Jacking Puck vs Hockey Puck
Or could be made with a hole saw and some spare lumber for free?
Jacking pucks are cheap insurance, in my book.
Its not something to worry about.
I prefer to use the machined aluminum ones, and not the ones that stay on the car all the time...
Our club had a local machine shop make us some for less than you can buy them...
The Best of Corvette for Corvette Enthusiasts
No different than people telling me I'm an idiot for buying the tinted Showstopper LED side markers instead of slapping some tint on the factory ones. We all choose what we like and that's why there's a market for various items that all technically do the same thing.




Bill




Last edited by Pizz; Dec 26, 2017 at 09:08 PM. Reason: Clarify
Bill
I've been using hockey pucks as a lifting aid for a good 15 years -- never an issue.Hockey pucks don't slip under load. If you're putting enough lateral force on the car that you're worried about a hockey puck slipping, you're doing it wrong, and would be in danger of pushing the car off the jack regardless of whether you are using a hockey puck or a $50 specialized puck.
I had 3 inch diameter alumiminum jack pads for my C6 but found the GM Owner's Manual was right- needed 2 1/2 inch diameter for my C7. There were two frame slots that the 3 inch pad that were hitting the plastic rocker panel. With a smaller diameter eye hook in a hockey puck it probably can be pushed further from the panel versus and aluminum puck that is centered in the slot.Also it is dependent on the length of the hydraulic jack arm as to how far the jack has to "move into" the car to keep it centered on the jack saddle as the car is raised. A short jack arm lifted near max-quite a bit (see pic.)
I bought a long reach jack from Harbor Freight so it would not have to move in as far. But it weighs 95 pounds! To get a low lift position it had a very shallow saddle! That heavy jack was not moving in at all! Solved that by welding a metal rim around the jack saddle (see pic.)
Bottom Line:
Whatever you are using be sure the Jack Pad/Hockey Puck is staying on the frame and jack saddle as you lift!
For equal lift height (max shown for short jack arm) a longer jack arm has to move in less to keep the jack saddle centered on the jack pad. Thinking I would solve the potential slipping problem (ask how I know about slipping!) I bought a long arm jack, it did not! The heavy jack was not moving in well even on my titled garage floor and would be difficult to have it move on my concrete driveway! Solved that by welding a rim on the shallow jack saddle making it deeper to hold my jack pad. Pic insert on left is after welding a rim to the jack saddle with a I inch high jack puck in place. Still plenty of room to fit under my side skirts and 1 inch high jack pad when installed on the frame.
Last edited by JerryU; Dec 29, 2017 at 07:44 AM.
Understand but my math is a bit different:
Saving ~$40 Not Worth one time slipping!
i.e. $50 (for quality jack pads) < $10 (and damaged $65,000 Vette!)

TO EACH THERE OWN!
PS
Eye bolts will help prevent slipping. Better than the short sections of 2X4 a trained C7 tech was ready to use recently on my Vette when I pulled out the bag with my 4 jack pads! He thanked me. The wood was OK for his center post lift with 4 arms as it raises straight up. OK IF he placed the wood properly under frame without hitting a plastic panel but not so good when using a hydraulic jack that must move into the car to keep the saddle and wood or hockey puck under the slot in the frame. Mechanics that work on few Vettes can't be expected to buy jack pads! IF the dealer had them, he would have to go to the parts department and check them out, assuming the fellow working the parts/tool crib could fine them!
Mechanics mostly buy their own tools. The prices from Snap-On, who bring a truck and visit the mechanics every couple of weeks, are very high! But as many jobs where folks live from paycheck to paycheck, Snap-On gives them credit. They have the dealer take $xx/week from their paycheck (depending on the agreed to credit plan with the mechanic!)
Last edited by JerryU; Dec 30, 2017 at 12:49 PM.
















