Want input on my plan for engine oil and transmission coolers
#1
Safety Car
Thread Starter
Want input on my plan for engine oil and transmission coolers
After finding out I needed to do a trans filter and fluid changeout, I decided to add a transmission cooler to my car - a Hayden 678 trans cooler which has a core size of 11" x 7.5" x .75" (the barbs for the lines are 3/8") and looks like the factory z06 and z51 engine oil coolers. I also bought a second one to use as an engine oil cooler just because of this (the $35 dollar price is also very reasonable compared to the ridiculous amount the factory wants to charge). I know I could go with a larger cooler as some folks who road race get temp issues after longer runs, but would like to stay in this range because it has to survive on the street in the cold and any hard driving will be for shorter sessions.
Rather than route the lines for the transmission from the radiator return to the cooler and back to the return in order to allow the transmission to warm up, I plan to sandwich the transmission cooler between the radiator and the new engine oil cooler which will sit in front. This should allow the transmission some heat to get to operating temp in the winter, but still keep it cooler (than using the radiator based trans cooler) in the summer on harder drives.
My one concern - on one of haydens catalogs they use a blanket statement for almost all their products (many of which look nothing like the parts similar to the factory style units I bought) saying not to use transmission coolers for engine oil because of the possibility of flow restrictions.
aside from the length and width (these coolers are in between the size of a Z51 and the Z06), everything about the cores of the coolers I purchased looks exactly like what GM used for engine oil on the ls3 and ls7.
I have attached photographs of the cooler design - Im hoping to get some input as far as whether its the worst idea in mankind or worth trying. Im not afraid of R&D and would obviously test/compare engine oil pressure while idling prior to driving and then keep monitoring it while taking it easy driving after first installing to make sure everything is ok...
thanks!
EDIT:
Here are pictures of the factory ones (Z51 and Z06) for comparison to the hayden:
Rather than route the lines for the transmission from the radiator return to the cooler and back to the return in order to allow the transmission to warm up, I plan to sandwich the transmission cooler between the radiator and the new engine oil cooler which will sit in front. This should allow the transmission some heat to get to operating temp in the winter, but still keep it cooler (than using the radiator based trans cooler) in the summer on harder drives.
My one concern - on one of haydens catalogs they use a blanket statement for almost all their products (many of which look nothing like the parts similar to the factory style units I bought) saying not to use transmission coolers for engine oil because of the possibility of flow restrictions.
aside from the length and width (these coolers are in between the size of a Z51 and the Z06), everything about the cores of the coolers I purchased looks exactly like what GM used for engine oil on the ls3 and ls7.
I have attached photographs of the cooler design - Im hoping to get some input as far as whether its the worst idea in mankind or worth trying. Im not afraid of R&D and would obviously test/compare engine oil pressure while idling prior to driving and then keep monitoring it while taking it easy driving after first installing to make sure everything is ok...
thanks!
EDIT:
Here are pictures of the factory ones (Z51 and Z06) for comparison to the hayden:
Last edited by el es tu; 09-08-2014 at 02:57 PM.
#3
Safety Car
Member Since: Nov 2000
Location: Shenandoah Valley Virginia
Posts: 4,549
Likes: 0
Received 27 Likes
on
24 Posts
Two comments / thoughts. First do not stack the coolers. You are looking for cool air flow to bring the fluid temps down. You do not want to "preheat" the air flowing into the second cooler. If you are worried about warm up in winter months, make a removable cover for the tranny cooler. That's what I did on my Z06 engine oil cooler. Second - DO NOT use a cooler designed for transmissions on an engine oil system. BELIEVE the manufacturer's statement. The cooling tubes are designed for less flow and often have "swirl generators" inside them to slow down oil flow to get max heat transfer and greater cooling.
#4
Safety Car
Thread Starter
I guess Ill have to wait to do my engine oil cooling... (will likely go with the drm setrab setup)
New plan is to use both of the haydens stacked together for the trans fluid cooling, but tap off the return line so I can get some heat to the transmission on cold days.
Thanks for the quick reply!
Two comments / thoughts. First do not stack the coolers. You are looking for cool air flow to bring the fluid temps down. You do not want to "preheat" the air flowing into the second cooler. If you are worried about warm up in winter months, make a removable cover for the tranny cooler. That's what I did on my Z06 engine oil cooler. Second - DO NOT use a cooler designed for transmissions on an engine oil system. BELIEVE the manufacturer's statement. The cooling tubes are designed for less flow and often have "swirl generators" inside them to slow down oil flow to get max heat transfer and greater cooling.
I could put these side by side, but not sure if its as big of a deal is theyre both going to be used for the transmission now... My concern is blocking off the radiator too much - especially if Im going to add an engine oil cooler down the road (meaning when I can afford it )
Thanks!
Last edited by el es tu; 09-08-2014 at 03:24 PM.
#5
Safety Car
Thread Starter
idea for dual trans cooler setup
metal line would be used for the bend between the two due to the fact that rubber hose has to be a minimum of a 3" bend and this would be much tighter than that...
total core dimensions would be 1.5" x 7.5" x 11.0" I hope this would be enough to keep it cool while still using the radiator "cooler" [heater]
btw only reason for tieing in to the radiator setup is for warming in the winter because some folks say running hard in cold temps is bad for autos, however the A6 has different pressure commands for different temp ranges, so Im not so sure if I even need to warm it up for longevity (as opposed to most older automatics that dont have the benefit of picking pressure based on temp) - any thoughts on this?
metal line would be used for the bend between the two due to the fact that rubber hose has to be a minimum of a 3" bend and this would be much tighter than that...
total core dimensions would be 1.5" x 7.5" x 11.0" I hope this would be enough to keep it cool while still using the radiator "cooler" [heater]
btw only reason for tieing in to the radiator setup is for warming in the winter because some folks say running hard in cold temps is bad for autos, however the A6 has different pressure commands for different temp ranges, so Im not so sure if I even need to warm it up for longevity (as opposed to most older automatics that dont have the benefit of picking pressure based on temp) - any thoughts on this?
Last edited by el es tu; 09-08-2014 at 04:13 PM.
#7
Tech Contributor
Member Since: Oct 1999
Location: Charlotte, NC (formerly Endicott, NY)
Posts: 40,096
Received 8,930 Likes
on
5,334 Posts
Bill
#8
Melting Slicks
Member Since: Jul 2010
Location: Tacoma, Wa/Surprise, Az
Posts: 2,849
Received 195 Likes
on
166 Posts
Ernie,
Mine doesn't have enough capacity.
I'm thinking of installing a Z06 engine oil cooler.
For the transmission and pertinent to this thread, the differential on the A-6s is certainly part of the culprit for all of the heat generation. I'm currently thinking if I abandon the DeWitts EOC in the radiator, perhaps I could use it to cool the differential oil if the diff oil pump generates enough 'head' pressure.
Thoughts?
Mine doesn't have enough capacity.
I'm thinking of installing a Z06 engine oil cooler.
For the transmission and pertinent to this thread, the differential on the A-6s is certainly part of the culprit for all of the heat generation. I'm currently thinking if I abandon the DeWitts EOC in the radiator, perhaps I could use it to cool the differential oil if the diff oil pump generates enough 'head' pressure.
Thoughts?
#9
Race Director
Member Since: Sep 2007
Location: Peoria/Phoenix AZ
Posts: 16,555
Received 2,061 Likes
on
1,505 Posts
C6 of Year Finalist (performance mods) 2019
If you mount the cooler horizontally at the bottom of the radiator, instead of vertically in front of the radiator, you won't block direct airflow to the radiator.
Then run an inline t-stat to control the downside temps.
Then run an inline t-stat to control the downside temps.
#10
Race Director
Member Since: Aug 2005
Location: Hudson WI
Posts: 13,598
Received 181 Likes
on
162 Posts
NCM Sinkhole Donor
I did a Z06 engine oil cooler. Bolts up and works great.When guys put blowers on Z06s, they sell the coolers, so you can normally find them with the line for about $300 in the parts section.