2007 Z51 LS2 Corvette vs 2008 Z51 LS3 Corvette
#22
People like Rusty is why I started this discussion. Like I stated before better hope you are a good driver because it ultimately comes down to the driver in order to get that car length.
Last edited by Sic Liter; 09-22-2017 at 11:59 AM.
#23
Having owned seven vettes in the last 10 years....its not just asbout peak power....the ls3 is much more driveable day to day because of the broader torque curve and the fact that they really improved heat soak on this engine...my old ls2 car would really run like a dog on hot summer days...the ls3's...no problem. Also the better trans makes quite a difference too.
#24
#25
Having owned seven vettes in the last 10 years....its not just asbout peak power....the ls3 is much more driveable day to day because of the broader torque curve and the fact that they really improved heat soak on this engine...my old ls2 car would really run like a dog on hot summer days...the ls3's...no problem. Also the better trans makes quite a difference too.
Last edited by Sic Liter; 09-22-2017 at 11:43 AM.
#26
Instructor
Your horsepower and weight tell you what your horsepower weight ratio is. Trap speed has NOTHING to do with it. Come on man. I've attached a link to do it for you.
https://www.easycalculation.com/phys...ight-ratio.php
#27
Instructor
The times clearly show that on average, with the average driver, the ls3 is faster.
So by default, the ls3 is faster.
Last edited by mtarr07; 09-22-2017 at 01:20 PM.
#28
Instructor
Show us a stock LS2 and a stock LS3 on a dyno back to back where the LS2 makes more torque.
You are providing ZERO real world data to substantiate your claims.
And you know dont even know how to calculate HP/ weight ratio.
#29
Racer
Agreed, why do people keep beating this dead horse?
The following users liked this post:
95rtturbo (09-22-2017)
#30
Drifting
Sorry bud. They're definitely more different than just "comes down to the driver". GM took what the aftermarket was doing and applied it to the next generation. Larger bore, better intake, more aggressive camshaft, strengthened casting, etc. The results can be seen in post #3.
So don't come in here, with your anger and regret, trying to prove something to yaself!
torque curve looks similar to me!
Honestly, you have a C6. ENJOY IT!! Do you think the LS3 guys are saying the new LT1 just comes down to the driver? NO. It's the next generation with several advancements. If GM didn't advance the designs every generation, we'd all have blue flame I6 engines.
I researched and found the car I wanted to modify. That car has an LS3.
#31
Drifting
Member Since: Nov 2011
Location: Chesterfield (St. Louis) MO
Posts: 1,377
Received 40 Likes
on
34 Posts
Finally starting to get some logical replies, good to see. The LS3 is more powerful, period. No debating it. No one is saying the LS2 sucks. I have an 08Z (LS7). No reason for me to make an asinine post saying the LS7 is more powerful than the LS9.
Last edited by 95rtturbo; 09-22-2017 at 02:01 PM.
#32
I just did an average trap calculation between the LS2 and the LS3 data from the list you provided. The average trap for the LS2 was 112.05 mph, the average trap for the LS3 was 115.83 mph. Trap speed tells you what your HP to weight is. My math comes out to be 115.83/112.05 = 3.37%. The LS3 is 430 hp, so 430*(0.9663) = 415 hp for the LS2. 15 HP difference means it ultimately comes down to the driver.
That's a 2.5 mph gain.... 25 hp
#33
You can't argue the Airflow from the Heads and the Intake Air Flow... Ls2 guys/gals have to install a FAST 102 plenum to match the LS3
Add the NPP option and there is no doubt the LS3 is faster...
Even at 410hp... the npp option car is 436
And how can you make up for the displacement.... 6.0 vs 6.2
Add the NPP option and there is no doubt the LS3 is faster...
Even at 410hp... the npp option car is 436
And how can you make up for the displacement.... 6.0 vs 6.2
Last edited by 2L8LUZ; 09-22-2017 at 02:47 PM.
#34
I think at this point the market is just so flooded with C6s for great prices that there isn't really a price difference from 2006-2009 cars for example. It comes down more often to that specific seller and what they want to get for their car. So why not get the newer one with more power if everything else is equal?
I think you're diving a bit deep with your analysis based on ONE data point. Maybe the LS3 is underrated? Maybe neither of them are? Who knows?
What I do know is that real world data consistently proves that the LS3 car traps 4-5mph higher than LS2 cars. Look at the tops 1/4 mile list for both from this very forum.
Showroom Stock LS2 (2005 -2007)
12.215 @ 115.45 - LS1LT1 - 06 A6 - (1278)
12.235 @ 115.58 - 06C6FVR - 06 M6 Z51 - (333)
12.290 @ 114.29 - Proney - 07 M6 - (4500)
12.314 @ 114.82 - CYA Vett - 05 M6 F55 - (675)
12.422 @ 113.90 - DrRichie - 05 M6 Z51
12.499 @ 114.90 - Jschindler - 05 M6 Z51
12.53x @ 113.00 - Wicked07C6 - 07 M6 Z51 - (914)
12.540 @ 113.59 - Tony 63 Vette - 06 A6 - (1510)
12.548 @ 113.74 - Tony96LT4 - 06 A6 Z51 - (1149)
12.56x @ 113.39 - Red Sleeper - 06 A6
12.56x @ 112.00 - Orange C6 - 05 A4 Z51 - (56)
12.650 @ 111.65 - Zippin Zee - 05 M6 Z51 - (48)
12.665 @ 113.03 - Mdrrandall - 07 M6 Z51 - (1675)
12.693 @ 114.88 - Prankster - 06 M6 - (1621)
12.69x @ 112.32 - Silverlx - 06 A6 - (872)
12.703 @ 112.43 - Jelsis - 06 A6 Z51 - (452)
12.70x @ 113.00 - Blackmajik - 07 A6 - (1627)
12.71x @ 111.30 - Flyin05 - 05 M6 Z51
12.71x @ 111.00 - Demented - 05 A4 Z51
12.74x @ 108.67 - Shooter 49 - 05 A4 3.15 - (39)
12.756 @ 112.57 - C5Pilot - 07 A6 Z51 - (903)
12.757 @ 109.25 - Ponchorello - 05 A4 3.15 - (990)
12.795 @ 112.17 - Jchazr - 05 M6 Z51 - (447)
12.80x @ 111.00 - SheDevilC6 - 07 A6 Z51 - (1668)
12.81x @ 112.83 - Vette-oholic - 05 M6 Z51 - (494)
12.817 @ 110.95 - SkyKing - 07 A6 F55 - (2480)
12.85x @ 114.53 - Mr Z51 - 06 M6 Z51
12.917 @ 111.67 - Brewcitygymratt - 06 A6 - (4578)
12.936 @ 111.40 - DiggyMoe - 07 M6 - (965)
12.97x @ 108.00 - Ginny C6 - 05 A4 F55 - (56)
12.98x @ 108.00 - Tampa Vet - 05 A4 3.15 - (119)
12.99x @ 111.70 - C64ME - 05 M6 Z51 - (329)
13.04x @ 109.15 - TMyers - 06 A6 - (528)
13.054 @ 113.31 - RDunn - 06 M6 - (982)
13.10x @ 108.70 - Rothchilds - 05 A4 F55 3.15
13.12x @ 110.40 - JDWK - 05 M6 Z51
13.25x @ 110.60 - C6 Matt - 05 M6 Z51 - (118)
13.267 @ 108.59 - Sfadchi - 06 A6 Z51 - (884)
13.26x @ 105.30 - Joeking - 05 A4 Z51 - (657)
13.30x @ 107.00 - Shurite44 - 06 A6 Z51 - (764)
13.35x @ 108.10 - Phatpharmd - 06 A6 - (591)
13.62x @ 106.18 - Rich28 - 05 A4 Z51
Showroom Stock LS3 (2008 - 2013)
11.718 @ 119.94 - AndrewZPSU - 08 M6 - (2586)
11.806 @ 118.82 - Gmrulz - 08 A6 Z51, NPP - (3478)
11.974 @ 116.98 - Proney - 08 M6 Z51, NPP - (4652)
12.058 @ 122.05 - AndrewZPSU - 10 A6 NPP - (5051)
12.100 @ 115.19 - Odin - 09 A6 2.73 npp - (4325)
12.102 @ 117.60 - Dingrao - 08 A6 - (3561)
12.127 @ 116.59 - Pettvette - 08 A6 - (4278)
12.159 @ 115.59 - Old Goat - 09 A6 2.73 - (3708)
12.167 @ 117.15 - DarkOctane - 08 A6 NPP - (6310)
12.167 @ 116.54 - Vinsane112 - 08 A6 2.73 - (2740)
12.173 @ 117.59 - Marcho Polo - 08 A6 Z51 2.73 npp - (7213)
12.186 @ 117.72 - Hardhattg - 08 M6 Z51 - (2686)
12.201 @ 114.07 - DerekSDickens - 08 A6 2.73 - (7061)
12.237 @ 112.86 - 940CACC - 08 A6 - (2871)
12.244 @ 117.83 - 74Vette - 08 M6 - (4617)
12.305 @ 116.51 - JBrunoJC6 - 08 A6 NPP - (6722)
12.400 @ 116.36 - RandyDank23 - 08 A6 - (6059)
12.262 @ 115.22 - Oklahoma - 08 A6 - (3765)
12.276 @ 118.66 - EZ28 - 08 M6 Z51 NPP - (3247)
12.355 @ 117.47 - Bain - 08 A6 NPP 2.73 - (2755)
12.357 @ 116.94 - TNorman - 08 A6 NPP - (4227)
12.408 @ 116.11 - XtremeChubbles - 08 A6 Z51 - (6589)
12.409 @ 114.70 - Jschindler - 08 M6 Z51 NPP - (2132)
12.419 @ 116.15 - JTorchz06 - 09 A6 Z51 NPP - (3185)
12.412 @ 115.38 - HOXXOH - 08 A6 F55 - (2478)
12.428 @ 116.67 - Pea-Jay - 08 A6 - (4448)
12.494 @ 115.54 - 1.8T - 08 M6 Z51 - (2310)
12.500 @ 115.53 - Shane Fap - 08 A6 - (6298)
12.514 @ 116.73 - SK360 - 08 A6 2.73 - (6283)
12.552 @ 114.70 - Larry R - 08 A6 2.73 - (4054)
12.600 @ 114.12 - Beefcake - 08 A6 - (2875)
12.658 @ 114.99 - PhillyLS1 - 09 M6 - (3151)
12.668 @ 113.61 - CFP40 - 08 A6 NPP 2.73 - (2828)
12.689 @ 112.07 - Bfppt1 - 10 A6 - (5300)
12.747 @ 114.31 - Detoxx03 - 08 M6 NPP- (4057)
12.828 @ 113.20 - C6David - 08 A6 NPP - (6854)
13.354 @ 110.78 - M453W - 09 A6 NPP- (5708)
13.428 @ 109.32 - Dan Wendling - 09 A6 NPP - (4032)
I think you're diving a bit deep with your analysis based on ONE data point. Maybe the LS3 is underrated? Maybe neither of them are? Who knows?
What I do know is that real world data consistently proves that the LS3 car traps 4-5mph higher than LS2 cars. Look at the tops 1/4 mile list for both from this very forum.
Showroom Stock LS2 (2005 -2007)
12.215 @ 115.45 - LS1LT1 - 06 A6 - (1278)
12.235 @ 115.58 - 06C6FVR - 06 M6 Z51 - (333)
12.290 @ 114.29 - Proney - 07 M6 - (4500)
12.314 @ 114.82 - CYA Vett - 05 M6 F55 - (675)
12.422 @ 113.90 - DrRichie - 05 M6 Z51
12.499 @ 114.90 - Jschindler - 05 M6 Z51
12.53x @ 113.00 - Wicked07C6 - 07 M6 Z51 - (914)
12.540 @ 113.59 - Tony 63 Vette - 06 A6 - (1510)
12.548 @ 113.74 - Tony96LT4 - 06 A6 Z51 - (1149)
12.56x @ 113.39 - Red Sleeper - 06 A6
12.56x @ 112.00 - Orange C6 - 05 A4 Z51 - (56)
12.650 @ 111.65 - Zippin Zee - 05 M6 Z51 - (48)
12.665 @ 113.03 - Mdrrandall - 07 M6 Z51 - (1675)
12.693 @ 114.88 - Prankster - 06 M6 - (1621)
12.69x @ 112.32 - Silverlx - 06 A6 - (872)
12.703 @ 112.43 - Jelsis - 06 A6 Z51 - (452)
12.70x @ 113.00 - Blackmajik - 07 A6 - (1627)
12.71x @ 111.30 - Flyin05 - 05 M6 Z51
12.71x @ 111.00 - Demented - 05 A4 Z51
12.74x @ 108.67 - Shooter 49 - 05 A4 3.15 - (39)
12.756 @ 112.57 - C5Pilot - 07 A6 Z51 - (903)
12.757 @ 109.25 - Ponchorello - 05 A4 3.15 - (990)
12.795 @ 112.17 - Jchazr - 05 M6 Z51 - (447)
12.80x @ 111.00 - SheDevilC6 - 07 A6 Z51 - (1668)
12.81x @ 112.83 - Vette-oholic - 05 M6 Z51 - (494)
12.817 @ 110.95 - SkyKing - 07 A6 F55 - (2480)
12.85x @ 114.53 - Mr Z51 - 06 M6 Z51
12.917 @ 111.67 - Brewcitygymratt - 06 A6 - (4578)
12.936 @ 111.40 - DiggyMoe - 07 M6 - (965)
12.97x @ 108.00 - Ginny C6 - 05 A4 F55 - (56)
12.98x @ 108.00 - Tampa Vet - 05 A4 3.15 - (119)
12.99x @ 111.70 - C64ME - 05 M6 Z51 - (329)
13.04x @ 109.15 - TMyers - 06 A6 - (528)
13.054 @ 113.31 - RDunn - 06 M6 - (982)
13.10x @ 108.70 - Rothchilds - 05 A4 F55 3.15
13.12x @ 110.40 - JDWK - 05 M6 Z51
13.25x @ 110.60 - C6 Matt - 05 M6 Z51 - (118)
13.267 @ 108.59 - Sfadchi - 06 A6 Z51 - (884)
13.26x @ 105.30 - Joeking - 05 A4 Z51 - (657)
13.30x @ 107.00 - Shurite44 - 06 A6 Z51 - (764)
13.35x @ 108.10 - Phatpharmd - 06 A6 - (591)
13.62x @ 106.18 - Rich28 - 05 A4 Z51
Showroom Stock LS3 (2008 - 2013)
11.718 @ 119.94 - AndrewZPSU - 08 M6 - (2586)
11.806 @ 118.82 - Gmrulz - 08 A6 Z51, NPP - (3478)
11.974 @ 116.98 - Proney - 08 M6 Z51, NPP - (4652)
12.058 @ 122.05 - AndrewZPSU - 10 A6 NPP - (5051)
12.100 @ 115.19 - Odin - 09 A6 2.73 npp - (4325)
12.102 @ 117.60 - Dingrao - 08 A6 - (3561)
12.127 @ 116.59 - Pettvette - 08 A6 - (4278)
12.159 @ 115.59 - Old Goat - 09 A6 2.73 - (3708)
12.167 @ 117.15 - DarkOctane - 08 A6 NPP - (6310)
12.167 @ 116.54 - Vinsane112 - 08 A6 2.73 - (2740)
12.173 @ 117.59 - Marcho Polo - 08 A6 Z51 2.73 npp - (7213)
12.186 @ 117.72 - Hardhattg - 08 M6 Z51 - (2686)
12.201 @ 114.07 - DerekSDickens - 08 A6 2.73 - (7061)
12.237 @ 112.86 - 940CACC - 08 A6 - (2871)
12.244 @ 117.83 - 74Vette - 08 M6 - (4617)
12.305 @ 116.51 - JBrunoJC6 - 08 A6 NPP - (6722)
12.400 @ 116.36 - RandyDank23 - 08 A6 - (6059)
12.262 @ 115.22 - Oklahoma - 08 A6 - (3765)
12.276 @ 118.66 - EZ28 - 08 M6 Z51 NPP - (3247)
12.355 @ 117.47 - Bain - 08 A6 NPP 2.73 - (2755)
12.357 @ 116.94 - TNorman - 08 A6 NPP - (4227)
12.408 @ 116.11 - XtremeChubbles - 08 A6 Z51 - (6589)
12.409 @ 114.70 - Jschindler - 08 M6 Z51 NPP - (2132)
12.419 @ 116.15 - JTorchz06 - 09 A6 Z51 NPP - (3185)
12.412 @ 115.38 - HOXXOH - 08 A6 F55 - (2478)
12.428 @ 116.67 - Pea-Jay - 08 A6 - (4448)
12.494 @ 115.54 - 1.8T - 08 M6 Z51 - (2310)
12.500 @ 115.53 - Shane Fap - 08 A6 - (6298)
12.514 @ 116.73 - SK360 - 08 A6 2.73 - (6283)
12.552 @ 114.70 - Larry R - 08 A6 2.73 - (4054)
12.600 @ 114.12 - Beefcake - 08 A6 - (2875)
12.658 @ 114.99 - PhillyLS1 - 09 M6 - (3151)
12.668 @ 113.61 - CFP40 - 08 A6 NPP 2.73 - (2828)
12.689 @ 112.07 - Bfppt1 - 10 A6 - (5300)
12.747 @ 114.31 - Detoxx03 - 08 M6 NPP- (4057)
12.828 @ 113.20 - C6David - 08 A6 NPP - (6854)
13.354 @ 110.78 - M453W - 09 A6 NPP- (5708)
13.428 @ 109.32 - Dan Wendling - 09 A6 NPP - (4032)
#36
Sorry bud. They're definitely more different than just "comes down to the driver". GM took what the aftermarket was doing and applied it to the next generation. Larger bore, better intake, more aggressive camshaft, strengthened casting, etc. The results can be seen in post #3.
So don't come in here, with your anger and regret, trying to prove something to yaself!
torque curve looks similar to me!
Honestly, you have a C6. ENJOY IT!! Do you think the LS3 guys are saying the new LT1 just comes down to the driver? NO. It's the next generation with several advancements. If GM didn't advance the designs every generation, we'd all have blue flame I6 engines.
I researched and found the car I wanted to modify. That car has an LS3.
Last edited by Sic Liter; 09-22-2017 at 03:02 PM.
#38
Drifting
Member Since: Nov 2011
Location: Chesterfield (St. Louis) MO
Posts: 1,377
Received 40 Likes
on
34 Posts
That is one spot on the curve, and the tq is basically even to the LS2, which is moot. Doesn't make up for everywhere else the LS3 is making more tq.
Last edited by 95rtturbo; 09-22-2017 at 03:04 PM.
#39
Race Director
No, it's 436 HP. The exhaust contributes to engine HP, otherwise it wouldn't be called HP.