Roll cages versus rollbars++
#1
Team Owner
Thread Starter
Member Since: Apr 2001
Location: Overwhelmed as one would be, placed in my position.... DFW, TX
Posts: 36,451
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
St. Jude Donor '05
Roll cages versus rollbars++
In my continuing quest to make a streetable C4 track car, I've come to the safety requirements and the rollcage decision.
Background info can be found HERE.
I've heard rumors of how flexible the C4 chassis is and that substantial strengthening will be required before suspension modifications will be successful. Now, I know a rollcage will provide significantly more protection and chassis stiffening versus an R-D rollbar and X-brace. Of course, it'll cost nearly twice as much and transform the door sill into an even less desireable tangle of tubes to clear when entering/exiting the car. For a race car this isn't a huge deal, but this will be a street car too.
So: is the rollcage worth pursuing or should I just be happy with the R-D racing rollbar and X-brace (and maybe the camber brace) and save myself a grand? That $1000 will buy five weekends of racing or a nice seat and harnesses.....
At this point in time, I have absolutely ZERO desire to do any wheel-to-wheel racing, nor am I a good driver.
Background info can be found HERE.
I've heard rumors of how flexible the C4 chassis is and that substantial strengthening will be required before suspension modifications will be successful. Now, I know a rollcage will provide significantly more protection and chassis stiffening versus an R-D rollbar and X-brace. Of course, it'll cost nearly twice as much and transform the door sill into an even less desireable tangle of tubes to clear when entering/exiting the car. For a race car this isn't a huge deal, but this will be a street car too.
So: is the rollcage worth pursuing or should I just be happy with the R-D racing rollbar and X-brace (and maybe the camber brace) and save myself a grand? That $1000 will buy five weekends of racing or a nice seat and harnesses.....
At this point in time, I have absolutely ZERO desire to do any wheel-to-wheel racing, nor am I a good driver.
#2
if you want to keep the car streetable, imo, skip the cage unless you wear a helmet all the time
in an accident, you really dont want to hit your head on a roll cage tube without a helmet on...the high density padding is still very hard material...i'd stick with a 4pt roll bar...
in an accident, you really dont want to hit your head on a roll cage tube without a helmet on...the high density padding is still very hard material...i'd stick with a 4pt roll bar...
#3
Melting Slicks
Member Since: Sep 2001
Location: Gig Harbor WA
Posts: 2,068
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Are you on Crack?
You just bought the car, have no HPDE experience, and think you need a cage?
Look, safer is safer but neither is necessary for HPDE.
My next track car will use stock seat belts only (as did my last street/track car, not even a 6 point harness)
You need to understand that HPDE is for driver improvement. You aren't racing.
You shouldn't be driving hard enough to need to worry about that.
If you are so aggressive that you do drive that hard, buy a racecar.
You just bought the car, have no HPDE experience, and think you need a cage?
Look, safer is safer but neither is necessary for HPDE.
My next track car will use stock seat belts only (as did my last street/track car, not even a 6 point harness)
You need to understand that HPDE is for driver improvement. You aren't racing.
You shouldn't be driving hard enough to need to worry about that.
If you are so aggressive that you do drive that hard, buy a racecar.
#5
I agree with the what are you thinking comment.
Get some seat time and then figure out what you want to do.
You may want to do wheel to wheel, may say hey I want a different track car,etc..
So leave your car alone and go practice.
Get some seat time and then figure out what you want to do.
You may want to do wheel to wheel, may say hey I want a different track car,etc..
So leave your car alone and go practice.
#8
Burning Brakes
Member Since: Jan 2005
Location: Littleton CO
Posts: 1,170
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
St. Jude Donor '07
As someone else mentioned a roll cage is a bit over kill for HPDE days. If you want to be on the safe side, like myself, then go with a nice 4 point roll bar. I have been driving for many years and just felt myself getting faster and faster and wanted to have it "just in case". But for someone who is just beginning and should be taking it slow to begin with you don't need one.
A race seat would be nice, but I still use my factory seats with a 5-point harness. Before I had the roll bar I had a harness bar to mount the shoulder straps too.
Roll cage and street driving don't mix...
A race seat would be nice, but I still use my factory seats with a 5-point harness. Before I had the roll bar I had a harness bar to mount the shoulder straps too.
Roll cage and street driving don't mix...
#9
Melting Slicks
Member Since: Sep 2001
Location: Gig Harbor WA
Posts: 2,068
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by redvetracr
If "crack" is cheaper and LESS addictive than racing?? it might be worth a try!!
...redvetracr
...redvetracr
Racing is an addiction only cured by poverty
#11
Melting Slicks
Originally Posted by Evan Ginsberg
The thing in the roof, covered in fiberglass, between the rear hatch and the targa panel???
Ya that thing, that IS a roll bar.
Ya that thing, that IS a roll bar.
Ya Think?
#12
Race Director
Originally Posted by Evan Ginsberg
Racing is an addiction only cured by poverty
...redvetracr
#13
Team Owner
Member Since: Mar 2001
Location: Boston, Dallas, Detroit, SoCal, back to Boston MA
Posts: 30,641
Received 239 Likes
on
167 Posts
Let's give the guy credit, his 1st mod is for safety. Most guys make it faster, then worry about saftey.
A cage is a little easier to do in an early C4, due to the interior. A 4pt rollbar is relatively easy on early and late models. You can get the 4pt and then upgrade it later to either a 6pt, with pullout bars, or a full cage. They're require for the faster drag cars, though the tubing is smaller than SCCA requirements, so be careful about that. Ask in the C4 Tech section.
That said, I'm doing HPDE w/o one.
Ya Think?
That's getting me thinking about one.
OUCH!
A cage is a little easier to do in an early C4, due to the interior. A 4pt rollbar is relatively easy on early and late models. You can get the 4pt and then upgrade it later to either a 6pt, with pullout bars, or a full cage. They're require for the faster drag cars, though the tubing is smaller than SCCA requirements, so be careful about that. Ask in the C4 Tech section.
That said, I'm doing HPDE w/o one.
Originally Posted by turtlevette
Ya Think?
OUCH!
#14
Melting Slicks
Member Since: Sep 2001
Location: Gig Harbor WA
Posts: 2,068
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Evan Ginsberg
The thing in the roof, covered in fiberglass, between the rear hatch and the targa panel???
Ya that thing, that is a roll bar.
Ya that thing, that is a roll bar.
OK, if you are getting one, plan on welding it to the chassis, not bolting to fiberglass
C4R has a 12 pt cage w NASCAR door bars, but it is a racecar
Last edited by DREGSZ; 02-12-2006 at 03:22 PM.
#15
Pro
Member Since: Jun 2003
Location: Cincinnati Ohio
Posts: 671
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by redvetracr
If "crack" is cheaper and LESS addictive than racing?? it might be worth a try!!
...redvetracr
...redvetracr
This has to be the quote of the year!...
#16
I agree actually after seeing that photo and money got the best of me.
Do at least a solo1 rear rollbar minimum.
I have it in my current car. Not in the way really at all and is worth at least 1 second when going around the track due to piece of mind.
Do at least a solo1 rear rollbar minimum.
I have it in my current car. Not in the way really at all and is worth at least 1 second when going around the track due to piece of mind.
#17
Team Owner
Thread Starter
Member Since: Apr 2001
Location: Overwhelmed as one would be, placed in my position.... DFW, TX
Posts: 36,451
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
St. Jude Donor '05
Thanks for the replies, guys.
I picked up the car yesterday!
The Apex Driving school here at MSR-Cresson is $200 for 7-8 sessions. So $1000 WILL get me 5 weekends of track time.
I agree that I'm still a novice, but I want to make sure it's safe when I go out there this time. I never really felt safe in my 'vert (for obvious reasons!). Looks like the four-point rollbar and a cross-brace are the way to go for now, as I suspected. I just wanted to make sure!
I picked up the car yesterday!
The Apex Driving school here at MSR-Cresson is $200 for 7-8 sessions. So $1000 WILL get me 5 weekends of track time.
I agree that I'm still a novice, but I want to make sure it's safe when I go out there this time. I never really felt safe in my 'vert (for obvious reasons!). Looks like the four-point rollbar and a cross-brace are the way to go for now, as I suspected. I just wanted to make sure!
#18
Le Mans Master
Member Since: Nov 2004
Location: Goleta CA
Posts: 6,566
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
Cruise-In VIII Veteran
Originally Posted by Umrswimr
The Apex Driving school here at MSR-Cresson is $200 for 7-8 sessions. So $1000 WILL get me 5 weekends of track time.
#19
Safety Car
Originally Posted by Umrswimr
Thanks for the replies, guys.
I picked up the car yesterday!
The Apex Driving school here at MSR-Cresson is $200 for 7-8 sessions. So $1000 WILL get me 5 weekends of track time.
I agree that I'm still a novice, but I want to make sure it's safe when I go out there this time. I never really felt safe in my 'vert (for obvious reasons!). Looks like the four-point rollbar and a cross-brace are the way to go for now, as I suspected. I just wanted to make sure!
I picked up the car yesterday!
The Apex Driving school here at MSR-Cresson is $200 for 7-8 sessions. So $1000 WILL get me 5 weekends of track time.
I agree that I'm still a novice, but I want to make sure it's safe when I go out there this time. I never really felt safe in my 'vert (for obvious reasons!). Looks like the four-point rollbar and a cross-brace are the way to go for now, as I suspected. I just wanted to make sure!
Figure in brakes, rotors, fuel, tires, etc, also if on the road hotel and towing.
For me carbotech brake pads front 1.5 weekends $150, fuel for the weekend $100, towing fuel $100, Tires figure at least $200 maybe double that. Figure in rotors and other stuff that will break if you are not out there driving like grandma.
I think AU engl had estimated about $700 per weekend, I think that is a pretty good guess.
I know the last 3 day weekend I did at viper days was well over 1k with everything.