Squeaking & Wobbling Harmonic Balancer
#1
Intermediate
Thread Starter
Member Since: Apr 2011
Location: Chicago IL
Posts: 35
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Squeaking & Wobbling Harmonic Balancer
I recently started hearing a squeaking noise coming from under the hood from my 2005 Corvette. I've owned the car for about 3 weeks now and about a week ago it started squeaking. It rained that day so I didn't think much of it (thought one of the belts got wet). 2-3 days passed and the squeak got even louder and more annoying so I went to Autozone and got some "belt dressing" thinking it would solve the problem. When I popped the hood to apply it I then noticed my Crankshaft Pulley was wobbling all over the place.
I got on the forums right away to see if anybody else has had this problem and come to find out there was a TSB on it (05-06-01-001A) which affected early 05 vettes Built Prior to VIN Breakpoint 55111039 (but mine is 55137328 so it doesn't fall in that TSB?)
Anyways long story short I see I have a problem and I just thought i'd stop by for some advice. I'm new to the GM family (this is actually my first American car i've ever owned so I'm def no vette expert) but I have been up for the past 24 hours stressing about this issue (I didnt expect this to happen after owning the car for 3 weeks) but then again it is a USED car...
I don't understand why there's not a Recall for this when it seems to be clearly GM's fault (I'm not happy throwing away $1,000 for a repair that is a common problem among the early C6's) I don't know if I should still go to the dealership and see if they would be willing to fix it since it is a common problem or are they just gonna tell me screw you its out of warranty.
It currently has 30,400 miles. Any advice would be greatly appreciated.
I got on the forums right away to see if anybody else has had this problem and come to find out there was a TSB on it (05-06-01-001A) which affected early 05 vettes Built Prior to VIN Breakpoint 55111039 (but mine is 55137328 so it doesn't fall in that TSB?)
Anyways long story short I see I have a problem and I just thought i'd stop by for some advice. I'm new to the GM family (this is actually my first American car i've ever owned so I'm def no vette expert) but I have been up for the past 24 hours stressing about this issue (I didnt expect this to happen after owning the car for 3 weeks) but then again it is a USED car...
I don't understand why there's not a Recall for this when it seems to be clearly GM's fault (I'm not happy throwing away $1,000 for a repair that is a common problem among the early C6's) I don't know if I should still go to the dealership and see if they would be willing to fix it since it is a common problem or are they just gonna tell me screw you its out of warranty.
It currently has 30,400 miles. Any advice would be greatly appreciated.
Last edited by Alen2488; 04-25-2011 at 05:46 AM.
#2
Racer
Member Since: Jul 2009
Location: Newport News Virginia
Posts: 340
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Same thing happened to me a couple of months after buying my 2005. I took it to the dealer. No warranty coverage. The replacement cost at the dealer is about $1200.
Andy
Andy
#3
Heel & Toe
Member Since: Jan 2011
Location: Clute Texas
Posts: 22
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Same thing happened here on my '05...Was a mustang owner and bought my first vette and didnt know about the problem until I heard squeking a couple weeks after I purchased my car. Had to go to the dealership and damn near cuss everyone out to get them to fix it with the 60 warranty. Otherwise it was going to be $1200. It is ridiculous that GM doesnt fix this problem that they created.
#5
Le Mans Master
Member Since: Dec 2005
Location: North Western Connecticut
Posts: 7,598
Received 91 Likes
on
54 Posts
I recently started hearing a squeaking noise coming from under the hood from my 2005 Corvette. I've owned the car for about 3 weeks now and about a week ago it started squeaking. It rained that day so I didn't think much of it (thought one of the belts got wet). 2-3 days passed and the squeak got even louder and more annoying so I went to Autozone and got some "belt dressing" thinking it would solve the problem. When I popped the hood to apply it I then noticed my Crankshaft Pulley was wobbling all over the place.
I got on the forums right away to see if anybody else has had this problem and come to find out there was a TSB on it (05-06-01-001A) which affected early 05 vettes Built Prior to VIN Breakpoint 55111039 (but mine is 55137328 so it doesn't fall in that TSB?)
Anyways long story short I see I have a problem and I just thought i'd stop by for some advice. I'm new to the GM family (this is actually my first American car i've ever owned so I'm def no vette expert) but I have been up for the past 24 hours stressing about this issue (I didnt expect this to happen after owning the car for 3 weeks) but then again it is a USED car...
I don't understand why there's not a Recall for this when it seems to be clearly GM's fault (I'm not happy throwing away $1,000 for a repair that is a common problem among the early C6's) I don't know if I should still go to the dealership and see if they would be willing to fix it since it is a common problem or are they just gonna tell me screw you its out of warranty.
It currently has 30,400 miles. Any advice would be greatly appreciated.
I got on the forums right away to see if anybody else has had this problem and come to find out there was a TSB on it (05-06-01-001A) which affected early 05 vettes Built Prior to VIN Breakpoint 55111039 (but mine is 55137328 so it doesn't fall in that TSB?)
Anyways long story short I see I have a problem and I just thought i'd stop by for some advice. I'm new to the GM family (this is actually my first American car i've ever owned so I'm def no vette expert) but I have been up for the past 24 hours stressing about this issue (I didnt expect this to happen after owning the car for 3 weeks) but then again it is a USED car...
I don't understand why there's not a Recall for this when it seems to be clearly GM's fault (I'm not happy throwing away $1,000 for a repair that is a common problem among the early C6's) I don't know if I should still go to the dealership and see if they would be willing to fix it since it is a common problem or are they just gonna tell me screw you its out of warranty.
It currently has 30,400 miles. Any advice would be greatly appreciated.
#6
Intermediate
Thread Starter
Member Since: Apr 2011
Location: Chicago IL
Posts: 35
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
^ I completely agree. I stopped driving the car after I discovered the problem and plan on having it towed to wherever I decide to have the car fixed. I will still contact Chevy just to hear what they'll say but I'm 99.9 sure they'll give me the "the vehicle is out of warranty bs" as i've seen them deny people's cleaims for this that HAVE WARRANTY! Its quite sad that GM doesnt fix the problem that they created like SuperSox said and sadly to say this is probably my first and last GM car.
#8
Race Director
Member Since: Jun 2005
Location: Phila Suburbs 2023 C8 & 2013 650ix
Posts: 10,444
Received 2,241 Likes
on
1,149 Posts
There are two potential problems with the crank pulley for early 05 cars.
1. The TSB you mentioned was for a "possible" loosening of the center crank pulley bolt. Your car is out of range for that problem so that's not an issue for your car.
2. The rubber flex coupling integral with with crank pulley (harmonic balancer) fails causing the outer ring, that is attached to the pulley you see, causing the outer ring (pulley) to wobble. This part is obviously under designed and I suspect it can't handle the twisting forces caused by the rapid acceleration of our engines under full power.
No one has ever mentioned that GM has accepted responsibility for this under design and I suspect your only solution is either get it replaced with a stock balancer or an aftermarket balancer.
As far as having to tow the car to get it fixed, that's not necessary. It will squeak (usually a chirping) and the worst that will happen is that it will throw the belt. Just keep the rpms down on the way to getting it fixed and you should be ok.
1. The TSB you mentioned was for a "possible" loosening of the center crank pulley bolt. Your car is out of range for that problem so that's not an issue for your car.
2. The rubber flex coupling integral with with crank pulley (harmonic balancer) fails causing the outer ring, that is attached to the pulley you see, causing the outer ring (pulley) to wobble. This part is obviously under designed and I suspect it can't handle the twisting forces caused by the rapid acceleration of our engines under full power.
No one has ever mentioned that GM has accepted responsibility for this under design and I suspect your only solution is either get it replaced with a stock balancer or an aftermarket balancer.
As far as having to tow the car to get it fixed, that's not necessary. It will squeak (usually a chirping) and the worst that will happen is that it will throw the belt. Just keep the rpms down on the way to getting it fixed and you should be ok.
Last edited by Walt White Coupe; 04-25-2011 at 09:03 AM.
#9
Le Mans Master
I don't understand why there's not a Recall for this when it seems to be clearly GM's fault (I'm not happy throwing away $1,000 for a repair that is a common problem among the early C6's) I don't know if I should still go to the dealership and see if they would be willing to fix it since it is a common problem or are they just gonna tell me screw you its out of warranty.
It currently has 30,400 miles. Any advice would be greatly appreciated.
It currently has 30,400 miles. Any advice would be greatly appreciated.
#10
Intermediate
Thread Starter
Member Since: Apr 2011
Location: Chicago IL
Posts: 35
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
There are two potential problems with the crank pulley for early 05 cars.
1. The TSB you mentioned was for a "possible" loosening of the center crank pulley bolt. Your car is out of range for that problem so that's not an issue for your car.
2. The rubber flex coupling integral with with crank pulley (harmonic balancer) fails causing the outer ring, that is attached to the pulley you see, causing the outer ring (pulley) to wobble. This part is obviously under designed and I suspect it can't handle the twisting forces caused by the rapid acceleration of our engines under full power.
No one has ever mentioned that GM has accepted responsibility for this under design and I suspect your only solution is either get it replaced with a stock balancer or an aftermarket balancer.
As far as having to tow the car to get it fixed, that's not necessary. It will squeak (usually a chirping) and the worst that will happen is that it will throw the belt. Just keep the rpms down on the way to getting it fixed and you should be ok.
1. The TSB you mentioned was for a "possible" loosening of the center crank pulley bolt. Your car is out of range for that problem so that's not an issue for your car.
2. The rubber flex coupling integral with with crank pulley (harmonic balancer) fails causing the outer ring, that is attached to the pulley you see, causing the outer ring (pulley) to wobble. This part is obviously under designed and I suspect it can't handle the twisting forces caused by the rapid acceleration of our engines under full power.
No one has ever mentioned that GM has accepted responsibility for this under design and I suspect your only solution is either get it replaced with a stock balancer or an aftermarket balancer.
As far as having to tow the car to get it fixed, that's not necessary. It will squeak (usually a chirping) and the worst that will happen is that it will throw the belt. Just keep the rpms down on the way to getting it fixed and you should be ok.
#11
Intermediate
Thread Starter
Member Since: Apr 2011
Location: Chicago IL
Posts: 35
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
#12
Race Director
Member Since: Jun 2005
Location: Phila Suburbs 2023 C8 & 2013 650ix
Posts: 10,444
Received 2,241 Likes
on
1,149 Posts
If you go in and tell them that your research on the "chirping" belt is that the "harmonic balancer" needs replacement to fix the problem and you want to know their opinion, I doubt they would charge you for confirming what you already know.
#13
Intermediate
Member Since: Jul 2010
Location: Summerville SC
Posts: 46
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Wobbling Harmonic "Crankshaft" Balancer '06 C6 32k
I found similar posts from Cadillac CTS and Pontiac G8 owners who have had the rubber separate from the balancer as well, so we are not alone with our problems. It is quite obvious that you are dead-on with your statement of "under-engineering". I call it "the design, manufacture and sale of a faulty product or component" something along the lines most lawyers would call, clears grounds for a product liability action if personal injuries were occurring !
What I don't get, are the posts that state some dealership responses have been "the wobble is normal". Well, if the wobble is normal, what are the measured tolerances of what is "normal wobble" and what is "failure wobble". And also, why aren't those measurements referenced in the Factory Service Manuals. And why isn't the wobble mentioned at all in any of the Factory Service Manuals ? One would think that if it was normal it would be mentioned in the engine diagnostics section and it would be given some reference data as to acceptable vs. unacceptable.
#14
Intermediate
One thing to point out as well is this can be caused from a faulty water pump. Once a bearing goes in the pump and it begins leaking through the weep hole (GM's are notorious for this), the corrosive dexcool drips directly onto the belt and harmonic balancer which begins wearing on the balancer in that rubber flex coupler which will cause the demise of the harmonic balancer. Leaking coolant will also cause wearing of the belt and cause a squeak/squeel.
This problem can present itself on any LS engine based vehicle due to the above cause.
This problem can present itself on any LS engine based vehicle due to the above cause.
#15
Le Mans Master
And also, why aren't those measurements referenced in the Factory Service Manuals. And why isn't the wobble mentioned at all in any of the Factory Service Manuals ? One would think that if it was normal it would be mentioned in the engine diagnostics section and it would be given some reference data as to acceptable vs. unacceptable.
#16
Go Canes!
go and get an underdrive pulley and pick up a few horses at the same time.
that's what i did.
that's what i did.
#17
Race Director
Member Since: Jun 2005
Location: Phila Suburbs 2023 C8 & 2013 650ix
Posts: 10,444
Received 2,241 Likes
on
1,149 Posts
HDDP,
Thanks for the kind words. I leaned about the crank pulley problem first hand because I had one of the first failures on my 05 after 19,000 miles. It took the dealer 6 weeks of trial and error before they replaced the pulley and fixed the problem. What I learned was that there is no acceptable tolerance for pulley wobble. I suspect that because the engine has to be running with the tension of the two belts on the pulley for it to wobble that there is no way to actually measure the wobble. A lot of pulleys wobble and will not be replaced simply because they are not running true. It's only when they cause the belt to chirp that the dealer will replace the pulley because that is the only way to eliminate the chirp.
Thanks for the kind words. I leaned about the crank pulley problem first hand because I had one of the first failures on my 05 after 19,000 miles. It took the dealer 6 weeks of trial and error before they replaced the pulley and fixed the problem. What I learned was that there is no acceptable tolerance for pulley wobble. I suspect that because the engine has to be running with the tension of the two belts on the pulley for it to wobble that there is no way to actually measure the wobble. A lot of pulleys wobble and will not be replaced simply because they are not running true. It's only when they cause the belt to chirp that the dealer will replace the pulley because that is the only way to eliminate the chirp.
#18
Instructor
same problem here, but I went to the dealer 4 mths before waranty expired! fixed for free....well, the second time, becuase the first time they just changed the belts, etc to see if that helps, but after not even 3 weeks, the noise came back, so they fixed it for good for the second time...
I agree with you, it should havbe been a recall, but u know think about reputation, etc
I agree with you, it should havbe been a recall, but u know think about reputation, etc
#19
Racer
I feel your pain. It was a long & hard fight for me to get my HB replaced, but I finally did and it runs perfectly now.
Here's what it sounded like at idle:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4HmMAyPdyDs
Here's what it looked like:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vRboo9a0RnY
Here's what it sounded like at idle:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4HmMAyPdyDs
Here's what it looked like:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vRboo9a0RnY
#20
don't think is only your 05, had the same issue with my 07, dealer replaced under 100K warranty. My frined with a 08 has the same issue, other friend with a G8 also same issue. If no warranty, take it to a good mechanic for arround 500$ you should get an aftermarket pulley and labor.