Mitchell Collision Estimating & Reference Guide
I am am appraiser and I work for an insurance company..
#1 Does your car have a 1 piece frt end?
#2 I fit does than a 1 piece ecklers frt end is what your entitled to.
#3 If you have orignal fiberglass with bonding strips there is no way I would accept an a/m 1 piece frt end
#4 why is getting an agreed price to repair your car between the shop and your insurer your problem
#5 36 hours is fair labour hours to r&r frt end
#6 12 hours to refinish frt end is fair plus time to blend time for the doors in the finish is a b/c c/c.
#7 wet sand and polish will likley be required
EVERYTHYING IS DEPENDENT ON THE QUALITY OF YOUR CAR
BOTTOM LINE....Let shop & your insurer saw off the price...at the end the vehicle must pre restored to its pre accident condition.
I live in Canada but we have the same cars up here.
good luck
Nic
I am am appraiser and I work for an insurance company..
#1 Does your car have a 1 piece frt end?
#2 I fit does than a 1 piece ecklers frt end is what your entitled to.
#3 If you have orignal fiberglass with bonding strips there is no way I would accept an a/m 1 piece frt end
#4 why is getting an agreed price to repair your car between the shop and your insurer your problem
#5 36 hours is fair labour hours to r&r frt end
#6 12 hours to refinish frt end is fair plus time to blend time for the doors in the finish is a b/c c/c.
#7 wet sand and polish will likley be required
EVERYTHYING IS DEPENDENT ON THE QUALITY OF YOUR CAR
BOTTOM LINE....Let shop & your insurer saw off the price...at the end the vehicle must pre restored to its pre accident condition.
I live in Canada but we have the same cars up here.
good luck
Nic
#4 You of all people should know the answer to that question. We as shops have to deal with this all of the time. The fact is, as an insurance company, HE IS , your customer, not the shop. The shop is in the middle. You tell the shop what he can charge per hour, you control the system, you ultimately have the power. If the shop needs more per hour, he has to squeeze the customer. Remember he is your customer.
#6 I will hire you to paint for me. On insurance figures, you will starve. Remember P pages? Y`all never seem to do that. Those numbers are based on new parts already basically ready to paint, on new vehicles, with no damage, and no old paint on them. It will take you 12 hours to get repro panels ready to paint, much less paint them, and then you are going to nickle and dime me to death on adjacent panel deductions and such nonsense.
Other than that, you seem to be a reasonable guy.
The Best of Corvette for Corvette Enthusiasts
. Please refer to my comment that "EVERYTHING IS DEPENDENT ON THE QUALITY OF YOUR CAR" Before you go on with your comments about starving. I have seen vettes, as I am sure you have I wouldn't even change the cartridge on my roller so I could match the quality of the paint on them. Cut me some slack on your comments I really don't know if you are working on a "silk purse or the sow's ear"
It is so nice to deal with competent people no matter which side of the fence you are standing on be it on the insurance side or in the shop. I have spent 18 of my 33 years in this industry in the shop. And there are definently people out there who should be arrested for impersonating an appraiser...just got no clue.
There should be an automatic 10% premium on labour rate just to deal with corvette owners...they can be pretty bazaar at times.
Just gotta carry on PLAYING the game.
Pretty tough making a living on Corvette Restoration.
Best regards
. Please refer to my comment that "EVERYTHING IS DEPENDENT ON THE QUALITY OF YOUR CAR" Before you go on with your comments about starving. I have seen vettes, as I am sure you have I wouldn't even change the cartridge on my roller so I could match the quality of the paint on them. Cut me some slack on your comments I really don't know if you are working on a "silk purse or the sow's ear"
It is so nice to deal with competent people no matter which side of the fence you are standing on be it on the insurance side or in the shop. I have spent 18 of my 33 years in this industry in the shop. And there are definently people out there who should be arrested for impersonating an appraiser...just got no clue.
There should be an automatic 10% premium on labour rate just to deal with corvette owners...they can be pretty bazaar at times.
Just gotta carry on PLAYING the game.
Pretty tough making a living on Corvette Restoration.
Best regards
You, sorry when I say you I mean the insurance companies, have to admit, you have shops by the b@11s. When insurance companies do prevailing rate surveys, they come around and tell what they will pay and then go back and report that as the prevailing rate. This sets an artificially low rate. For example go to a Chevy dealer and ask at their service dept. what the labor rate is, Insurance companies have no control there, and you are going to find it is at least 1/3 more than it is at the same dealership`s body shop. Now does that sound reasonable considering that a service dept. needs far less expensive equipment, and most techs are basically parts changers? The body shop, on the other hand, needs paint booths, frame machines, alignment racks etc. and the tech is a sculpturer and an artist. He has to satisfy the most demanding customers eye. He gets much less pay?
I am sure that you are a great adjuster and you seem to know your business. I am sure that we would get along fine if we had to work together.
Last edited by wombvette; Feb 29, 2008 at 11:46 PM.
I am am appraiser and I work for an insurance company..
#1 Does your car have a 1 piece frt end?
#2 I fit does than a 1 piece ecklers frt end is what your entitled to.
#3 If you have orignal fiberglass with bonding strips there is no way I would accept an a/m 1 piece frt end
#4 why is getting an agreed price to repair your car between the shop and your insurer your problem
#5 36 hours is fair labour hours to r&r frt end
#6 12 hours to refinish frt end is fair plus time to blend time for the doors in the finish is a b/c c/c.
#7 wet sand and polish will likley be required
EVERYTHYING IS DEPENDENT ON THE QUALITY OF YOUR CAR
BOTTOM LINE....Let shop & your insurer saw off the price...at the end the vehicle must pre restored to its pre accident condition.
I live in Canada but we have the same cars up here.
good luck
Nic
The bodyshop generally does not do insurance jobs...they do corvette restorations. They charge the customer for labor and materials. The customer pays up-to-date after each 40 hours of labor. For me, the bodyshop is willing to do an insurance job but does not agree with labor hours listed on the appraisal. The bodyshop thought the Mitchell manual would provide a more accurate estimate of labor (and it's documented). Essentially, the bodyshop wants to meet with the appraiser and revise the labor. Why is it my problem? Because I want to use this particular bodyshop and they are doing me a favor by accepting the insurance appraisal for a "turnkey price". If I can't get them to agree, then I pay out of pocket to this body shop for the difference or go looking for another bodyshop. Make sense? By-the-way, the appraiser listed my car a "show quality". It's not but who am I to argue?
The bodyshop generally does not do insurance jobs...they do corvette restorations. They charge the customer for labor and materials. The customer pays up-to-date after each 40 hours of labor. For me, the bodyshop is willing to do an insurance job but does not agree with labor hours listed on the appraisal. The bodyshop thought the Mitchell manual would provide a more accurate estimate of labor (and it's documented). Essentially, the bodyshop wants to meet with the appraiser and revise the labor. Why is it my problem? Because I want to use this particular bodyshop and they are doing me a favor by accepting the insurance appraisal for a "turnkey price". If I can't get them to agree, then I pay out of pocket to this body shop for the difference or go looking for another bodyshop. Make sense? By-the-way, the appraiser listed my car a "show quality". It's not but who am I to argue?
Maybe you can helpt me...Question???????
Got a bad right knee....I havea 66 with PG trans & PB...would love to be able to lower the height of the brake pedal....any suggestions???
thanks
nic
You, sorry when I say you I mean the insurance companies, have to admit, you have shops by the b@11s. When insurance companies do prevailing rate surveys, they come around and tell what they will pay and then go back and report that as the prevailing rate. This sets an artificially low rate. For example go to a Chevy dealer and ask at their service dept. what the labor rate is, Insurance companies have no control there, and you are going to find it is at least 1/3 more than it is at the same dealership`s body shop. Now does that sound reasonable considering that a service dept. needs far less expensive equipment, and most techs are basically parts changers? The body shop, on the other hand, needs paint booths, frame machines, alignment racks etc. and the tech is a sculpturer and an artist. He has to satisfy the most demanding customers eye. He gets much less pay?
I am sure that you are a great adjuster and you seem to know your business. I am sure that we would get along fine if we had to work together.
Maybe you can helpt me...Question???????
Got a bad right knee....I havea 66 with PG trans & PB...would love to be able to lower the height of the brake pedal....any suggestions???
thanks
nic
The bodyshop generally does not do insurance jobs...they do corvette restorations. They charge the customer for labor and materials. The customer pays up-to-date after each 40 hours of labor. For me, the bodyshop is willing to do an insurance job but does not agree with labor hours listed on the appraisal. The bodyshop thought the Mitchell manual would provide a more accurate estimate of labor (and it's documented). Essentially, the bodyshop wants to meet with the appraiser and revise the labor. Why is it my problem? Because I want to use this particular bodyshop and they are doing me a favor by accepting the insurance appraisal for a "turnkey price". If I can't get them to agree, then I pay out of pocket to this body shop for the difference or go looking for another bodyshop. Make sense? By-the-way, the appraiser listed my car a "show quality". It's not but who am I to argue?
Well its a good thing the appraiser has graded your vehicle as "show" quality. There you go he has essentially admitted that there is a premium to be paid to conduct this repair. I don't no how different it is in your neck of the woods but I come up against situations like this from time to time. Its your choice where the vehicle is repaired a least thats how it works in Canada. If the shop is being reasonable and the appraiser has some idea of what he is doing...they should be able to "SAW IT OFF" and do the deal.
my $0.02
Nic
Well its a good thing the appraiser has graded your vehicle as "show" quality. There you go he has essentially admitted that there is a premium to be paid to conduct this repair. I don't no how different it is in your neck of the woods but I come up against situations like this from time to time. Its your choice where the vehicle is repaired a least thats how it works in Canada. If the shop is being reasonable and the appraiser has some idea of what he is doing...they should be able to "SAW IT OFF" and do the deal.
my $0.02
Nic
Maybe you can helpt me...Question???????
Got a bad right knee....I havea 66 with PG trans & PB...would love to be able to lower the height of the brake pedal....any suggestions???
thanks
nic
I guess you could shorten up on the plunger some to lower the pedal. The PB cars are much lower already than the standard cars. But carefull, you need enough travel, and there is a limit to how far you can go.
Got a bad right knee....I havea 66 with PG trans & PB...would love to be able to lower the height of the brake pedal....any suggestions???
thanks
nic[/QUOTE]










