When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.
Sometimes with aftermarket modifications like roller rockers, headers, more aggressive cams, etc... things can get a little noisier and the knock sensor will pick that up and start recording knock counts (even if it doesn't get to the point of retarding timing)
Also an incorrect sensor can cause it. Knock sensors are tuned for particular engines (i.e.. 305 vs 350 for example).
It's a '96 LT1. Roller rockers and 52mmTB, are the only major mods done by the PO. During idle, I get 2.4K knocks, 0 knock retard. Should I only be concerned if I get knock retard?
Originally Posted by ULTM8Z
Is your car stock? What year?
Sometimes with aftermarket modifications like roller rockers, headers, more aggressive cams, etc... things can get a little noisier and the knock sensor will pick that up and start recording knock counts (even if it doesn't get to the point of retarding timing)
Also an incorrect sensor can cause it. Knock sensors are tuned for particular engines (i.e.. 305 vs 350 for example).
It's a '96 LT1. Roller rockers and 52mmTB, are the only major mods done by the PO. During idle, I get 2.4K knocks, 0 knock retard. Should I only be concerned if I get knock retard?
Assuming your knock sensor is not malfunctioning and is correct for the car, then I would likely chalk it up to false knock due to the roller rocker noise.
Questions about real/false knock are common on thirdgen.org. Couple of sample threads below... the first one is mine, where I was troubleshooting what I determined to be mostly false knock. But if you search you'll find tons of threads. Granted they're all about Gen1 small blocks, but the logic and diagnostics are largely going to be the same.
I ran across this awhile back. I read don't worry about the counts only the knock retard. The counts start at 0 and go up to 60k or so on a loop. Looking at a few of my logs I noticed my counts went from 79 to 12k before I turned the key to start the engine. It stays at the 12k through the log unless you get spark retard at which it may go up 50 points. It also depends on where the log starts in the loop. Another started at 700 counts and remained there until I shut the car off and it climbed to 60k. I did notice couple times the count increased 40 or so and there was no knock retard. Must be the norm, 1993 lt1.
I wouldn't introduce more variables into the mix. I'd ensure you have a genuine GM knock sensor for your vehicle. In that thread I linked to, I had to do that in order to solve my issue.
In a nutshell, it could be a false reading is what I gathered. My MAP readings look good, plus I have no knock retard, but my egr has been deleted. Shouldn't the LT4 module help "quite" things down? (I got confused between the module vs knock senor). As far a stock knock sensors, I'm more than 100% sure they're the originals, but I'll check anyways. The car was badly neglected, when I got it.
Originally Posted by ULTM8Z
I wouldn't introduce more variables into the mix. I'd ensure you have a genuine GM knock sensor for your vehicle. In that thread I linked to, I had to do that in order to solve my issue.
Last edited by TheKodiak; Sep 25, 2024 at 07:41 AM.