Which is Best, C5 or C6
The following users liked this post:
steady_p (08-01-2019)
The following users liked this post:
Harold97 (10-19-2020)
#25
Melting Slicks
For those who think C6's have no problems you are crazy! I can't tell you how many times I have shaken my head at the many, many common issues I have found and worked on with the C6.
Here is a quick list off the top of my head of common problems found in the C6...
Slave cylinders- $1k+ to fix
Clutch pressure plates- $1k+ to fix
Window regulators- $500+ to fix
Headlight bulb- $300 from the dealer
Door release switches
Tires due to poor factory alignments
Removable top creaks
Belt squeals
Harmonic balancer wobble
Differentials that grenade ('05)
Battery failures (must have shifter in reverse when off)
Rear compartment lights don't come on (latch)
Service active handling (steering wheel pos sensor)
Service charging system (harmonic balancer and or alternator)
Fuel door release cable/actuator (spring breaks inside)
Key Fobs not detected
Pet Peves about the C6 that I have...
Keyless entry and ignition... half the time the door doesn't open the first time or engine doesn't start/shut off the first time.
Ugly rear bumper that flexes and shakes over bumps.
Dash fades and discolors with normal cleaners.
Expensive parts... can never get the part you need, its always part of a more expensive part...ie Window regulator cable frayed...cant get cable must order regulator with door module for $500.
Knowing that if I buy a stick shift I need to change the clutch fluid with every oil change or I risk losing my clutch.
Less of a value compared to C5... you can find 05, 06 and 07's in the upper $20k range now. 97's didn't drop that low as quick. A mint 04 Corvette is worth the same or more than a mint 05 Corvette with similar miles.
The only way I would get into a C6 is if it were a C6 Z06 or ZR1.
Here is a quick list off the top of my head of common problems found in the C6...
Slave cylinders- $1k+ to fix
Clutch pressure plates- $1k+ to fix
Window regulators- $500+ to fix
Headlight bulb- $300 from the dealer
Door release switches
Tires due to poor factory alignments
Removable top creaks
Belt squeals
Harmonic balancer wobble
Differentials that grenade ('05)
Battery failures (must have shifter in reverse when off)
Rear compartment lights don't come on (latch)
Service active handling (steering wheel pos sensor)
Service charging system (harmonic balancer and or alternator)
Fuel door release cable/actuator (spring breaks inside)
Key Fobs not detected
Pet Peves about the C6 that I have...
Keyless entry and ignition... half the time the door doesn't open the first time or engine doesn't start/shut off the first time.
Ugly rear bumper that flexes and shakes over bumps.
Dash fades and discolors with normal cleaners.
Expensive parts... can never get the part you need, its always part of a more expensive part...ie Window regulator cable frayed...cant get cable must order regulator with door module for $500.
Knowing that if I buy a stick shift I need to change the clutch fluid with every oil change or I risk losing my clutch.
Less of a value compared to C5... you can find 05, 06 and 07's in the upper $20k range now. 97's didn't drop that low as quick. A mint 04 Corvette is worth the same or more than a mint 05 Corvette with similar miles.
The only way I would get into a C6 is if it were a C6 Z06 or ZR1.
#26
Melting Slicks
Kind of off the subject but why not keep the 64? It's a C2 and they are the ultimate Corvette. As for C5 vs. C6 I think it depends on which body style you like better. You can get a really nice C5 for under $20k while a C6 will cost you $5k+ more. Good luck with your decision
#27
Team Owner
Member Since: Jan 2009
Location: Somewhere in Mo
Posts: 73,434
Likes: 0
Received 31 Likes
on
27 Posts
St. Jude Donor '09-'10, '14
For those who think C6's have no problems you are crazy! I can't tell you how many times I have shaken my head at the many, many common issues I have found and worked on with the C6.
Here is a quick list off the top of my head of common problems found in the C6...
Slave cylinders- $1k+ to fix
Clutch pressure plates- $1k+ to fix
Window regulators- $500+ to fix
Headlight bulb- $300 from the dealer
Door release switches
Tires due to poor factory alignments
Removable top creaks
Belt squeals
Harmonic balancer wobble
Differentials that grenade ('05)
Battery failures (must have shifter in reverse when off)
Rear compartment lights don't come on (latch)
Service active handling (steering wheel pos sensor)
Service charging system (harmonic balancer and or alternator)
Fuel door release cable/actuator (spring breaks inside)
Key Fobs not detected
Pet Peves about the C6 that I have...
Keyless entry and ignition... half the time the door doesn't open the first time or engine doesn't start/shut off the first time.
Ugly rear bumper that flexes and shakes over bumps.
Dash fades and discolors with normal cleaners.
Expensive parts... can never get the part you need, its always part of a more expensive part...ie Window regulator cable frayed...cant get cable must order regulator with door module for $500.
Knowing that if I buy a stick shift I need to change the clutch fluid with every oil change or I risk losing my clutch.
Less of a value compared to C5... you can find 05, 06 and 07's in the upper $20k range now. 97's didn't drop that low as quick. A mint 04 Corvette is worth the same or more than a mint 05 Corvette with similar miles.
The only way I would get into a C6 is if it were a C6 Z06 or ZR1.
Here is a quick list off the top of my head of common problems found in the C6...
Slave cylinders- $1k+ to fix
Clutch pressure plates- $1k+ to fix
Window regulators- $500+ to fix
Headlight bulb- $300 from the dealer
Door release switches
Tires due to poor factory alignments
Removable top creaks
Belt squeals
Harmonic balancer wobble
Differentials that grenade ('05)
Battery failures (must have shifter in reverse when off)
Rear compartment lights don't come on (latch)
Service active handling (steering wheel pos sensor)
Service charging system (harmonic balancer and or alternator)
Fuel door release cable/actuator (spring breaks inside)
Key Fobs not detected
Pet Peves about the C6 that I have...
Keyless entry and ignition... half the time the door doesn't open the first time or engine doesn't start/shut off the first time.
Ugly rear bumper that flexes and shakes over bumps.
Dash fades and discolors with normal cleaners.
Expensive parts... can never get the part you need, its always part of a more expensive part...ie Window regulator cable frayed...cant get cable must order regulator with door module for $500.
Knowing that if I buy a stick shift I need to change the clutch fluid with every oil change or I risk losing my clutch.
Less of a value compared to C5... you can find 05, 06 and 07's in the upper $20k range now. 97's didn't drop that low as quick. A mint 04 Corvette is worth the same or more than a mint 05 Corvette with similar miles.
The only way I would get into a C6 is if it were a C6 Z06 or ZR1.
Fire away boys, prove me wrong.
The following users liked this post:
speedracer2 (10-05-2020)
#28
Intermediate
Thread Starter
Member Since: Aug 2011
Location: Mansfield MA
Posts: 38
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Geez....that's quite the list, and something to consider Are all these problems relative to the C6 only? Does an 04 C5 have its own list of problems?
Thanks,
Bob
Thanks,
Bob
#29
Team Owner
Member Since: Jan 2009
Location: Somewhere in Mo
Posts: 73,434
Likes: 0
Received 31 Likes
on
27 Posts
St. Jude Donor '09-'10, '14
And the problem with all the elctronic gadgets is one simple issue from a wire can cause all sorts of other stuff to happen so unless you're experienced it's a nightmare to find out the cause. You can't even go with a simple code, like Oh it's that code so if I fix that it will solve the problem. it doesn't work that way.
My experience has been with other cars like roadrunners, camaros, other classic cars and related muscle type cars.
(These are my opinons and taken from personal experience and the experiences of people I know.) See my join date here? It was because I was looking for a fix to an issue on my C4 that I found this place.
But if you don't mind the issues and can wrench yourself, they are wonderful cars, all of them! You won't find a more fun car to drive I guarantee that.
Last edited by RetiredSFC 97; 08-30-2011 at 12:30 PM.
#31
My next car will be a C6, someday, an 08+, someday.
I bought my 2001 in Feb of 2009 with 32,505 and traded it in for $12,500 with almost 70,000 miles on it. Almost 40,000 flawless miles in 2 years and 3 months and I was not easy on the car at all.
With a 15 month old and another one on the way in December, I'll have some years to save up for my next Vette as for now I'm Vette-less.
I had the C5 and it was awesome, the most awesome machine I've ever had but I'm not going back to that car again. I'll be in a C6 at least.
I bought my 2001 in Feb of 2009 with 32,505 and traded it in for $12,500 with almost 70,000 miles on it. Almost 40,000 flawless miles in 2 years and 3 months and I was not easy on the car at all.
With a 15 month old and another one on the way in December, I'll have some years to save up for my next Vette as for now I'm Vette-less.
I had the C5 and it was awesome, the most awesome machine I've ever had but I'm not going back to that car again. I'll be in a C6 at least.
#32
Melting Slicks
Other than that an 03-04 is your best bet for a C5 in term of quality. I could make a list of common issues but I assure you the cars are better built than C6's. If only they came out with the LS3 earlier.
#33
Le Mans Master
The C6 has more plastic on it. I've also read an article where GM admitted the C6 is a very cheaply built car. They also say in the same article that the C5 is the best Vette they've ever made. I personally love the looks of the C6 but after reading about GM saying themselves that the C6 is cheaply built, I'll keep my C5. I'll try and find that article again and post it.
Yup, I would like to read that "article". At any rate, I traded an '02 C5Z for a '10 GrandSport. The GS is a better Car in every way.
#34
In my experience I have found none of these vettes are built worth a ****. They're pretty much what I always thought they were, a rich man's toy or someone who enjoys working on them all the time. But they're not for someone who expects quality, I do know that.
Fire away boys, prove me wrong.
Fire away boys, prove me wrong.
The following users liked this post:
speedracer2 (10-05-2020)
#35
Melting Slicks
I have to disagree tho. There are many things about it that are improved over the C5 but in some aspects they cut some corners short. A big difference between a NEW C6 owner and a C5 owner is:
1.) New Car Warranty
2.) You got the ca$h. Problems aren't as big of a deal for you VS the majority of current C5 owners who can't afford a new C6 .
#36
Corvette C5 Enthusiast
Beating the horse here a bit.....but from personal bias, I believe the C5 is the way to go. The syle and lines of the C5 are classic as compared to the C6. Sure, each year had issues, but when I roll down the road and see a C6 coming at me, I wave.....but then I smile because I know my C5 is the better looking car.
#37
Le Mans Master
Member Since: Aug 2004
Location: West Michigan crew Mich
Posts: 8,506
Likes: 0
Received 4 Likes
on
3 Posts
CI 7-8-9 Veteran
St. Jude Donor '07-'08 & '12
Beating the horse here a bit.....but from personal bias, I believe the C5 is the way to go. The syle and lines of the C5 are classic as compared to the C6. Sure, each year had issues, but when I roll down the road and see a C6 coming at me, I wave.....but then I smile because I know my C5 is the better looking car.
I will say this I had a c5 for 7 years and a c6 for 1 year and I enjoyed them both the same. My point is you can be happy with either car
#38
Safety Car
my personal opinion is if you can afford a C6, then you could also afford an 04 C5 (which would be my choice personally and not just because i own one), it all comes down to what it is you like. if you like the styling of the C6, then the standard advice of buy as new with as low mileage as you can will certainly apply. i have to admit that the people i have spoken to with C6s seem to love them. they certainly offer a wider array of OEM features (that many of us with C5s have modded our cars to replicate). i just can't get over the styling which just doesn't appeal to me at all. it hasn't since the 05 came out and it still doesn't, and i am a corvette guy having owned at least one most of my adult life since 1964. that said, it still comes down to what you can afford and what actual appeals to you.
Last edited by srs244; 08-31-2011 at 05:18 PM.
The following users liked this post:
JimHarris4 (10-09-2020)
#39
Le Mans Master
If I spent $50K, $60, or maybe even $70k on a GS I sure as hell would talk my self into saying it's a better car in every way too!
I have to disagree tho. There are many things about it that are improved over the C5 but in some aspects they cut some corners short. A big difference between a NEW C6 owner and a C5 owner is:
1.) New Car Warranty
2.) You got the ca$h. Problems aren't as big of a deal for you VS the majority of current C5 owners who can't afford a new C6 .
I have to disagree tho. There are many things about it that are improved over the C5 but in some aspects they cut some corners short. A big difference between a NEW C6 owner and a C5 owner is:
1.) New Car Warranty
2.) You got the ca$h. Problems aren't as big of a deal for you VS the majority of current C5 owners who can't afford a new C6 .
30K plus the Z got me a '10 GrandSport with NPP exhaust, two tops, 3LT, two tone interior/seats. chrome wheels, six speed, better interior. And, the updated C6 look. The C5 was a great generation. But, the nineties technology/look were just too dated for me.
#40
Melting Slicks
Does a mid 90's Viper look outdated? NO! Neither does the C5 Corvette. They are both original looking, sexy and will not be outdated for decades.
As long as you are happy than that's all that matters. Personally I would have kept the $30k, put $10K into the C5Z and have a car that looks better and is faster than your GS and have $20k left over.