A8 vs M7, the truth!!!
#1
Drifting
Thread Starter
A8 vs M7, the truth!!!
The main difference between the two is the shifting time between gears, been the A8 the fastest... But is not the driver of the M7 fault, is the ECU that have a "safety issue" if you want it to call it something that always close the TB between shift no matter how fast you power shift your M7.
Everybody knows there is people that can drive this beast, but this "issue" it's there limitation. This info came from on good friend that is very respectable GM Tech.
Either way I don't change my M7 for A8, for me the Manual Tranny is a blast to drive
Just want to share... Oh and sorry if this topic is repost
Everybody knows there is people that can drive this beast, but this "issue" it's there limitation. This info came from on good friend that is very respectable GM Tech.
Either way I don't change my M7 for A8, for me the Manual Tranny is a blast to drive
Just want to share... Oh and sorry if this topic is repost
#2
Melting Slicks
I think I understand the gist of what you're saying. The M7 is not advertised as quick as the A8 simply due to a human involved with rowing the gears. Simply put, the computer can change gears faster than a human at this point, and the technology has increased enough to offset the negatives of the increased weight and drive train losses.
Unless you're looking to shave milliseconds, go with the one that suits your fancy. Can't go wrong with either one if you're sitting in a Z.
Unless you're looking to shave milliseconds, go with the one that suits your fancy. Can't go wrong with either one if you're sitting in a Z.
The following 2 users liked this post by alienranch:
Richmond427 (01-06-2024),
salsno (04-13-2023)
#5
Former Vendor
Auto from a roll pulls on 7 speed easy. Had some roll racing over weekend and no matter what mph 20 50 70 rolls the 7 speed just fell behind
#7
Team Owner
On average, the automatic equipped car will always beat the manual car (all else (power, race weight, options etc.) being equal) in the 1/4 mile.
On average (ie: average drivers) that is.
A great (not good, but GREAT) manual driver will typically put down a quicker and faster time than any automatic (this was true in the stock C5 LS1s and the C6 LS3s as well) though.
But with the C7s I don't know, it does seem that the torque management ("nanny") intrusions are much worse this time around in both the C7 LT1 and C7 Z06 LT4 cars leaving the automatics to still return better drag strip times.
Once modified and the tuning/programming software gets even better though the manuals WILL shine, I'm guessing.
On average (ie: average drivers) that is.
A great (not good, but GREAT) manual driver will typically put down a quicker and faster time than any automatic (this was true in the stock C5 LS1s and the C6 LS3s as well) though.
But with the C7s I don't know, it does seem that the torque management ("nanny") intrusions are much worse this time around in both the C7 LT1 and C7 Z06 LT4 cars leaving the automatics to still return better drag strip times.
Once modified and the tuning/programming software gets even better though the manuals WILL shine, I'm guessing.
#8
Safety Car
Member Since: Jun 2006
Location: Westlake Village, Ca
Posts: 3,717
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
On average, the automatic equipped car will always beat the manual car (all else (power, race weight, options etc.) being equal) in the 1/4 mile.
On average (ie: average drivers) that is.
A great (not good, but GREAT) manual driver will typically put down a quicker and faster time than any automatic (this was true in the stock C5 LS1s and the C6 LS3s as well) though.
But with the C7s I don't know, it does seem that the torque management ("nanny") intrusions are much worse this time around in both the C7 LT1 and C7 Z06 LT4 cars leaving the automatics to still return better drag strip times.
Once modified and the tuning/programming software gets even better though the manuals WILL shine, I'm guessing.
On average (ie: average drivers) that is.
A great (not good, but GREAT) manual driver will typically put down a quicker and faster time than any automatic (this was true in the stock C5 LS1s and the C6 LS3s as well) though.
But with the C7s I don't know, it does seem that the torque management ("nanny") intrusions are much worse this time around in both the C7 LT1 and C7 Z06 LT4 cars leaving the automatics to still return better drag strip times.
Once modified and the tuning/programming software gets even better though the manuals WILL shine, I'm guessing.
Nothing will beat the shifts of a fast shifting auto.
#10
Burning Brakes
The main difference between the two is the shifting time between gears, been the A8 the fastest... But is not the driver of the M7 fault, is the ECU that have a "safety issue" if you want it to call it something that always close the TB between shift no matter how fast you power shift your M7.
Everybody knows there is people that can drive this beast, but this "issue" it's there limitation. This info came from on good friend that is very respectable GM Tech.
Either way I don't change my M7 for A8, for me the Manual Tranny is a blast to drive
Just want to share... Oh and sorry if this topic is repost
Everybody knows there is people that can drive this beast, but this "issue" it's there limitation. This info came from on good friend that is very respectable GM Tech.
Either way I don't change my M7 for A8, for me the Manual Tranny is a blast to drive
Just want to share... Oh and sorry if this topic is repost
The C7 has a no lift shift option. Floor the accelerator and do not lift and no TB close occurs. The revs
go to red line and hold. No over rev. Try it you will love it......but hang on.
#11
Race Director
#12
Safety Car
The truth is the auto cars still overheat faster and they are still heavier. It's not a good choice for guys that do HPDEs. Then again most guys that do HPDEs enjoy controlling a car, so many of them are manual anyway. Certainly there is an appeal to no clutch fast shifting transmissions, and that is winning. But no one is really winning anything at an HPDE, although I'm sure many feel as if they do.
#13
The truth is the auto cars still overheat faster and they are still heavier. It's not a good choice for guys that do HPDEs. Then again most guys that do HPDEs enjoy controlling a car, so many of them are manual anyway. Certainly there is an appeal to no clutch fast shifting transmissions, and that is winning. But no one is really winning anything at an HPDE, although I'm sure many feel as if they do.
1. At a club racing weekend I noticed some of the racers were angry and upset most of the time. I tried telling them "remember, this is a hobby and we are doing this for fun." Wow, that made them much more angry. Ha.
2. Comparing the M7 to A8, yes the A8 shifts faster, but the gear ratios are different. The gap between 4-5 is huge in the A8 compared to the M7. This might explain some of the .7 second lap time difference between the two in the Motor Trend re-test with Pobst.
The A8 gear ratios seem to be optimized for 0-60 times and for EPA fuel mileage tests. This definitely dings the performance of the A8 on a road course. If the A8 had consistent, close ratio spreads between gears it might be the best trans ever, but that is not quite what we got.
I have an A8 (arrived 3 days ago) and I love it.
The following users liked this post:
Blk07Z06 (01-05-2024)
#14
Safety Car
2 things:
1. At a club racing weekend I noticed some of the racers were angry and upset most of the time. I tried telling them "remember, this is a hobby and we are doing this for fun." Wow, that made them much more angry. Ha.
2. Comparing the M7 to A8, yes the A8 shifts faster, but the gear ratios are different. The gap between 4-5 is huge in the A8 compared to the M7. This might explain some of the .7 second lap time difference between the two in the Motor Trend re-test with Pobst.
The A8 gear ratios seem to be optimized for 0-60 times and for EPA fuel mileage tests. This definitely dings the performance of the A8 on a road course. If the A8 had consistent, close ratio spreads between gears it might be the best trans ever, but that is not quite what we got.
I have an A8 (arrived 3 days ago) and I love it.
1. At a club racing weekend I noticed some of the racers were angry and upset most of the time. I tried telling them "remember, this is a hobby and we are doing this for fun." Wow, that made them much more angry. Ha.
2. Comparing the M7 to A8, yes the A8 shifts faster, but the gear ratios are different. The gap between 4-5 is huge in the A8 compared to the M7. This might explain some of the .7 second lap time difference between the two in the Motor Trend re-test with Pobst.
The A8 gear ratios seem to be optimized for 0-60 times and for EPA fuel mileage tests. This definitely dings the performance of the A8 on a road course. If the A8 had consistent, close ratio spreads between gears it might be the best trans ever, but that is not quite what we got.
I have an A8 (arrived 3 days ago) and I love it.
#15
M7 cars will rule the road courses while the A8's sit letting there's cool off. While we M7 guys will get spanked at the drag strip.
#17
Drifting
The main difference between the two is the shifting time between gears, been the A8 the fastest... But is not the driver of the M7 fault, is the ECU that have a "safety issue" if you want it to call it something that always close the TB between shift no matter how fast you power shift your M7.
Everybody knows there is people that can drive this beast, but this "issue" it's there limitation. This info came from on good friend that is very respectable GM Tech.
Either way I don't change my M7 for A8, for me the Manual Tranny is a blast to drive
Just want to share... Oh and sorry if this topic is repost
Everybody knows there is people that can drive this beast, but this "issue" it's there limitation. This info came from on good friend that is very respectable GM Tech.
Either way I don't change my M7 for A8, for me the Manual Tranny is a blast to drive
Just want to share... Oh and sorry if this topic is repost
The following users liked this post:
CRS1962 (01-05-2024)
#18
Drifting
Thread Starter
#19
Drifting
Thread Starter
On average, the automatic equipped car will always beat the manual car (all else (power, race weight, options etc.) being equal) in the 1/4 mile.
On average (ie: average drivers) that is.
A great (not good, but GREAT) manual driver will typically put down a quicker and faster time than any automatic (this was true in the stock C5 LS1s and the C6 LS3s as well) though.
But with the C7s I don't know, it does seem that the torque management ("nanny") intrusions are much worse this time around in both the C7 LT1 and C7 Z06 LT4 cars leaving the automatics to still return better drag strip times.
Once modified and the tuning/programming software gets even better though the manuals WILL shine, I'm guessing.
On average (ie: average drivers) that is.
A great (not good, but GREAT) manual driver will typically put down a quicker and faster time than any automatic (this was true in the stock C5 LS1s and the C6 LS3s as well) though.
But with the C7s I don't know, it does seem that the torque management ("nanny") intrusions are much worse this time around in both the C7 LT1 and C7 Z06 LT4 cars leaving the automatics to still return better drag strip times.
Once modified and the tuning/programming software gets even better though the manuals WILL shine, I'm guessing.
#20
Drifting
Thread Starter
I try several times and the car always put the nose down (hesitate) a little bit, not like the C6 Z06 that I have...