10W30 vs 20W50
I live in TN so we have a pretty mild winter.
It all depends
I always run 20W-50 unless the temperature is going to drop below -20ºC or -4ºF. I don't think TN gets that cold. I would not recommend altering the oil viscosity ratings between changes unless you are going to change the filter each time. A safe choice for continental USA is 10W-40. If you like to rev it up then perhaps a 20W-50 would protect your engine better since it will be more viscous at higher temperatures. If you want more protection for cold starts then take a look at the synthetic oils which are available with a 5W-50 viscosity.
Briefly from my research oil is there to lubricate, wash away any dirt, and to form a compressed layer inside main and cam bearings so that the parts never hit metal to metal. Each of the viscosities for detergent oils such as all the motor oils will lubricate and wash away dirt, but the viscosities are a good indication of how well they maintain the compressed layer in the bearings. The viscosity also tells you how easily it will flow at colder temperatures. Ideally you want the oil to be the same viscosity throughout the entire operating range of the engine, but you might as well change your oil in your dreams cause you won't get this in reality. The viscosity ratings are a relational comparison with a standardized sample of oil. The first number is its viscosity at -20ºC (-4ºF) and the second number is its viscosity at 100ºC (212ºF) when compared to the sample. For example, a 10W-40 oil has the same viscosity as an SAE 10W oil at -20ºC and the same viscosity as an SAE 40W oil at 100ºC, this is called holding it's viscosity cause normally a SAE 10W oil would be way too thin at 100ºC to stay inside the bearing caps and would get squeezed out, but a 40W oil would be fine, and a 50W would be even better at 100ºC. However, a 50W oil would be too thick at -20ºC and may not even flow into the bearings using the stock oil pump thus resulting in dry bearings until the oil heats up which causes excessive wear. Thus the industry has discovered a means to create an oil that holds its viscosity better, and thus you need to research the oils to see what the specs are for your area to make sure you use an oil that is thick enough for higher temps, and low enough for the coldest temps in your region.
A note on synthetics: In my research I found that the synthetics do lubricate better than fossil fuel oils, but they don't have the coehesion that fossil fuel oils do and at higher temps the synthetics tend to squirt out of the bearing caps before the fossil fuel oils having the same viscosity ratings.
A note on racing oils: I use racing oil when I can afford it. It has better engine cleaning components to keep your engine clean. But, it requires you to change your oil twice as often and it costs twice as much as conventional motor oil. I suggest changing the oil when it gets dirty, and racing oil gets dirty after about 1,500 miles or 3 months which ever comes first.
A note on changing oil: You should check your oil at least once a month, and when going on a drive for over 100 miles. If the oil is low then you should change the oil, not just add some and let it go like that. If you lost some oil then it may be due to contaminates in the oil so add some to bring it up to level only so you can go to the store for more oil. You should change the oil when you can not see through it to the dip stick. You should also change your filter every time you change your oil. The filter can hold up to a quart of dirty oil and will require you to change your oil more often. In the long run an oil change will last longer and protect your engine better if you change your filter each time.
Hope this helps.
The Best of Corvette for Corvette Enthusiasts
For water cooled engines, the advice I got from a chemist working at a large oil company (developing engine oils) is this:
Once a water cooled engine is up to temperature it should stay at around that temperature, so the grade of oil should be the same whatever the season, if the cooling system is in good health (as long as you don't live in the arctic or idle for long periods in Death Valley). The thinner oil is for protecting the engine during the warm up period, when a thick oil wouldn't be able to lubricate as efficiently as splash fed componants may get starved of oil.
This advice applies to engines in good condition. If they are a bit worn then run a heavier oil as mentioned above.
I've followed this advice & my daily driver still sounds OK after 8 years of general neglect & abuse :)
:cheers:
[Modified by UKPaul, 6:36 PM 12/21/2001]
UKPaul: sounds like an old Brit bike that you're running straight 50 in? I remember one of my friends taking about 10 minutes to warm up his E-Jag because he was running 50-weight. We thought it was cool and because it must have the motor-from-hell in it or something; today I understand that it was just that the oil was so hard to pump that if he didn't warm it up he couldn't even get the clutch out. I wonder if you're not doing yourself a disservice. FWIW, I switched from 20W-50 to 10W-40 on an old Triumph and enjoyed better performance.
The lower the weight. the lower the outdoor temp you can run and may limit highway driving. I mean this from the prospect that you may not be able to drive on hot days.
I have stopped using winter grades since straight 30 meets my needs.
If you don't need a heavy oil don't bother with it.
No one has mentioned using 5W-30, why?
SES
The weather is finally good and I don't have to work tomorrow so I can take it out for the first time. Can't wait!!!
No one has mentioned using 5W-30, why?
SES
I go with 10w40 in my '69.
The *** bikes of that era (haven't a clue about modern stuff) run best on 10/40 & everybody I know with that age of *** bike uses 10/40 - even with Turbos fitted. The oilways on a Triumph are of a larger cross section than a comparable *** engine so maybe a thicker oil passes more easily?
Happy new year!!
Paul


















