When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.
2020 Corvette of the Year Finalist (appearance mods)
C4 of Year Winner (appearance mods) 2019
Originally Posted by FICINJECTORS
I do not own a vette so I can't really do a ligit test comparing the Bosch and the Lucas. I will send you a set of Design III's Put in the Lucas first and drive the car for 3 weeks. Record mileage performance etc. Then Install the Bosch's and do the same. Report your results to the forum. The injectors will be yours to keep.... I hope you want to do the test for us.
thanks
jon
Jon,
That's a great offer -- one that shows a lot of integrity! But, I'm not sure it's a question of whether I want to do the test -- I do. I'm always the type to go for product comparisons! But, it may be several weeks before I could help you out.
To be honest, I've recently been asked to evaluate an intake setup. As a result, I'm having to choose between multiple intakes (and whether to polish/chrome/or leave natural. Plus I'm waiting on a set of Tri-Y headers from CA.)
I'm not sure you'd want to wait for your results. As a married guy, things happen slow in the garage at my house. (I have a lot of ***** in the air.) I feel I'd be a good choice for someone who's thorough/fair. For example, I might want to (or even be forced to) go more than 3 wks to complete my comparison. (TPIs are a pain to swap injectors.) FYI: I'm choosing between a Large-tube style intake, a modified large-tube setup, and a Holley Stealth Ram (for intakes). Plus I'm going to add 1.6 rockers and headers. If I picked the HSR, the injector swap would be easiest. I'm also buying tuning software and getting help from the forum to optimize my tune.
If you'd want to hear the results (on whichever combo I pick) and you're willing to wait for a thorough test, let me know.
That's a great offer -- one that shows a lot of integrity! But, I'm not sure it's a question of whether I want to do the test -- I do. I'm always the type to go for product comparisons! But, it may be several weeks before I could help you out.
To be honest, I've recently been asked to evaluate an intake setup. As a result, I'm having to choose between multiple intakes (and whether to polish/chrome/or leave natural. Plus I'm waiting on a set of Tri-Y headers from CA.)
I'm not sure you'd want to wait for your results. As a married guy, things happen slow in the garage at my house. (I have a lot of ***** in the air.) I feel I'd be a good choice for someone who's thorough/fair. For example, I might want to (or even be forced to) go more than 3 wks to complete my comparison. (TPIs are a pain to swap injectors.) FYI: I'm choosing between a Large-tube style intake, a modified large-tube setup, and a Holley Stealth Ram (for intakes). Plus I'm going to add 1.6 rockers and headers. If I picked the HSR, the injector swap would be easiest. I'm also buying tuning software and getting help from the forum to optimize my tune.
If you'd want to hear the results (on whichever combo I pick) and you're willing to wait for a thorough test, let me know.
Gregg
Gregg Not a problem Adam (another member) should be getting his in shortly. he is comparing to multecs. Get it together, run the injectors you have and get some performance data. Then PM me. I will send you a set to try.
Hey I'm ready. We are allowed to carry all kinds of guns and shovels in Ga. Plus there are two Rotweillers at the shop their names are Manager and Assistant Manager
I think the best response would be by video versus detailed text. This week I will post a new video comparing a Bosch design III 30, 24 & 22 to the Bosch design II (old style) 30, 24 & 22.
I think the best response would be by video versus detailed text. This week I will post a new video comparing a Bosch design III 30, 24 & 22 to the Bosch design II (old style) 30, 24 & 22.
Thanks.
Jon - FIC
wow.........that would be stellar........
also, do you carry the new style red top 3o?
here is a kinda cool link, injector technical drawing
2020 Corvette of the Year Finalist (appearance mods)
C4 of Year Winner (appearance mods) 2019
Originally Posted by FICINJECTORS
Gregg Not a problem Adam (another member) should be getting his in shortly. he is comparing to multecs. Get it together, run the injectors you have and get some performance data. Then PM me. I will send you a set to try.
Injectors received.... Thanks Jon!!!!!
I will compare in my Jeep first (as indicated in a pm). I think it will help if these injectors are shown to improve mileage in multiple cars. Seems like it would show atomization is part of the key!
BTW: How are these injectors rebuilt? I know they are typically cleaned, but what about the coil that's at the heart of the "on/off switch"?
I will compare in my Jeep first (as indicated in a pm). I think it will help if these injectors are shown to improve mileage in multiple cars. Seems like it would show atomization is part of the key!
BTW: How are these injectors rebuilt? I know they are typically cleaned, but what about the coil that's at the heart of the "on/off switch"?
Gregg Thanks and good luck. The design 3 Bosch is designed with a sealed coil that is molded over with the phenellic plastic. The coils cannot be servised. These are not multecs/ The multec coil failure is caused by chemicals such as fuel injector additives and the ethanol that is now in our gas breaking down the seal in the injector. The coil gets shorted from this liquid and the Injector fails. Bosch coils seldom ever fail, there is no way that any fluid can get to the coil. Copper lasts forever. I can buy 3000 cores and have only a handful of injecotrs that i can't bring back to 100% of the original specs. There seems to be an epidemic of multecs failing lately, I am convinced its a direct result of non compatable chemicals breaking down the seal inside the multec. Only GM guys seem to worry about Ohm testing.
Interesting video's, and a little disturbing. What your third video suggests is that the Accel injectors I paid $300.00 for are basically junk. What really sucks is that they were recommended by a respected member of this forum. I guess my only question is, are you sure all Lucas injectors perform like the ones in your test?
Oh well, I guess I'll be replacing injectors again...
2020 Corvette of the Year Finalist (appearance mods)
C4 of Year Winner (appearance mods) 2019
Originally Posted by FICINJECTORS
The design 3 Bosch is designed with a sealed coil that is molded over with the phenellic plastic. The coils cannot be serviced. These are not multecs. The multec coil failure is caused by chemicals such as fuel injector additives and the ethanol that is now in our gas breaking down the seal in the injector. The coil gets shorted from this liquid and the Injector fails. Bosch coils seldom ever fail, there is no way that any fluid can get to the coil. Copper lasts forever.
Thanks Jon,
What makes the seals in the Bosch better than the Multecs? How about difference(s) in coil insulation?
Regarding the life of copper, I have "Monster Cable" stereo wire that I purchased 15+ yrs ago. Inside the clear sealed insulation, it has turned black (oxidized) over the years. Wouldn't this be happening in the Bosch coils as well?
2020 Corvette of the Year Finalist (appearance mods)
C4 of Year Winner (appearance mods) 2019
Originally Posted by RandyJ75
Interesting video's, and a little disturbing. What your third video suggests is that the Accel injectors I paid $300.00 for are basically junk. What really sucks is that they were recommended by a respected member of this forum. I guess my only question is, are you sure all Lucas injectors perform like the ones in your test?
Oh well, I guess I'll be replacing injectors again...
Not necessarily. I gathered it depends on which design you purchased. My take is the early design has much worse atomization -- while the newer design includes a 3-hole outlet to increase atomization. I'm don't recall anything being mentioned about longevity of the designs....Was it?
Interesting video's, and a little disturbing. What your third video suggests is that the Accel injectors I paid $300.00 for are basically junk. What really sucks is that they were recommended by a respected member of this forum. I guess my only question is, are you sure all Lucas injectors perform like the ones in your test?
Oh well, I guess I'll be replacing injectors again...
What makes the seals in the Bosch better than the Multecs? How about difference(s) in coil insulation?
Regarding the life of copper, I have "Monster Cable" stereo wire that I purchased 15+ yrs ago. Inside the clear sealed insulation, it has turned black (oxidized) over the years. Wouldn't this be happening in the Bosch coils as well?
How old are the cores?
Gregg
gregg the Bosch design 3's have no seals the coil is outside the 1 piece stainless orfice. The multec has a seal that when broken down, fluid will enter the coil and short it out. As for the copper winding. I believe magnetic field wire is 100% copper. It will last untill it stops working. All I know if you test a new vs very old injector on an impedance tester. Not an ohm meter, both coils will read the same as long as both are operational. How old are the cores. I do not know when they came off the assembly line. You can buy new injectors that have been in inventory for 5 years or longer.
Designer Imagines A Corvette That Looks More Like a Corvette Than the Corvette
Slideshow: A Jaguar designer's personal project imagines what a modern front-engined Corvette might look like if Chevrolet revisited the golden age of the Stingray.