When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.
Since I have only had experience with MGW on my 08, I don't know how it compares to anything but stock. The MGW is a big improvement over stock.
I can tell you it's an improvement over every shifter I've had in either my C5Z or C6Z! This includes the Hurst, Kirban, and the 427x. I don't have the lower box in either, but I'm sure knowing George at MGW, it's a big improvement over stock. The poly bushings in the MGW box alone should provide a much smoother surface for the box!
I just installed the shifter top. It is great. The car is new to me so i didn't know the previous owner had put a B&M shifter in it. This is much better. Very precise. I work for a defense contractor and when we make a mechanical assembly it costs alot, but is built very very well. The MGW looks Full-Mil. It has an extra block of metal just for vibration damping (I think) and the 4 bolts that hold it down have extra allen locking bolts. You don't see that on most standard products; but I can only compare to the B&M.
I opted for the threaded shaft that is standard on the C5 and mounted a solid hurst ball. It is short and tight. I thought the OEM C6 ****, while very ergonomic, had a cheap tin top and they whole **** felt mushy. (I did spend $15 for the C6 shaft in case I ever want to go back). Best of luck to you.
had mine for 3 years...installed at 40k miles by Penske INDY
I think it is TOO stiff - although it has loosened up a bit over past year(or maybe I'm thoroughly used to it)
1st thru 4th is nice'n quick...
pattern from 4th to 5th is DEFINITELY a dogleg jog up and over to the right; sixth gear has to be precise also(down right).
I tend to skip gears alot on FL A1A, in interest of economy(!)
3rd to 5th is real EZ; 4th to 6th not so good(could be tranny arms!).
furthermore, HEAT seems to aggravate stiffness/precision(after driving 15-20+ hours non-stop on I-10 FLA-TX&beyond, multiple times)