Is a dual-clutch transmission right for you?
#42
Melting Slicks
I have owned 11 vehicles with a dual clutch transmission. I would not own a conventional TQ- converter auto trans. Since the Corvette is not going to have a manual transmission a DCT is the only way I would buy the car.
If the DCT is programmed properly to match the engine rpm’s it’s truly a lot of fun. The fast shifts create burbles and pops from the exhaust the sound can be amazing. In one of the video”s of the C8 you could her the shift and the exhaust making pops while slowing down.
If the DCT is programmed properly to match the engine rpm’s it’s truly a lot of fun. The fast shifts create burbles and pops from the exhaust the sound can be amazing. In one of the video”s of the C8 you could her the shift and the exhaust making pops while slowing down.
Last edited by fasttoys; 07-10-2019 at 09:35 PM.
#43
Le Mans Master
Member Since: Oct 2005
Location: Metro Detroit Michigan
Posts: 7,078
Received 1,817 Likes
on
1,085 Posts
Sure, I was impressed as a teenager by modified automatics which would chirp the tires on even a part-throttle shift. It wasn't until later that I learned it really had nothing to do with being fast..
Last edited by Warp Factor; 07-10-2019 at 10:07 PM.
#44
Melting Slicks
You don't really understand transmissions. The guts of the DCT can be put in any "case" GM wants. If GM wants to put that DCT into a FWD car, I am positive they could find a way. The transaxle in the C8 is a "configuration" of a DCT from the transmission manufacturer, such as Tremec or ZF.
#45
I have a DCT in an Audi RS5 and have driven several different Porsche PDK’s in high performance manner including the Porsche Driving Experirnce program in Germany. I’m a manual guy to the bone BUT still manage to get a huge “kick” out of driving a DCT. I think the C8’s biggest challenge is getting the tranny right. Tremec has a huge lift to make a reliable DCT that is competive “feel wise” with what ZF has spent more than a decade perfecting. If the C8’s tranny falls short, it’s not possible for near perfection in everything else to make up for it. In that respect, GM is taking a huge gamble IMO.
The following users liked this post:
23/C8Z (07-11-2019)
#46
Drifting
Yes would buy it over a MT
Yeah there are FWD DCT cars. What might complicate putting the "guts" of the Corvette ME transaxle DCT version into a standard FE/RWD configuration is how the differential is integrated into the package. Expect there would be a number of parts in common but dont think it would be a straight case swap.
Anyway those worrying about will the trans be any good think its going to be will the software be any good. I am not all that worried about the mechanicals a gear box is a gear box.
Yeah there are FWD DCT cars. What might complicate putting the "guts" of the Corvette ME transaxle DCT version into a standard FE/RWD configuration is how the differential is integrated into the package. Expect there would be a number of parts in common but dont think it would be a straight case swap.
Anyway those worrying about will the trans be any good think its going to be will the software be any good. I am not all that worried about the mechanicals a gear box is a gear box.
Last edited by BEAR-AvHistory; 07-11-2019 at 08:45 AM.
#47
I had a DCT in my previous 16 M3. A great transmission that shifts fast both up and down. However it got quite boring to me. The C8 will have to be a HUGE improvement in a lot of ways for me to consider one when the Z version comes out. As for now I’m considering a low wing M7 ZR1 to be my next car in a coupe years.
#48
Safety Car
While that may feel faster, it's precisely what you don't want on a high horsepower car, which is already traction limited. "Spinnin' ain't winnin' ". That can be taken care of on either a torque converter automatic or a DCT with the proper engine and transmission programming, providing a shift which gives more even torque to the rear wheels, rather than jerking the tires loose.
Sure, I was impressed as a teenager by modified automatics which would chirp the tires on even a part-throttle shift. It wasn't until later that I learned it really had nothing to do with being fast..
Sure, I was impressed as a teenager by modified automatics which would chirp the tires on even a part-throttle shift. It wasn't until later that I learned it really had nothing to do with being fast..
#49
Le Mans Master
I have owned 11 vehicles with a dual clutch transmission. I would not own a conventional TQ- converter auto trans. Since the Corvette is not going to have a manual transmission a DCT is the only way I would buy the car.
If the DCT is programmed properly to match the engine rpm’s it’s truly a lot of fun. The fast shifts create burbles and pops from the exhaust the sound can be amazing. In one of the video”s of the C8 you could her the shift and the exhaust making pops while slowing down.
If the DCT is programmed properly to match the engine rpm’s it’s truly a lot of fun. The fast shifts create burbles and pops from the exhaust the sound can be amazing. In one of the video”s of the C8 you could her the shift and the exhaust making pops while slowing down.
Last edited by Michael A; 07-10-2019 at 11:34 PM.
#51
Instructor
Dct
The DCT in my Mercedes AMG GTS is the same transmission (7DCL750) used in the Ford GT and Ferrari California. It's the best transmission I've ever experienced. Of the 38 cars I've own in my life, I've had many manuals, including in the three Corvettes I've owned. I always preferred a manual - until I bought the GTS. Even if the C8 were offered with a manual, I'd pick the dual clutch.
The following users liked this post:
thebishman (07-11-2019)
#52
Tech Contributor
Member Since: Mar 1999
Location: Northern VA
Posts: 10,067
Received 3,809 Likes
on
1,146 Posts
"Ask Tadge" Producer
We'll see.
#53
Team Owner
Member Since: Jun 2005
Location: Northern, VA
Posts: 46,106
Received 2,481 Likes
on
1,944 Posts
St. Jude Donor '15
"In honor of jpee"
Just for a rough estimate I went and copied the following from a Porsche forum.
"If I am reading the parts diagram correctly, a new '09 Cayman S PDK transmission is 9G2-300-021-20 dealer list $27,264.66, a reman unit is 9G2-300-021-2X dealer list $12,125.42.
While it is correct that most service parts (and tech doc) are unavailable, you can get the valve body, cooler, seals, and a few other odds and ends. The valve body is often what needs attention."
"If I am reading the parts diagram correctly, a new '09 Cayman S PDK transmission is 9G2-300-021-20 dealer list $27,264.66, a reman unit is 9G2-300-021-2X dealer list $12,125.42.
While it is correct that most service parts (and tech doc) are unavailable, you can get the valve body, cooler, seals, and a few other odds and ends. The valve body is often what needs attention."
I can't find it now, but I distinctly remember when the A8 was about to be introduced, GM published some data purporting to show the A8 to be equal or better than the PDK in terms of shift speed. Most believed it at the time, and that was one reason the auto sales percentages jumped suddenly over manual.
Fast forward to today after the A8 has created so much angst, not many accept that anymore, and so many expect just going to a DCT is going to be nirvana. I think the PDK has raised DCT expectations to mythical proportions. I hope they aren't disappointed again, but this is another of those things I'm keeping my fingers crossed about.
Fast forward to today after the A8 has created so much angst, not many accept that anymore, and so many expect just going to a DCT is going to be nirvana. I think the PDK has raised DCT expectations to mythical proportions. I hope they aren't disappointed again, but this is another of those things I'm keeping my fingers crossed about.
I have to say I am not impressed with all the tailpipe firecracker theatrics of some of today's cars. Jaguar is big into this. In an F Type R in sport mode, don't let off the gas near a cop, or he/she may open fire and ask questions later. Porsche started doing this nonsense with the 718 Cayman, to cover up the lame four cylinder sound. The whole thing comes off very fake to me, and it is fake. These cars don't have carburetors. It ranks right up there with piping in pseudo exhaust sound through the stereo (are you listening BMW). Besides if you are going to have a fireworks show coming out the exhaust, activate all the senses, and do it right with flames coming out the exhaust. For those of us not into creating a sideshow, there should be a setting in the car to selectively turn all this nonsense off.
He understands reading comprehension just fine. You and NY09C6 are implying through your posts that somehow the DCT in the new car will only be in the Corvette and not shared across other platforms. I wouldn't bet on that. My speculation based on years and years of owning and understanding Corvettes is: that DCT or some form of it will find its way into other GM cars regardless of their engine layout. Amortizing costs is GM's way; without it our cars would cost vastly more than they do today. The truck guys pay for the Corvette's engine, it just gets changed enough to meet what Corvette needs. The same will likely be said about the DCT and other car lines within GM.
We'll see.
We'll see.
#54
Burning Brakes
IN
The DCT in my Mercedes AMG GTS is the same transmission (7DCL750) used in the Ford GT and Ferrari California. It's the best transmission I've ever experienced. Of the 38 cars I've own in my life, I've had many manuals, including in the three Corvettes I've owned. I always preferred a manual - until I bought the GTS. Even if the C8 were offered with a manual, I'd pick the dual clutch.
The DCT in my Mercedes AMG GTS is the same transmission (7DCL750) used in the Ford GT and Ferrari California. It's the best transmission I've ever experienced. Of the 38 cars I've own in my life, I've had many manuals, including in the three Corvettes I've owned. I always preferred a manual - until I bought the GTS. Even if the C8 were offered with a manual, I'd pick the dual clutch.
#55
PS - the folks I know who know have confirmed the manual is done. That's not terribly surprising to most of us, but there is 0% chance of a surprise manual on the 18th. That doesn't mean they might not bring it back one day, but for now... done.
#56
Le Mans Master
I'm curious how you knew how fast the shifts were. Modern DCTs don't always cut the ignition during a shift like the early ones did, producing that characteristic "bark", which some interpret as a fast shift.
The Corvette A8 doesn't either, though it will under some circumstance.
Instead, the majority of shifts are accomplished with some combination of throttle reduction, timing retard, and clutch or torque converter slippage. Jerky shifts were considered to be an indication of high performance at one time, when cars only had around 500 horsepower, but they are horrible for traction management at higher power levels.
The Corvette A8 doesn't either, though it will under some circumstance.
Instead, the majority of shifts are accomplished with some combination of throttle reduction, timing retard, and clutch or torque converter slippage. Jerky shifts were considered to be an indication of high performance at one time, when cars only had around 500 horsepower, but they are horrible for traction management at higher power levels.
#57
Race Director
This car is the biggest gamble gm will make in my lifetime.
So many things that will inherently have an issue or 2 (or 10) and this can all go sideways fast.
That's why the safe(r) approach would have been to make the ME with a conventional trans and a manual then offer the DCT and a manual over time. Just my opinion.
It seems like they are sticking to ohv engine for now. And it makes me wonder how they have this much faith in the DCT. I hope they're right as I may... be looking at the late Z06 version once I'm convinced this isn't 1984 all over again. Where every year for the next 12....they made the car better and whichever bought the year before got screwed. If they can put a car together that can make it 3 or 4yrs without huge improvements I will feel a lot more comfortable trying out an ME car..
Just tough watching the latter years if each design be night and day better then having to trade up.. in gonna try patience this time lol
So many things that will inherently have an issue or 2 (or 10) and this can all go sideways fast.
That's why the safe(r) approach would have been to make the ME with a conventional trans and a manual then offer the DCT and a manual over time. Just my opinion.
It seems like they are sticking to ohv engine for now. And it makes me wonder how they have this much faith in the DCT. I hope they're right as I may... be looking at the late Z06 version once I'm convinced this isn't 1984 all over again. Where every year for the next 12....they made the car better and whichever bought the year before got screwed. If they can put a car together that can make it 3 or 4yrs without huge improvements I will feel a lot more comfortable trying out an ME car..
Just tough watching the latter years if each design be night and day better then having to trade up.. in gonna try patience this time lol
#58
Melting Slicks
He understands reading comprehension just fine. You and NY09C6 are implying through your posts that somehow the DCT in the new car will only be in the Corvette and not shared across other platforms. I wouldn't bet on that. My speculation based on years and years of owning and understanding Corvettes is: that DCT or some form of it will find its way into other GM cars regardless of their engine layout. Amortizing costs is GM's way; without it our cars would cost vastly more than they do today. The truck guys pay for the Corvette's engine, it just gets changed enough to meet what Corvette needs. The same will likely be said about the DCT and other car lines within GM.
We'll see.
We'll see.
Taking that a step further, it we assume the C8 has 500hp and close to that in torque, what sense does it make to put a transmission that was developed for that into a car with half the power? It makes zero sense and it is something GM has never done for logical reasons.
On top of that, why would a truck need a DCT? GM already has a pretty awesome transmission in the trucks (their biggest advantage IMHO) and a truck doesn't really need super fast shifts because they aren't sports cars.
So, unless GM plans to build other cars with a longitudinal transaxle, this trans is very likely Corvette specific.
Now, can they take what they have learned and use that to build a more generic transmission? Sure, and I can see that happening. But, that is not using the same transmission. I also think DCTs are a nitch solution and as TC autos continue to iadvance, DCTs may go away. The comments from the Aston Martin CEO make alot of sense when you think about it.
Last edited by vndkshn; 07-11-2019 at 10:39 AM.
#59
Le Mans Master
IN
The DCT in my Mercedes AMG GTS is the same transmission (7DCL750) used in the Ford GT and Ferrari California. It's the best transmission I've ever experienced. Of the 38 cars I've own in my life, I've had many manuals, including in the three Corvettes I've owned. I always preferred a manual - until I bought the GTS. Even if the C8 were offered with a manual, I'd pick the dual clutch.
The DCT in my Mercedes AMG GTS is the same transmission (7DCL750) used in the Ford GT and Ferrari California. It's the best transmission I've ever experienced. Of the 38 cars I've own in my life, I've had many manuals, including in the three Corvettes I've owned. I always preferred a manual - until I bought the GTS. Even if the C8 were offered with a manual, I'd pick the dual clutch.
https://www.autoevolution.com/news/f...ce-130104.html
Last edited by NY09C6; 07-11-2019 at 10:58 AM.
#60
Melting Slicks
I'm really surprised they are betting everything on DCT. With as much change as this car will represent, I'm really surprised they are going this far. It's surprising to me they aren't releasing DCT first in a ZR1 model (maybe Z06) and then bringing to the base car (to control the release and manage development/advancement more). Going back to my earlier point, the more testing vehicles and the more test drivers, the quicker they can fix issues, but if they have tens of thousands of cars and drivers, and things go sideways, it will blow up. GM's nuts are WAY out on the chopping block with this car, and that trans could make or break it.