When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.
"NEVER buy a toy unless you can pay for it in cash. If you can't afford it, then you can't afford to take out a loan for it".
Never steered me wrong...
boats are toys, lots of vettes are toys and I would guess many are financed by responsible people every day. Every situation is different and we don’t really know this person’s situation.
Pretty interesting video on the topic. I don't entirely agree with everything he says, but the rest of his channel has some great C5 specific car content (non-finance related).
My daughter got shot down by a couple banks since she had no credit history...decent income just never had any revolving credit accts...we encouraged her to buy a new car so it had a warranty, maint plan, etc...we simply co-signed and she was good to go...that's all she needs is a co-signer and she's golden.
Have her try Lightstream, it’s a division of SunTrust Bank. I used them for mine last year and very good rates for short terms. They will deposit the money right in her bank account and she will then write you a check. She will get multiple emails telling her what she needs to do and obtain for records to send back to them.
Weak financial advice (or lack thereof). Buy buying cars/toys on loan, it means one likely doesn't have a 6 month to 1 year emergency fund, it delays retirement, delays a down payment on a house....etc etc.
And you build up credit easily just by having open accounts (eg. credit card bills paid in full each month), spending foolishly is not advised to get a good credit score.
I'm a CPA so I might know what I'm talking about here.
Actually you are completely wrong. An installment loan paid on time will do nothing but make her credit score go up. Stick to cranking out tax returns and balance sheets
Just a little update, PenFed did in fact finance the car for her! She could not be happier. The car passed Maryland inspection with flying colors did not even need a windshield wiper replacement! Her insurance went up 20 bucks a month.
thats good news, I didn't understand why some were telling you not to sell her the car. Especially not knowing the full story, they were assuming she had no one in her life to advise her. Also if you didn't sell it to her what would stop her from going to a dealership and paying more, plus hitting her with a high interest loan. Credit Unions have great rates, I hope she enjoys the car :thumbs
Just a little update, PenFed did in fact finance the car for her! She could not be happier. The car passed Maryland inspection with flying colors did not even need a windshield wiper replacement! Her insurance went up 20 bucks a month.
Thanks to those who actually gave advice.
Sounds like a win-win. You had a car you were wanting to sell. You had a buyer wanting the car who needed to finance her purchase. She secured a loan which I understand will help her establish credit. Some are fortunate enough to pay cash for everything they buy; others of us have to finance homes, cars, and other significant purchases. My wife's parents and my parents thought we were not fiscally sound when we had to finance our first house - guess everything is relative.
thats good news, I didn't understand why some were telling you not to sell her the car. Especially not knowing the full story, they were assuming she had no one in her life to advise her. Also if you didn't sell it to her what would stop her from going to a dealership and paying more, plus hitting her with a high interest loan. Credit Unions have great rates, I hope she enjoys the car :thumbs
yeah it's amazing how everyone seems to know the answers about other peoples lives when they really don't know a damn thing. I forgot to mention she got a 3.9% interest rate. If she had gone to a dealer and bought a car she would've gotten nailed with a rate at least twice that maybe triple. Not sure why so many people think this car which is in mint condition is going to give her so many problems. As if other used cars are 100% reliable. All cars have problems but mine treat me very well because I take very very good care of them
yeah it's amazing how everyone seems to know the answers about other peoples lives when they really don't know a damn thing. I forgot to mention she got a 3.9% interest rate. If she had gone to a dealer and bought a car she would've gotten nailed with a rate at least twice that maybe triple. Not sure why so many people think this car which is in mint condition is going to give her so many problems. As if other used cars are 100% reliable. All cars have problems but mine treat me very well because I take very very good care of them
Here you go HeeHaw, I gave you your first "Thanks" Glad it worked out for both of you. The 1999 FRC that I bought 5 years ago has cost me next to nothing to repair and maintain. Hope she has the same results.
Penfed's shortest auto loan is 36 months. At 3.9% she's probably in a 48 month loan on a 19 year old car. It will be 23 years old when the loan is up.
Since she was unable to pay in full for the car, she is likely unable to afford any significant repair on the car. Her insurance and fuel costs went up as well. Brakes, tires, waterpump, clutch, etc. are far more likely to need replaced on a 19 year old car than a 2 or 3 year old car.
Justify it all you want; this was not a financially responsible decision. Ask this young girl how she feels about this purchase three years from now. I'll wager she'll regret it.
Now, you didn't initially ask *should* she get a loan on it, but rather *could* she get a loan on it. But...the forum can't help itself (been there, done that).
Penfed's shortest auto loan is 36 months. At 3.9% she's probably in a 48 month loan on a 19 year old car. It will be 23 years old when the loan is up.
Since she was unable to pay in full for the car, she is likely unable to afford any significant repair on the car. Her insurance and fuel costs went up as well. Brakes, tires, waterpump, clutch, etc. are far more likely to need replaced on a 19 year old car than a 2 or 3 year old car.
Justify it all you want; this was not a financially responsible decision. Ask this young girl how she feels about this purchase three years from now. I'll wager she'll regret it.
Now, you didn't initially ask *should* she get a loan on it, but rather *could* she get a loan on it. But...the forum can't help itself (been there, done that).
Peace.
I'm not justifying anything and I don't feel bad or regret selling her the car. Peace.
Here you go HeeHaw, I gave you your first "Thanks" Glad it worked out for both of you. The 1999 FRC that I bought 5 years ago has cost me next to nothing to repair and maintain. Hope she has the same results.
steve
"Thanks" Steve! I know there are many many c5s (and C4s) out there with well over 200K. She makes decent money and plans on paying the car off in less than two years. Bye then her credit will be stronger and then she's going to get a newer vehicle and keep the vet as a toy. This forum has really gotten bad, worse than I remember. Far too many financial experts and psychiatrists for me. 😂 Cheers to you!
Congratulations on getting the deal done. A C5 does not have to be a toy, it can be driven daily and is not expensive to maintain. My only hesitation for this young lady would be winter driving. If she can't drive it in Jan-Feb because of ice and snow, how will she get to work? I gather that she's thought this through, since it's February now. As for the rest - the C5 is a good every day car as long as you don't have little kids who need a back seat. I'm sure that she'll love the car, and I'm glad she found a way to buy it.
Congratulations on getting the deal done. A C5 does not have to be a toy, it can be driven daily and is not expensive to maintain. My only hesitation for this young lady would be winter driving. If she can't drive it in Jan-Feb because of ice and snow, how will she get to work? I gather that she's thought this through, since it's February now. As for the rest - the C5 is a good every day car as long as you don't have little kids who need a back seat. I'm sure that she'll love the car, and I'm glad she found a way to buy it.
You are correct it really does not cost substantially more than any other car if well-maintained. We don't get a lot of snow here. She was driving a worn out 2002 mustang so she's making a lateral move in regards to winter driving. It amazes me all the negativity in this post. It's one of the reasons I don't come around here anymore.