When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.
I have posted asking something similar to this before, but I continuously fight with myself about which way to go for engine mods- boosted with H/C or just H/C. I have bought stuff to go one way, then decide a different route. I know I need to come up with a plan and stick with it, but as soon as I do, I change my mind a few days later. The car is not a racecar, but I do enjoy "spirited" driving and bragging rights. The car isn't a daily driver, but isn't a garage queen by any means.
I need some sensible reasoning to go one way or the other. I have most parts to go either way:
N/A
Ported LS6 heads(might sell for TSP 5.3 stage 2)
TSP Torquer V2 cam(232/234, .595/.598)
LS6 intake(possible upgrade to FAST 90/90 if I go this route)
Kooks Headers and X-pipe
It's really up to you. The SC setup will definitely net you more HP but with a level of complexity that a H/C setup won't. As for me, I'm just an N/A type of guy.
It's really up to you. The SC setup will definitely net you more HP but with a level of complexity that a H/C setup won't. As for me, I'm just an N/A type of guy.
Yeah, I know it is up to me. That is the problem . I am very indecisive. I was a little concerned about the added cylinder pressure of the S/C.I stopped into IPS Motorsports this morning and talked to the owner and he said that the P1SC should be fine. If I decide to go the N/A route, do you still happen to have those 5.3 heads?
Send the car to A&A or ECS and have them throw some boost on it. With either one of their kits you can get over 500 rwhp safely. I have the A&A kit on my 02 Z with 5 psi, it makes 540 rwhp, w/o meth.
I've always liked big cubes and staying N/A, although after having a few S/C'd cars there is nothing like it. IMO
Send the car to A&A or ECS and have them throw some boost on it. With either one of their kits you can get over 500 rwhp safely. I have the A&A kit on my 02 Z with 5 psi, it makes 540 rwhp, w/o meth.
I've always liked big cubes and staying N/A, although after having a few S/C'd cars there is nothing like it. IMO
It is a BLAST!
I planned to install the stuff myself plus I already have most of what I need other than gaskets and push-rods(don't know what size I need yet)
Yeah, I know it is up to me. That is the problem . I am very indecisive. I was a little concerned about the added cylinder pressure of the S/C.I stopped into IPS Motorsports this morning and talked to the owner and he said that the P1SC should be fine. If I decide to go the N/A route, do you still happen to have those 5.3 heads?
As a matter of fact I do have the heads. A&A (West Coast Cylinder Heads) Stage 2 w/ Comp 921's)
The way I looked at NA vs SC was the same way I looked at the 4 wheel drive option when I bought my CTS. 4 wheel drive would be nice when I really needed it but I really don't need it that often. I don't want to drag the 4 wheel drive hardware around the 99.9% of the time I don't need it.
I'm running on the stock bottom end, but is 425-450 reasonable for N/A?
My concerns are keeping the engine together(of course), FMIC making the car run hot, more complex and added cost to tune.
My 346 made 460RWHP and I drove it in DC rush hour traffic. I had a 230-236 112 cam, 90/90 setup. JACKS996 bought that setup and is crazy happy with it. I took it on many 500 mile plus trips.
As a matter of fact I do have the heads. A&A (West Coast Cylinder Heads) Stage 2 w/ Comp 921's)
The way I looked at NA vs SC was the same way I looked at the 4 wheel drive option when I bought my CTS. 4 wheel drive would be nice when I really needed it but I really don't need it that often. I don't want to drag the 4 wheel drive hardware around the 99.9% of the time I don't need it.
Just my $.02
yeah, I can see your thoughts on that, but it sure is nice to have it when you want it. I keep thinking that the N/A set-up would be easier to install, I don't think I will need crank pinning, I won't need to mount the FMIC and possibly have cooling issues, cheaper to tune. etc..
What were the specs on the heads again?
Originally Posted by WKMCD
My 346 made 460RWHP and I drove it in DC rush hour traffic. I had a 230-236 112 cam, 90/90 setup. JACKS996 bought that setup and is crazy happy with it. I took it on many 500 mile plus trips.
I guess this is $.03
I am pretty sure I would be happy with 460RWHP. What would I need to change in the N/A list to get that? Would your heads help over the ported LS6 heads?
I'm running on the stock bottom end, but is 425-450 reasonable for N/A?
My concerns are keeping the engine together(of course), FMIC making the car run hot, more complex and added cost to tune.
Really depends on wether or not are six speed or auto. Give out point in Auto's is around 400 - 450 on stock parts. Six speed good to about 450 but needs an aftermarket clutch. Skip the new heads and cam and use that beef up drive train.
When I started my engine mods i just was planing on a cam and springs. But then all of the rest of the stuff I bought used form my buddies and ended up spending alot more than I thought. If I knew I was going to spend that much in the end I would of put a blower on it. But I love the idle.
Really depends on wether or not are six speed or auto. Give out point in Auto's is around 400 - 450 on stock parts. Six speed good to about 450 but needs an aftermarket clutch. Skip the new heads and cam and use that beef up drive train.
My car is an MN6 and I'll probably run the current clutch until it goes, then upgrade. I already have the parts I have listed so to skip that step, I would have to sell everything and start all over. However, if I go with the N/A set-up, I may sell the P1SC kit which will free up a bit of cash for me.
When I started my engine mods i just was planing on a cam and springs. But then all of the rest of the stuff I bought used form my buddies and ended up spending alot more than I thought. If I knew I was going to spend that much in the end I would of put a blower on it. But I love the idle.
That is another thing I hadn't mentioned in my original post. I do want a decent sounding idle. I'm sure the headers alone will help some.
I have posted asking something similar to this before, but I continuously fight with myself about which way to go for engine mods- boosted with H/C or just H/C. I have bought stuff to go one way, then decide a different route. I know I need to come up with a plan and stick with it, but as soon as I do, I change my mind a few days later. The car is not a racecar, but I do enjoy "spirited" driving and bragging rights. The car isn't a daily driver, but isn't a garage queen by any means.
I need some sensible reasoning to go one way or the other. I have most parts to go either way:
N/A
Ported LS6 heads(might sell for TSP 5.3 stage 2)
TSP Torquer V2 cam(232/234, .595/.598)
LS6 intake(possible upgrade to FAST 90/90 if I go this route)
Kooks Headers and X-pipe
I went the H/C way first and even though it was good and fun it turned out not to be enough! Especially when these motors love parts! 423 RWHP
So the more you throw at them the better they are!
So I slapped on a P1SC and picked it up to 591 RWHP! Now I'm satisfied and man it is a world of a difference and totally awesome!
7.6 PSI of B@@ST! on a 3.85" pulley and my H/C set-up!
My car is an MN6 and I'll probably run the current clutch until it goes, then upgrade. I already have the parts I have listed so to skip that step, I would have to sell everything and start all over. However, if I go with the N/A set-up, I may sell the P1SC kit which will free up a bit of cash for me.
AT the HP level you're looking for the SC would be the cheapest way. Sell the other parts as you can easily make 450 RWHP and use the funds down the road on the drive train.
Somehow I knew you would pop in here and say something like that. I really wish it was that simple for me.
It is simple, I did everything all at once, and love the boost, you did mention bragging rights, then put the blower on, save your $$$ and go forged when you do heads and cam, then you can really turn up the wick
It is simple, I did everything all at once, and love the boost, you did mention bragging rights, then put the blower on, save your $$$ and go forged when you do heads and cam, then you can really turn up the wick
Actually, for me it isn't that simple. I make up my mind exactly what I want to do, but then the sensible side of me tells me that I really don't need all that. It really wouldn't be so bad if I wouldn't buy all the stuff and then change my mind.
right now, I am thinking of maybe beginning one of two ways
1. Install the ported LS6 heads and Torquer cam along with a 2pc timing cover. That way, I can change the cam fairly easily if I decide to add the P1SC.
or
2. Install the P1SC only and see if it is enough for me. then possibly sell everything else and beef up the drivetrain. i can then add a blower cam and heads if I feel the desire. Only issue I have with this route is that I won;t have the exhaust sound I want