High lift camshafts link bar lifter failure
#21
Team Owner
Member Since: Sep 2003
Location: Raleigh / Rolesville NC
Posts: 43,084
Likes: 0
Received 28 Likes
on
27 Posts
Comp Cams ground LPE GT-19 camshaft. 227/239 .678/.688 114 LSA.
snip
Possible reasons for the carnage...
1) too high of lift used in road race conditions
snip
Possible reasons for the carnage...
1) too high of lift used in road race conditions
something in this line
258 / 258 @ .050, .578 / .578 lift, 110 LSA
3000 to redline several times a min for 20 to 30 min at a time, beats the living crap out of a valve train.
Last edited by AU N EGL; 07-13-2011 at 07:29 PM.
#22
My stock LS7 failed two lifters, I noticed new ticking noises and tore into it. This was a mfg Jun/06 car, 80,000 street miles, ~1,000 track miles.
.02
Shown below: #3 exhaust (roller bearing felt irregular), #7 exhaust (fretting), #5 exhaust (normal)
Cam surface looks similar; I did measure full lift though.
.02
Shown below: #3 exhaust (roller bearing felt irregular), #7 exhaust (fretting), #5 exhaust (normal)
Cam surface looks similar; I did measure full lift though.
#23
Le Mans Master
My stock LS7 failed two lifters, I noticed new ticking noises and tore into it. This was a mfg Jun/06 car, 80,000 street miles, ~1,000 track miles.
.02
Shown below: #3 exhaust (roller bearing felt irregular), #7 exhaust (fretting), #5 exhaust (normal)
Cam surface looks similar; I did measure full lift though
.02
Shown below: #3 exhaust (roller bearing felt irregular), #7 exhaust (fretting), #5 exhaust (normal)
Cam surface looks similar; I did measure full lift though
Last edited by DSOMC6; 08-14-2011 at 01:25 PM.
#24
DSOM- how "old" was your 2006 when your lifters failed? Track usage?
#25
Le Mans Master
It was only one lifter that actually failed.
The car had about 58,xxx miles at failure.
Twin turbos and cam added at aprox 20,000 miles.
Never tracked, mostly frwy miles.
New lifters, lifter trays, heads machined with new manly dual valve springs, new valve seals, new higher lift cam, APR head bolts, New Katech C5R timing chain, New Powerbond UD pulley pinned to crank.
It runs pretty strong now.
Last edited by DSOMC6; 08-16-2011 at 04:06 AM.
#26
Melting Slicks
Thread Starter
Yeh my cam lobe was trashed as well.
It was only one lifter that actually failed.
The car had about 58,xxx miles at failure.
Twin turbos and cam added at aprox 20,000 miles.
Never tracked, mostly frwy miles.
New lifters, lifter trays, heads machined with new manly dual valve springs, new valve seals, new higher lift cam, APR head bolts, New Katech C5R timing chain, New Powerbond UD pulley pinned to crank.
It runs pretty strong now.
It was only one lifter that actually failed.
The car had about 58,xxx miles at failure.
Twin turbos and cam added at aprox 20,000 miles.
Never tracked, mostly frwy miles.
New lifters, lifter trays, heads machined with new manly dual valve springs, new valve seals, new higher lift cam, APR head bolts, New Katech C5R timing chain, New Powerbond UD pulley pinned to crank.
It runs pretty strong now.
It was amazing the power my car picked up getting the lift in my cam back.
I'm running an under .640" lift cam now, more duration and I still hit the same top speed down the back straight of my favorite road coarse.
My power band is wider too.
Last edited by bowtiguy; 12-31-2011 at 10:38 AM. Reason: spealing
#27
Drifting
I don't know what oil you have been using but you may want to switch to an oil that has a higher zinc/phosphorus content such as Royal Purple's HPS or XPR oils or Redline's Race Oils.... I had the same type thing happen to my stock LS7 that I've never tracked or run past 6000 RPM. Vette had 23 - 24 thousand miles when found......
Mark
Mark
#28
Le Mans Master
I don't know what oil you have been using but you may want to switch to an oil that has a higher zinc/phosphorus content such as Royal Purple's HPS or XPR oils or Redline's Race Oils.... I had the same type thing happen to my stock LS7 that I've never tracked or run past 6000 RPM. Vette had 23 - 24 thousand miles when found......[:
I've debated this.
Anywhere to purchase any of those oils at a discount?
I have an F/I set-up and change my oil and plugs about every 3-4k miles.
#30
Former Vendor
Mike, the pic you posted is due to hardness. Ive seen it happen in the past, maybe 3x in the last 10/12 years on LS engines. Each time, the cam was sent for harndness, and of those 3, 2 were not up to spec and one was too gone to determine the root cause.
The added zinc in the oil will help, lots of flat tappen/solid roller diesel guys must use oil with a lot of zinc when they do cam swaps in order to get them to seat properly.
Lets clear up one thing, lift doesnt mean much interms of cam/engine reliability, considering we are no more than 10% lift than stock.
What matters here, is the lobe profiles. Im not sure how the LPE profiles are, but for consistently high RPM engines, the duration at .200 tappet lift tell more about a cams radical, or not so radical behavior. This is where quite a bit of the work is done, leading up to the nose of the cam where it pushes the lifter up, and compresses the spring, opening the valve against cylinder pressures.
I would certainly attribute this to an isolated hardness issue, and some oil analysis, magnetic drain plugs, or a scavenge filter in your return line to the tank would have told you something was up, if your hearing wasnt up to par
Hope all is well!
Louis
The added zinc in the oil will help, lots of flat tappen/solid roller diesel guys must use oil with a lot of zinc when they do cam swaps in order to get them to seat properly.
Lets clear up one thing, lift doesnt mean much interms of cam/engine reliability, considering we are no more than 10% lift than stock.
What matters here, is the lobe profiles. Im not sure how the LPE profiles are, but for consistently high RPM engines, the duration at .200 tappet lift tell more about a cams radical, or not so radical behavior. This is where quite a bit of the work is done, leading up to the nose of the cam where it pushes the lifter up, and compresses the spring, opening the valve against cylinder pressures.
I would certainly attribute this to an isolated hardness issue, and some oil analysis, magnetic drain plugs, or a scavenge filter in your return line to the tank would have told you something was up, if your hearing wasnt up to par
Hope all is well!
Louis
Last edited by Louis @ LG Motorsports; 08-18-2011 at 01:11 PM.