[C2] Good Golly - I hate Poly
#1
Team Owner
Thread Starter
Good Golly - I hate Poly
The 63 trailing arms are out with the help of a good forum pal (with an air-conditioned garage and all the tools for the job). The poly bushings shattered into nothingness, swiftly and catastrophically; unlike old rubber that will gradually "give it up" over a period of time....one side blew out on the trailing arm bushings.. which stressed the other side until it crumbled. The inner/outer wheel bearings and seals were actually OK. The metal core of the bushing arrangement was all that was left in either trailing arm
To wit, this entire job could have been avoided if a previous owner handn't used poly for the bushings. At any rate, the arms will be rebuilt with Timken bearings (still available apparently), new seals - dialed in and new front RUBBER bushings. The shim packs were intact so hopefully alignment will go easily..
Another downside to the poly is that the cumbly bits filled up the rear vertical drain area just outside the T/A cavity and prevented water draining. It was 20 minutes poking the junk out of the weep hole, vacuuming and blowing out with shop air to clear it out. See the bottom of the last picture.
The poly was a mistake and nothing but trouble....didn't even hold up on a lightly-driven, base motor car...
The greenish cast on the interior of the T/A cavity is the Eastwood Internal Chassis Treatment -- gives you a good idea of how it coats, encapsulates rust and protects the frame inside...
To wit, this entire job could have been avoided if a previous owner handn't used poly for the bushings. At any rate, the arms will be rebuilt with Timken bearings (still available apparently), new seals - dialed in and new front RUBBER bushings. The shim packs were intact so hopefully alignment will go easily..
Another downside to the poly is that the cumbly bits filled up the rear vertical drain area just outside the T/A cavity and prevented water draining. It was 20 minutes poking the junk out of the weep hole, vacuuming and blowing out with shop air to clear it out. See the bottom of the last picture.
The poly was a mistake and nothing but trouble....didn't even hold up on a lightly-driven, base motor car...
The greenish cast on the interior of the T/A cavity is the Eastwood Internal Chassis Treatment -- gives you a good idea of how it coats, encapsulates rust and protects the frame inside...
Last edited by Frankie the Fink; 06-19-2018 at 01:26 AM.
The following 3 users liked this post by Frankie the Fink:
#2
Pro
The car I just bought is full of poly. Approx 10K miles on rebuild. The only damage so far is the bushings in the Vette Brake adjustable strut rods. The TA bushings look good and all shims intact. TA bushings are on my watch list
Randy
Randy
Last edited by 66RBS; 06-21-2018 at 07:59 AM.
#3
Melting Slicks
Replaced all the original dried cracked original bushings in our 66 sometime in the early 90s with nice black rubber replacements and they are still in great condition.
#4
Le Mans Master
Poly
I am also in "recovery" with respects to poly. I had to keep the poly strut rod bushings as rubber will not fit the VB&P rods. You can still get them at Van Steel. Not a big deal to switch out every few years. Jerry
#5
Safety Car
I used poly when I restored my Pontiac. As I pulled the last bushing in place that feeling started creeping in that I should have used Moog. I called Summit to see if I was going to need one or two Moog kits. The guy says for just a few dollars more you can get poly urethane. I said I just finished replacing them and I'm going to swap them all out for rubber. The salesman then said well they've been in my car for 14 years without issue. I called a guy in the area that builds street rods professionally and asked his opinion. He stated that one car that stays in his show room and is never driven had poly and they started crumbling and falling out. I discussed it with my painter and he has had them in his 68 Chevelle over 20 years now. So I left them in. So far 4 years 10,000 miles on them no squeaks and no crumbling that I am aware of.
#6
Team Owner
Thread Starter
The trailing arms are a stressful area. Where some other bushings may only be subject to compression The trailing arm bushings are constantly opposing a twisting stress. Again. This car is a granny-driven base motor. The poly is just bad.
#7
Melting Slicks
It's still amazing that several well known Corvette suspension experts still sell and/or recommend these poly bushings for the rear control arm and strut rod.
The 1st picture in your 1st post clearly shows that, with the car jacked up and suspension hanging, the control arm is correctly rotated to change camber.
Last edited by Critter1; 06-19-2018 at 09:30 AM.
#8
Team Owner
I think poly bushings in general are snake oil products.
The following users liked this post:
biggd (06-19-2018)
#9
Burning Brakes
I’ve noticed the vendors have come out with a poly version of the infamous self-destructing clutch rod bushings used on C1s. Wonder how that’s gonna hold up?
Last edited by vettepoor; 06-19-2018 at 09:47 AM.
#10
Burning Brakes
I agree with this.
All these guys do is mix it up, pour it into a mold and then bake it.
The majority of the molds are oversized, so you end up having to trim them to install them. They bind and wear poorly or crumble.
I've never checked into any of the manufacturers, but having toured many factories over the years in Asia, I can believe that the compounds used have R E A L L Y W I D E degrees of tolerance and are sometimes overly full of fillers or just plain junk. The cheaper they can make a product, the more money they make...
I've had several bushings from a certain Vette Brakes and Suspension supplier who recently folded their tent, that crumbled within days of installation.
They probably don't even reference a specification on the poly when they buy it from overseas. If they do, I would be shocked if they ever checked that what they received was actually to that spec.
All these guys do is mix it up, pour it into a mold and then bake it.
The majority of the molds are oversized, so you end up having to trim them to install them. They bind and wear poorly or crumble.
I've never checked into any of the manufacturers, but having toured many factories over the years in Asia, I can believe that the compounds used have R E A L L Y W I D E degrees of tolerance and are sometimes overly full of fillers or just plain junk. The cheaper they can make a product, the more money they make...
I've had several bushings from a certain Vette Brakes and Suspension supplier who recently folded their tent, that crumbled within days of installation.
They probably don't even reference a specification on the poly when they buy it from overseas. If they do, I would be shocked if they ever checked that what they received was actually to that spec.
#12
Team Owner
Thread Starter
It was a prior owner before you Herb.....the trailing arms were powder coated and the bearings nicely packed with modern grease which hadn't congealed. Ten years or ten months no matter IMO - I don't like catastrophic parts failures.
I had driven 3 miles to the local NAPA store -- fat, dumb and happy - no problems. Two miles from home on the return trip the rear end of the split window suddenly just "came loose" and started "twerking" like a drunk girl at a booty call. Every time I got on or off the gas... I literally thought I'd torn the rear end out of the car somehow (which is partially true I guess)...
No worries - I'm using the opportunity to install a fresh snubber bushing, zerk-less U-joints on the half-shafts and new strut rod bushings -- along with new rear leaf spring rubber. The sombreros -- well; we'll see...
I had driven 3 miles to the local NAPA store -- fat, dumb and happy - no problems. Two miles from home on the return trip the rear end of the split window suddenly just "came loose" and started "twerking" like a drunk girl at a booty call. Every time I got on or off the gas... I literally thought I'd torn the rear end out of the car somehow (which is partially true I guess)...
No worries - I'm using the opportunity to install a fresh snubber bushing, zerk-less U-joints on the half-shafts and new strut rod bushings -- along with new rear leaf spring rubber. The sombreros -- well; we'll see...
#13
Team Owner
Thread Starter
#15
Team Owner
Thread Starter
Pretty much like:
It was exhilarating and scary at the same time....
Hmmm.....maybe that poly stuff isn't so bad
My apologies to the moderators ahead of time but I WAS asked!
It was exhilarating and scary at the same time....
Hmmm.....maybe that poly stuff isn't so bad
My apologies to the moderators ahead of time but I WAS asked!
Last edited by Frankie the Fink; 06-19-2018 at 11:21 AM.
The following 3 users liked this post by Frankie the Fink:
#16
Race Director
Member Since: Apr 2015
Location: Fresno California
Posts: 17,505
Received 3,443 Likes
on
2,113 Posts
Thanks for the post, Frank. And it pretty much sums up why I never used poly bushings after one mis-guided sway bar bushing episode on one of my GTO's in the '80's. It's Moog Rubber for me, and hopefully they'll keep making it so it holds up, unlike off-shore rubber. I like the frame coating inside the rails of your car.....makes me feel like I'm looking into the superstructure of a P-51 or P-38...and that's not a bad thing!!
#17
Le Mans Master
Thanks for the post, Frank. And it pretty much sums up why I never used poly bushings after one mis-guided sway bar bushing episode on one of my GTO's in the '80's. It's Moog Rubber for me, and hopefully they'll keep making it so it holds up, unlike off-shore rubber. I like the frame coating inside the rails of your car.....makes me feel like I'm looking into the superstructure of a P-51 or P-38...and that's not a bad thing!!
#18
Tether Man
Member Since: Dec 2004
Location: Pittsburgh, South Hills
Posts: 4,537
Received 2,014 Likes
on
1,039 Posts
2023 C2 of the Year Finalist - Modified
2022 C2 of the Year Finalist - Unmodified
2019 C1 of Year Finalist (appearance mods)
Pretty much like:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HW9Nz8l_dwg
It was exhilarating and scary at the same time....
Hmmm.....maybe that poly stuff isn't so bad
My apologies to the moderators ahead of time but I WAS asked!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HW9Nz8l_dwg
It was exhilarating and scary at the same time....
Hmmm.....maybe that poly stuff isn't so bad
My apologies to the moderators ahead of time but I WAS asked!