"Clunkers for Cash"....
Are you willing to take a pay and benefits cut, and work you butt off to do your job right the first time, in order to accomplish this? Most Americans will say "hell no!" and that's what got this country in a mess in the first place - including bad foreign policies which rewarded US businesses for opening shop overseas.
I hate to start this AGAIN!!! 
Flame suit on...
Your tax money is not going to Japan if you buy a Japanese car. It's going to the hands of a giant multi national who may invest that money in whichever country they please. The case is the same if you give your money to GM or Ford.
The cash for clunkers is a fair thing to do. No one's asking you to turn in your classic cars or exotics, but if I have a junker C4 sitting at home which will get me less than $1000 in a sale, I would not hesitate a moment to turn that thing in for a new car.
I am not with any politician, but I hate it when people don't get the facts straight.

Flame suit on...
Your tax money is not going to Japan if you buy a Japanese car. It's going to the hands of a giant multi national who may invest that money in whichever country they please. The case is the same if you give your money to GM or Ford.
The cash for clunkers is a fair thing to do. No one's asking you to turn in your classic cars or exotics, but if I have a junker C4 sitting at home which will get me less than $1000 in a sale, I would not hesitate a moment to turn that thing in for a new car.
I am not with any politician, but I hate it when people don't get the facts straight.
I don't want to be with any politician either but where does the money for the program come from. Just another way to transfer the wealth. Take for me and give to someone else. BTW, where is it green to take a car that runs and distroy it, only to replace it with a "newer model".
Are you willing to take a pay and benefits cut, and work you butt off to do your job right the first time, in order to accomplish this? Most Americans will say "hell no!" and that's what got this country in a mess in the first place - including bad foreign policies which rewarded US businesses for opening shop overseas.
I am trying to stay out of the discussion, but transferring the wealth from one to another has been going on since the 80's. The middle class is disappearing, the wealth has gone to the top 2%. This has been through tax policy, market deregulation and fiscal policy. If you disagree, that's fine. But I suggest you study Macro Economics rather than listen to cable news (cable news is kinda like big time wrestling). Even the great Alan Greenspan has come to this conclusion.
Brother, you are supporting the middle east economy by driving your american clunker. I dream of a day that we don't have to suck up to the arabs for oil. I don't mind driving a Prius to get there.
I like people who are passionate about making the right choices to keep the dough in the US, but such choices are often not that easy as hating a Japanese car and driving an american car.
Ok.. no more from me.
I like people who are passionate about making the right choices to keep the dough in the US, but such choices are often not that easy as hating a Japanese car and driving an american car.
Ok.. no more from me.

Partner, your talking about assembly points. Look at the domestic content on the window sticker. Alot more jobs are supported by your purchase than just those assembly jobs.
I am trying to stay out of the discussion, but transferring the wealth from one to another has been going on since the 80's. The middle class is disappearing, the wealth has gone to the top 2%. This has been through tax policy, market deregulation and fiscal policy. If you disagree, that's fine. But I suggest you study Macro Economics rather than listen to cable news (cable news is kinda like big time wrestling). Even the great Alan Greenspan has come to this conclusion.
So what are you saying? More wealth transfer, more taxes, more goverment deciding where my money is spent. I guess just sit back and take the screwing... Maybe you are ok with that but not me.
Le Mans Master






Joined: Jan 2007
Posts: 7,985
Likes: 3,333
From: Omaha NE
2025 c3 ('74-'82) of the Year Finalist - Unmodified
2023 C3 of the Year Finalist - Unmodified
2022 C3 of the Year Finalist - Unmodified
2020 C3 of the Year Finalist - Unmodified
The Camry has over 75% domestic content...
The new Camaro & '10 Mustang are around 60%........
At least the Mustang is U.S. built...........
..
Le Mans Master



Joined: Sep 2000
Posts: 9,078
Likes: 7
From: DFW TX
Cruise-In VII Veteran
St. Jude Donor '07
We ended up passing on the program. Selection was limited, interest rates are still a little high for me(highier than 2%), and it was hard to swallow trading a perfectly good truck that would be crushed.
Also, it seemed like the dealerships were treating the money like it was theirs before you walked in the door. They weren't even following the law and giving the consumer the scrap value of the car and if they did it was only $50. Load of BS there.
Also, it seemed like the dealerships were treating the money like it was theirs before you walked in the door. They weren't even following the law and giving the consumer the scrap value of the car and if they did it was only $50. Load of BS there.

I watched a video on Friday of a perfectly nice ~'90 Chevy short wheelbase pickup that got traded. The guy says almost new tires. They pour that stuff in, lock the motor, forklift to the coolant, drain the fluids, and into the crusher she goes. This is so wrong on several points IMHO.
1-why waste new tires? Surely with as hard as it is to get tires they could at least recycle those? Isn't that more green than into the crusher? Who does this help?
2-That was a perfectly nice vehicle for somebody. The TBI motors are so reliable, why couldn't that truck be used by somebody who can't afford a new one? It is probably better than most "clunkers" that are out there. No rust to be seen when they rolled it around with the forklift. Who does this help?
3-No body parts or drivetrain salvaged-perfectly good 700R4 and rearend gone. I know those trucks don't bring what they did 10 years ago, but perfectly nice spare parts-gone! No effort to segregate metals or anything. Who does this help?
4-If we flood the market with scrap metal-where does it go?-what does that do to the price? $1B at $4500/car is roughly 1/4 million cars. If you average 3500lbs/car you get around 3/4billion lbs of scrap cars that will hit the market in the next 6 months. Who does this help?
WE and our children will be paying for all this "free help" for a long time to come. In more ways than money and taxes. My .02
4-If we flood the market with scrap metal-where does it go?-what does that do to the price? $1B at $4500/car is roughly 1/4 million cars. If you average 3500lbs/car you get around 3/4billion lbs of scrap cars that will hit the market in the next 6 months. Who does this help?
My car isn't 100% Japanese - its emissions control devices were designed and manufactured by an American electronics company. One of my relatives works for them who does business with a lot of Japanese companies. What many don't seem to understand is that the supply chains of many large foreign manufactures aren't totally tied to one country - they're all mostly outsourcing these days. Once again, people - it's a GLOBAL economy!
What people traded in and what the got.
http://finance.yahoo.com/family-home...d=family-autos
I'm kinda shocked that a PT Cruiser only gets 21 mpg. Some of us in this forum get better than that.
http://finance.yahoo.com/family-home...d=family-autos
I'm kinda shocked that a PT Cruiser only gets 21 mpg. Some of us in this forum get better than that.
I found these two quotes funny:
...the government says that the federal Food and Drug Administration classifies sodium silicate as GRAS -- "generally regarded as safe."
Consisting largely of ingredients as common as salt and sand, sodium silicate isn't hard to make.
Your tax money is not going to Japan if you buy a Japanese car. It's going to the hands of a giant multi national who may invest that money in whichever country they please.
The cash for clunkers is a fair thing to do.
I am not with any politician, but I hate it when people don't get the facts straight.
Name one automobile which is mass produced that's still 100% American made. Anyone, anyone?














