unknown noise at idle
It seems to run fine at higher rpm. When idling has some slight misfiring so the there is negative acceleration of rotation of the crankshaft, the noise is in sync with this intermittent deceleration.
Any idea?
You can hear it in the video attached
Thanks
These cars are really sensitive to uneven idle due to things like an injector not firing properly or a bad ignition wire. If you have an unsteady idle due to things like those, you're more likely to have gear rattle that the DMF can't damp enough to prevent hearing the gear noise. When my car's injectors started acting up (Multecs) I changed them out for new Bosch IIIs and put in new plugs, wires, etc., then re-tuned the idle settings, throttle body minimum air, etc. Unsteady idle went away, no more gear rattle noise. Car ran much better through the gears also.
147K is a lot for a DMF according to some people here on the forum. But first I'd work on fixing your lumpy idle if you have an issue like those mentioned above. That would cause gear rattle even with a solid flywheel and conventional clutch most likely.
you were right about the engine. I replaced the flywheel and now there is rattling when the clutch is engaged because of the noisy gearbox but the engine misfires and makes it worse, I suppose it’s because of the backlash and rotational acceleration (+-)
Anyway, I couldn’t evaluate the condition of the DMFW while it was on the car and I thought it was the original one and the car has 140k miles and that would’ve been a lot for a DM flywheel. However, I’m not sure if it was replaced before, but looks in good condition, there the steel face has very small signs of wear, so it seems in a very good condition. The new flywheel I installed I like more because the engine can respond faster. The clutch springs are stronger than on the stock flywheel which I think is better because in case of a shock softer springs reach the end of the travel and after that they can’t do their job anymore.
Currently I’m trying to diagnose the misfiring. I’ll do different kinds of testing. I prepared pulse sensors (exhaust, blow-by), ignition spark current sensor, vibration sensors.
I’ve managed to check the ignition timing and it’s 4deg btdc not 6. For some reason someone changed it or the harmonic balancer is degraded and doesn’t show the correct timing.
Anyway, I’ve noticed another thing that is very likely the cause of intermittent misfiring that gets worse with temperature. While the engine is running with the hood open I can hear electric discharges on the driver side of the engine, moreover they seem to happen exactly when the engine is misfiring.
Good luck with the fixes remaining.









