which is still in warranty????
#53
Safety Car
Here is what you need to know right now to assess whether you are individually at risk. If you have excessive valvetrain noise or oil consumption you should have it looked at. If you are in warranty and your engine is not modified it will be covered. If you have an aftermarket cam it will not be covered. I'm not sure of what other aftermarket modifications dictate whether or not it will be covered, but we should know more about that soon. Further info is coming soon.
The proper fix if the vehicle is out of warranty or modified is bronze guides with Ti/Mo intake valves and OEM exhaust valves such as Katech has been doing all along. It was our experience in the C5-R and C6.R racing programs and the bronze guide/molybdenum coated intake valve which brought us to this conclusion. C5-R heads with 15,000 race miles showed virtually no measurable wear on the valve guide.
The proper fix if the vehicle is out of warranty or modified is bronze guides with Ti/Mo intake valves and OEM exhaust valves such as Katech has been doing all along. It was our experience in the C5-R and C6.R racing programs and the bronze guide/molybdenum coated intake valve which brought us to this conclusion. C5-R heads with 15,000 race miles showed virtually no measurable wear on the valve guide.
#55
Melting Slicks
Here is what you need to know right now to assess whether you are individually at risk. If you have excessive valvetrain noise or oil consumption you should have it looked at. If you are in warranty and your engine is not modified it will be covered. If you have an aftermarket cam it will not be covered. I'm not sure of what other aftermarket modifications dictate whether or not it will be covered, but we should know more about that soon. Further info is coming soon.
The proper fix if the vehicle is out of warranty or modified is bronze guides with Ti/Mo intake valves and OEM exhaust valves such as Katech has been doing all along. It was our experience in the C5-R and C6.R racing programs and the bronze guide/molybdenum coated intake valve which brought us to this conclusion. C5-R heads with 15,000 race miles showed virtually no measurable wear on the valve guide.
The proper fix if the vehicle is out of warranty or modified is bronze guides with Ti/Mo intake valves and OEM exhaust valves such as Katech has been doing all along. It was our experience in the C5-R and C6.R racing programs and the bronze guide/molybdenum coated intake valve which brought us to this conclusion. C5-R heads with 15,000 race miles showed virtually no measurable wear on the valve guide.
#56
I didn't know that, but that's good to know. And for what it's worth Jason, my post wasn't meant as an assault against Katech. I'm not looking to point a finger at anyone or to throw anyone under a bus. I'm just a concerned owner doing the best I can to sort through the various opinions and data, hoping to come to a solution that doesn't involve me replacing a motor, that's all. My '06 Z has 24k on it, I'm just hoping to hear that there's a concrete solution to this situation. I don't disbelieve Jason or anyone else. I just want to make sure when I tear the car apart it gets done right, not repaired with a band-aid. It makes me a little nervous that waiting could potentially cost me a lot of money, or nothing at all. So if anything, take my posts regarding this subject as a concerned owner that admittedly knows nothing about this, not a guy that claims to know more than anyone.
#57
ok so the two questions i have is...what is WCCH doing for the intake valves? cause there using bronze guides
and who does Katechs heads? If i went to Katech do they rebuild them there or send them out?
and who does Katechs heads? If i went to Katech do they rebuild them there or send them out?
#58
I have wondered that myself....does anyone have a sound clip of a bad valve train? mine seems quiet while driving...other then what i assume is a small injector noise coming into the cabin
#59
Premium Supporting Vendor
Nothing changed. I've been saying to replace the guides with bronze all along.
If I'm reading you right, then it's sounding like the valve guides were the problem, and going from the powdered steel valve guides to the bronze valve guides is the way to go.
However in doing that, then keep the stock exhaust valves, but change the intake valves to ti/mo coated.
So was it the valve guides which were causing the exhaust valves to fail?
I ask that question because you're not saying throw out the exhaust valves themselves, but you are saying throw out the stock (exhaust) valve guides (as well as the stock intake valve guides)and go from there.
This all would imply that there was a problem with some bad guides.
Also with regard to the part in bold above, would you please clarify:
"The proper fix if the vehicle is out of warranty or modified is bronze guides with Ti/Mo intake valves and OEM exhaust valves such as Katech has been doing all along."
Is this also the proper fix for a car which is still in warranty????
However in doing that, then keep the stock exhaust valves, but change the intake valves to ti/mo coated.
So was it the valve guides which were causing the exhaust valves to fail?
I ask that question because you're not saying throw out the exhaust valves themselves, but you are saying throw out the stock (exhaust) valve guides (as well as the stock intake valve guides)and go from there.
This all would imply that there was a problem with some bad guides.
Also with regard to the part in bold above, would you please clarify:
"The proper fix if the vehicle is out of warranty or modified is bronze guides with Ti/Mo intake valves and OEM exhaust valves such as Katech has been doing all along."
Is this also the proper fix for a car which is still in warranty????
WCCH has been doing Katech's heads as dictated by us with bronze guides and Ti/Mo intake valves.
#60
Safety Car
Member Since: Nov 1999
Location: S.E. WI.
Posts: 4,243
Received 69 Likes
on
50 Posts
St. Jude Donor '08-'09-'10
Jason, appreciate you staying involved and sharing your findings. Just curious but do you know why this is only affecting a small number of engines and not all of them?
Any idea why GM changed part # for 2009 and later exhaust valves?
Any idea why GM changed part # for 2009 and later exhaust valves?