Transmission (2016 A8) "shutters" while driving/crusing.
#1
Burning Brakes
Thread Starter
Transmission (2016 A8) "shutters" while driving/crusing.
2016 A8 Z51 with 4090 miles. I feel a "shuttering" feeling while driving at consistent cruising speeds. This came on gradually and seems to have gotten worse. I have not been on the forum in awhile, so maybe this same topic has been discussed, but in a search, I could not find it.
I brought into my local dealer, they said it was "common" and needed a "flash" for an update. While there, I had the air bag recall issue taken care of, and the complimentary oil change. They said they test drove it, and everything checked out. I did notice the shifts from gear to gear appeared smoother, however after about 10 minutes of driving I felt the first shutter. Drove it yesterday on a very smooth and level road. At 62 mph, the rpm's are @ 1500. Then comes the shutter that lasts about 2-4 seconds (some are worse and longer than others) during that time, the tach clearly drops 200-300 rpms and the needle fluctuates in conjunction with the shutter as the motor and drive train seem to fight through the problem. It is annoying as hell, and can't be a good thing as it feels the entire drive train is struggling during the problem. It is not a minor shutter, pretty severe, I counted 14 occurrences in the 4 mile run. Made another appointment for this Friday morning. I was told they will "take care of it" any ideas? Anyone else experience this problem. I use the word "shutter" because that is the best description I can think of, it is a very pronounced way beyond vibration that you feel in the entire car, seat, etc. In fact my wife said "what was that?" when it first occurred. 7th and mostly 8th gear seem the worst, but I seldom stay in 6th and below the way the trans shifts.
I brought into my local dealer, they said it was "common" and needed a "flash" for an update. While there, I had the air bag recall issue taken care of, and the complimentary oil change. They said they test drove it, and everything checked out. I did notice the shifts from gear to gear appeared smoother, however after about 10 minutes of driving I felt the first shutter. Drove it yesterday on a very smooth and level road. At 62 mph, the rpm's are @ 1500. Then comes the shutter that lasts about 2-4 seconds (some are worse and longer than others) during that time, the tach clearly drops 200-300 rpms and the needle fluctuates in conjunction with the shutter as the motor and drive train seem to fight through the problem. It is annoying as hell, and can't be a good thing as it feels the entire drive train is struggling during the problem. It is not a minor shutter, pretty severe, I counted 14 occurrences in the 4 mile run. Made another appointment for this Friday morning. I was told they will "take care of it" any ideas? Anyone else experience this problem. I use the word "shutter" because that is the best description I can think of, it is a very pronounced way beyond vibration that you feel in the entire car, seat, etc. In fact my wife said "what was that?" when it first occurred. 7th and mostly 8th gear seem the worst, but I seldom stay in 6th and below the way the trans shifts.
Popular Reply
01-25-2017, 03:10 PM
Instructor
It's a feature called "lock Up". Simply put, the TC transfers the power from the engine to the transmission hydraulically, meaning that the engine is not connected directly to the transmission on automatic cars. Rather, inside the TC you have two turbines, or fans, facing each other, submerged in transmission fluid, so when the engine side starts turning its fan, it blows the fluid onto the fan connected to transmission and subsequently starts turning that fan and moving the car. Much like blowing on a pinwheel. But since the engine is not directly connected to the trans, you can completely stop the car without stalling the engine. Needless to say, there is a huge loss of power due to the inefficiencies of this hydraulic connection. This is where "lock up" comes in. On most cars, when the transmission senses that you are in top gear and traveling at a constant 45+ MPH, it will automatically bypass the fans and connect directly to the engine, ergo the RPM drop as if you had another gear. Soon as you drop speed or accelerate to pass, it disengages until you resume a normal cruising speed again. Reason for the system is mainly fuel economy. The way the system is designed is that there is a clutch and plate in the TC that engages and disengages and the shutter is normally from a bad clutch or the "lock Up" engagement coming in or out at the wrong times. I had just purchased a new Chevy Tahoe and noticed at certain speeds and rpm, there is a slight vibration which I think is the TC coming in too early at lower gears, and I believe the car has the same 8L90-E A8 as the Corvette. So I think GM has some engineering and warranty work to do.
The following users liked this post:
vettpapaw (09-05-2017)
#3
Team Owner
Yup, likely torque converter.
See TSB in post 15:
https://www.corvetteforum.com/forums...-shudders.html
See TSB in post 15:
https://www.corvetteforum.com/forums...-shudders.html
#4
Safety Car
No doubt, you need a new torque converter, mine did the same thing. Take it to a dealer who has replaced torque converters before. The first dealer I went to said everything was normal. Took my car to a dealer who had replaced quite a few TC's and in 5 min they said I needed a new TC.
#6
Melting Slicks
Member Since: Dec 2015
Location: Just outside a swamp in Florida
Posts: 2,209
Received 929 Likes
on
522 Posts
Stingray Chevrolet
Consider taking it to Stingray Chevrolet in Plant City.
One of the members just had their transmission Repaired there. While others are talking about weeks they were done within just a couple of days, or less, If I remember correctly.
One of the members just had their transmission Repaired there. While others are talking about weeks they were done within just a couple of days, or less, If I remember correctly.
#7
Team Owner
Why do the RMPs drop if it's the TC?
#8
Drifting
No doubt, you need a new torque converter, mine did the same thing. Take it to a dealer who has replaced torque converters before. The first dealer I went to said everything was normal. Took my car to a dealer who had replaced quite a few TC's and in 5 min they said I needed a new TC.
#9
Melting Slicks
I brought into my local dealer, they said it was "common"....
...and needed a "flash" for an update.
Last edited by iclick; 01-25-2017 at 05:54 PM.
#10
Instructor
It's a feature called "lock Up". Simply put, the TC transfers the power from the engine to the transmission hydraulically, meaning that the engine is not connected directly to the transmission on automatic cars. Rather, inside the TC you have two turbines, or fans, facing each other, submerged in transmission fluid, so when the engine side starts turning its fan, it blows the fluid onto the fan connected to transmission and subsequently starts turning that fan and moving the car. Much like blowing on a pinwheel. But since the engine is not directly connected to the trans, you can completely stop the car without stalling the engine. Needless to say, there is a huge loss of power due to the inefficiencies of this hydraulic connection. This is where "lock up" comes in. On most cars, when the transmission senses that you are in top gear and traveling at a constant 45+ MPH, it will automatically bypass the fans and connect directly to the engine, ergo the RPM drop as if you had another gear. Soon as you drop speed or accelerate to pass, it disengages until you resume a normal cruising speed again. Reason for the system is mainly fuel economy. The way the system is designed is that there is a clutch and plate in the TC that engages and disengages and the shutter is normally from a bad clutch or the "lock Up" engagement coming in or out at the wrong times. I had just purchased a new Chevy Tahoe and noticed at certain speeds and rpm, there is a slight vibration which I think is the TC coming in too early at lower gears, and I believe the car has the same 8L90-E A8 as the Corvette. So I think GM has some engineering and warranty work to do.
Last edited by Gearbox22; 01-25-2017 at 03:14 PM.
The following 8 users liked this post by Gearbox22:
ben dover (01-25-2017),
Jmcdude (01-26-2017),
joemessman (01-26-2017),
LB001 (09-05-2017),
Pisswilly (09-07-2017),
and 3 others liked this post.
#12
Race Director
Member Since: Oct 2011
Location: Holly Springs NC
Posts: 14,371
Received 1,609 Likes
on
1,037 Posts
St. Jude Donor '16-'17,'22,'24
Many threads on this issue and mine is in the shop now for a TC replacement. Do a search, research thoroughly, and have your info together before approaching the dealer again. One important document is PIP5337E, which will probably sound familiar when you read it. Note that the TC part # 24279495 (Rev. 2) stated in that document has been superseded by 24280631 (Rev. 3). Make sure they use the latest TC revision!
#13
Le Mans Master
Member Since: Nov 2015
Location: Lake Havasu City Arizona
Posts: 7,326
Received 3,439 Likes
on
2,059 Posts
#14
A8 Shutter
Was able to record the shuddering noise with my phone. Is this what people are hearing? I'm coasting, then gently accelerate and the noise is constant until I go back into V8 mode.
Last edited by RIRENTERC6; 09-05-2017 at 06:13 PM.
#15
If you are observing an RPM change of over 50 RPM and/or observing a shaking in the steering wheel or seat much like driving over a rough road it is extremely likely you have a TC problem. It is likely the RPM changes and shaking will go away when you put it in V8 mode.
Refer your dealer to bulletin 16-na-175. It seems that currently the first fix is to do a "triple flush" and use Mobil 1 synthetic fluid. Had it done to mine last month and it has been good since.
RIRENTERC6 - Just by looking at your RPM changes, you have the problem. Have the dealer fix it.
Refer your dealer to bulletin 16-na-175. It seems that currently the first fix is to do a "triple flush" and use Mobil 1 synthetic fluid. Had it done to mine last month and it has been good since.
RIRENTERC6 - Just by looking at your RPM changes, you have the problem. Have the dealer fix it.
#16
Racer
Was able to record the shuttering noise with my phone. Is this what people are hearing? I'm coasting, then gently accelerate and the noise is constant until I go back into V8 mode.
https://youtu.be/1Tv3A5GpHnU
https://youtu.be/1Tv3A5GpHnU
Mine had the TC Shudder and it didn't feel or sound like that.
#17
ShuTTer is something found in a camera or beside a window. ShuDDer is a vibration or shaking.
I just can't understand why GM even bothered trying to meet their CAFE goals by putting the AFM and destined-to-fail TC lockup clutch arrangement in the Corvettes. They add several thousand dollars to the purchase price, nobody really wants them, and for sure nobody wants all the headaches they've caused. Look at all the lost sales, unhappy customers, and added warranty expense they've incurred.
C7 buyers would have been way better off just paying the gas guzzler tax on every car.
I just can't understand why GM even bothered trying to meet their CAFE goals by putting the AFM and destined-to-fail TC lockup clutch arrangement in the Corvettes. They add several thousand dollars to the purchase price, nobody really wants them, and for sure nobody wants all the headaches they've caused. Look at all the lost sales, unhappy customers, and added warranty expense they've incurred.
C7 buyers would have been way better off just paying the gas guzzler tax on every car.
#18
If you are observing an RPM change of over 50 RPM and/or observing a shaking in the steering wheel or seat much like driving over a rough road it is extremely likely you have a TC problem. It is likely the RPM changes and shaking will go away when you put it in V8 mode.
Refer your dealer to bulletin 16-na-175. It seems that currently the first fix is to do a "triple flush" and use Mobil 1 synthetic fluid. Had it done to mine last month and it has been good since.
RIRENTERC6 - Just by looking at your RPM changes, you have the problem. Have the dealer fix it.
Refer your dealer to bulletin 16-na-175. It seems that currently the first fix is to do a "triple flush" and use Mobil 1 synthetic fluid. Had it done to mine last month and it has been good since.
RIRENTERC6 - Just by looking at your RPM changes, you have the problem. Have the dealer fix it.
they completed the flush 2 weeks ago. They are now going to look into replacing the TC. I'll keep you all posted.
#19
Racer
Was able to record the shuddering noise with my phone. Is this what people are hearing? I'm coasting, then gently accelerate and the noise is constant until I go back into V8 mode.
https://youtu.be/1Tv3A5GpHnU
https://youtu.be/1Tv3A5GpHnU
Look into this TSB
http://www.corvetteactioncenter.com/...-afm-1357.html
#20
NCM Life Member
I don't notice any symptoms except for the RPM variations but this can't be a good thing.
John
Last edited by jbeidl; 09-05-2017 at 07:45 PM.