cannot remove distributor
#121
Team Owner
Member Since: Aug 2008
Location: Rochester NY
Posts: 31,358
Received 5,010 Likes
on
2,529 Posts
St. Jude Donor '09-'10-'11-'12-'13-'14-'15-'16-'17-'18-‘19-'20-'21-'22-'23-'24
The following 2 users liked this post by Railroadman:
Easy Rhino (02-06-2017),
hope2 (02-01-2017)
#122
Race Director
I read all the responses from 'Daren67'...and many of the other suggestions....but not the entire thread. Because if I read them correctly the main housing will spin.
I have also encountered many distributors that were really stuck and it took a bit if twisting and pulling to get it to come out. But lucky for me I got them out. But I also used my digital calipers so I could actually see I was gaining on the height and they were coming out.
From what I gather...general consensus is the roll pin is coming out and not getting past the cam gear. And what Lars commented on that not being able to do anything from the bottom of the engine would cause me to do this.
Keep this in mind. I believe you spun the engine.. BUT..I do believe that the roll pin is installed on the main shaft in the same location in relation to the top of the distributor...if I am not mistaken. I do not believe that when this hole was drilled it was done randomly. Hopefully the hole for the roll pin is not drilled randomly. If all the holes are in the exact same 'clocked' location....then knowing the angle of the hole that is drilled for the roll pin....in relation to your upper distributor area where you attach your rotor button should be the same. So you might still stop and think that even though you spun the engine....maybe it needs more because now you will know that there are only two places the distributor can be rotated to in order to get the roll pin away from the gear area of the cam. Did that make sense???? I know there are more than just twp places for the distributor to be positioned...but I feel some may get what I am trying to convey.
OR...
The one option if that I would try is to pull the timing chain cover and begin the process of attempting to get parts loosened or removed so the cam can slide forwards a little bit to the roll pin can get past the cam gear. I feel that if the cam came forward an 1/8"...it may come out....if not then 3/16"...which should not cause for lifter to drop out and get caught up. My only possible concern might be the fuel pump push rod...but that may be OK also. But with teh fuel pump push rods diameter being smaller than a lifter...that is was raises my concern...so dropping a fuel pump to me is no big deal.
I feel that this should work due if the roll pin is coming out..it can only be out far enough that it would interfere withe cam gear BUT also be effective in holding the distributor gear on the main shaft. I seriously doubt that the roll pin is so far out that it is actually extended past the outer circumference of the distributor gear itself. If it were...the gear would come off...I think. I would have to check that tomorrow at work to see if I am correct.
And if all else fails....
I know this may **** some of you off...but oh well. I would more than likely end up dropping the pan just to make sure what I am going to do does not damage the engine internally. But I would cut the distributor below the area where the cap is mounted.
I would pull out the housing....and hopefully because the housing is now out...the main shaft with the gear would have enough play in it to allow the shaft to get past the cam gear.
I currently do not have an engine torn down so I could actually cut one of my old distributors with a roll pin extended otu of it and check and see if what I am thinking is plausible.
'Daren67'
I applaud you ability to not give up...many people by this point would more than likely lost patience and really did more damage then if they just took their time. You have put a lot more into this than I would...but I do this stuff for a living and when the inevitable is staring me in the face..I have to go with it.
DUB
I have also encountered many distributors that were really stuck and it took a bit if twisting and pulling to get it to come out. But lucky for me I got them out. But I also used my digital calipers so I could actually see I was gaining on the height and they were coming out.
From what I gather...general consensus is the roll pin is coming out and not getting past the cam gear. And what Lars commented on that not being able to do anything from the bottom of the engine would cause me to do this.
Keep this in mind. I believe you spun the engine.. BUT..I do believe that the roll pin is installed on the main shaft in the same location in relation to the top of the distributor...if I am not mistaken. I do not believe that when this hole was drilled it was done randomly. Hopefully the hole for the roll pin is not drilled randomly. If all the holes are in the exact same 'clocked' location....then knowing the angle of the hole that is drilled for the roll pin....in relation to your upper distributor area where you attach your rotor button should be the same. So you might still stop and think that even though you spun the engine....maybe it needs more because now you will know that there are only two places the distributor can be rotated to in order to get the roll pin away from the gear area of the cam. Did that make sense???? I know there are more than just twp places for the distributor to be positioned...but I feel some may get what I am trying to convey.
OR...
The one option if that I would try is to pull the timing chain cover and begin the process of attempting to get parts loosened or removed so the cam can slide forwards a little bit to the roll pin can get past the cam gear. I feel that if the cam came forward an 1/8"...it may come out....if not then 3/16"...which should not cause for lifter to drop out and get caught up. My only possible concern might be the fuel pump push rod...but that may be OK also. But with teh fuel pump push rods diameter being smaller than a lifter...that is was raises my concern...so dropping a fuel pump to me is no big deal.
I feel that this should work due if the roll pin is coming out..it can only be out far enough that it would interfere withe cam gear BUT also be effective in holding the distributor gear on the main shaft. I seriously doubt that the roll pin is so far out that it is actually extended past the outer circumference of the distributor gear itself. If it were...the gear would come off...I think. I would have to check that tomorrow at work to see if I am correct.
And if all else fails....
I know this may **** some of you off...but oh well. I would more than likely end up dropping the pan just to make sure what I am going to do does not damage the engine internally. But I would cut the distributor below the area where the cap is mounted.
I would pull out the housing....and hopefully because the housing is now out...the main shaft with the gear would have enough play in it to allow the shaft to get past the cam gear.
I currently do not have an engine torn down so I could actually cut one of my old distributors with a roll pin extended otu of it and check and see if what I am thinking is plausible.
'Daren67'
I applaud you ability to not give up...many people by this point would more than likely lost patience and really did more damage then if they just took their time. You have put a lot more into this than I would...but I do this stuff for a living and when the inevitable is staring me in the face..I have to go with it.
DUB
#123
Team Owner
Member Since: Mar 2003
Location: Greenville, Indiana
Posts: 26,118
Received 1,843 Likes
on
1,398 Posts
Now there's an original idea for a change!
#124
Team Owner
Look on the bright side, if you throw enough money at this problem the problem will go away.
#125
Melting Slicks
I'm sorry but cutting the distributor off only leaves a useless hunk of metal still stabbed into and stuck in the guys engine block. Then what?
Keep yanking, spraying? Getting mad at it never works. If it was working well before all this maybe just clamp it back down an leave it.
If the OP is dead set on removal this needs a second set of eyes on it.
Keep yanking, spraying? Getting mad at it never works. If it was working well before all this maybe just clamp it back down an leave it.
If the OP is dead set on removal this needs a second set of eyes on it.
#126
Safety Car
Member Since: Jan 2006
Location: Smyrna/Vinings, Georgia
Posts: 3,662
Received 358 Likes
on
241 Posts
So, one more shot. If when the distributor is in correct position, there should be play moving shaft up and down. So, when distributor is pulled out to position where it is stuck, if there still is same play, problem is in housing, if no play problem is shaft.
#127
Drifting
Guys, appreciate everyone's help. Please bear in mine I work 8-7pm EST and have many young kids to put to bed. I work on the Vette 9pm-10pm (or when the wife calls me up).
To answer some questions: 1) The dist Shaft comes up only 1/2 inch and cannot clear the cam. So when I turn the shaft clockwise it sits right back down on the cam. So the rotor actually never moved since I have been trying to get out. 2) I have used some force but not excessive force yet. I am being patient on this as car is stock and intake is aluminum and I do not want to be pulling oil pan or engine in my garage. The car was apart for one year 2015 for paint and want to drive the thing come this April. I do not have own a prybar. All I have is a medium screwdriver, 2ft crowbar, and 1x2 piece of solid maple wood 6ft long. 3) I have tried Lars approach (pulled plugs/rotated engine) but only did 180 degrees this morning before work (at 7am). I will try the remaining 180 degrees tonight after I pick up some PB, Kroil or WD 40. I thank everyone for your help with this. And will report back either late tonight or first thing tomorrow am.
To answer some questions: 1) The dist Shaft comes up only 1/2 inch and cannot clear the cam. So when I turn the shaft clockwise it sits right back down on the cam. So the rotor actually never moved since I have been trying to get out. 2) I have used some force but not excessive force yet. I am being patient on this as car is stock and intake is aluminum and I do not want to be pulling oil pan or engine in my garage. The car was apart for one year 2015 for paint and want to drive the thing come this April. I do not have own a prybar. All I have is a medium screwdriver, 2ft crowbar, and 1x2 piece of solid maple wood 6ft long. 3) I have tried Lars approach (pulled plugs/rotated engine) but only did 180 degrees this morning before work (at 7am). I will try the remaining 180 degrees tonight after I pick up some PB, Kroil or WD 40. I thank everyone for your help with this. And will report back either late tonight or first thing tomorrow am.
Listen to GTOguy, he does this stuff for a living.
Just pulling or prying is not the same as using an impact tool. Think of a valve cover, water pump, or intake manifold that's held in place with Permatex - pull all you want and it ain't coming off, but a couple of strikes with a dead blow and -- voila!
The following users liked this post:
GTOguy (02-02-2017)
#128
Race Director
Member Since: Apr 2015
Location: Fresno California
Posts: 17,505
Received 3,443 Likes
on
2,113 Posts
All due respect, cutting the dizzy in half is batsh!t crazy, IMO.
#129
Burning Brakes
Thread Starter
No play when it's up 1/2 inch. A forum member GCD1962 may be gracious enough to to peak at it Sunday. Watch he sees the dist bolt still in.....just kidding.
#130
Race Director
Member Since: Apr 2015
Location: Fresno California
Posts: 17,505
Received 3,443 Likes
on
2,113 Posts
I was a bit harsh in my last post and apologize for that. But I'm glad you're getting other eyes on it. Cutting the distributor in half will result in metal shavings in the engine, a broken distributor, and a piece of it still lodged in the engine. Do that, and you'll be pulling the engine, tearing it down, and boiling it out to get rid of all the metal debris. Get other eyes on it and go from there. Kudos to you for having the patience so far not to do anything rash and destroy anything. Since the dizzy has been out fairly recently, I don't think it's sludge or varnish. We will wait and see if Lars does his lab experiment with the roll pin and the indexing of the dizzy shaft and will look forward to results, and your ultimate solution for this issue! Good luck.
Jeff
Jeff
#131
Team Owner
Member Since: Mar 2003
Location: Greenville, Indiana
Posts: 26,118
Received 1,843 Likes
on
1,398 Posts
Now here's a thought not suggested yet.
Never mind the arrows and text in this picture of the block. Look at the block where the distributor goes through it.
Any chance the intake manifold was sealed up in the back with silicone instead of a rubber gasket? Taken a little further, any chance an excess amount of silicone was used and it squeezed into the real estate of the distributor when it was installed? On the next machined surface down from the gasket.
I don't have anything here to measure it but lifting the distributor about a 1/2" sounds about right for this scenario. But you should be able to feel this interference if that's the case.
Never mind the arrows and text in this picture of the block. Look at the block where the distributor goes through it.
Any chance the intake manifold was sealed up in the back with silicone instead of a rubber gasket? Taken a little further, any chance an excess amount of silicone was used and it squeezed into the real estate of the distributor when it was installed? On the next machined surface down from the gasket.
I don't have anything here to measure it but lifting the distributor about a 1/2" sounds about right for this scenario. But you should be able to feel this interference if that's the case.
Last edited by MikeM; 02-02-2017 at 11:57 AM.
#132
Safety Car
If you cut the distributor mainshaft "football" off and file it smooth with a chamfer, you can then slide the points cam off the top of the shaft, pull out the distributor housing, and then you have room to manipulate the mainshaft/gear/pin until it clears to pull it out from the top.
Last edited by 65tripleblack; 02-02-2017 at 12:05 PM.
#133
Team Owner
Member Since: Aug 2008
Location: Rochester NY
Posts: 31,358
Received 5,010 Likes
on
2,529 Posts
St. Jude Donor '09-'10-'11-'12-'13-'14-'15-'16-'17-'18-‘19-'20-'21-'22-'23-'24
#134
Team Owner
Well I did say I tend to take the extreme route sometimes.
#135
Team Owner
Good thought Mike - I covered that in post #35 though...the pictures help.
I think its between the roll pin and the issue you cite...
I think its between the roll pin and the issue you cite...
#137
Team Owner
Member Since: Mar 2003
Location: Greenville, Indiana
Posts: 26,118
Received 1,843 Likes
on
1,398 Posts
#138
Race Director
#139
Team Owner
If this is a roll pin issue the only way to resolve it is from the top. The dist will have to be disassembled down to the shaft so you can hopefully move it sideways to get the shaft out.
I have search the internet for a cutaway view of this area but no luck.
I have search the internet for a cutaway view of this area but no luck.