When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.
Norval.
You HAVE to understand this...
There is a world of difference between street driving and track driving. Rotors get very hot on the track and then cool then very hot again. Pedal pressures are very high.
On a track you are WOT or full brake. very hard on the pads and rotors.
I think you are confusing the issue.
I'm not confusing the issue. We drive STREET cars. 99% of us spend all our time on the street. For those that do OCCASIONAL drive on a track still 99% of mileage is racked up on the street.
I came home last night across country , about 65 miles running hard with a very fast VBP suspenioned front and back 383 running in the 100 mph range even in some of the corners. Alot of stops signs running those back roads, on the brakes hard and then slipping through the stop signs and off again. My brakes are doing what they are supose to, stopping me hard from a high rate of speed. That is what they are supose to do. I don't drive 4 hours to a track, get a few laps and then go home. Why do I want to invest in special brakes if my homemade set work great?? NO warping, no cracking and no complaints.
We all like to think we drive race cars in our minds but they are nothing but street cars occassionaly some see the track.
Last edited by norvalwilhelm; Jul 21, 2005 at 08:02 AM.
I'm not confusing the issue. We drive STREET cars. 99% of us spend all our time on the street. For those that do OCCASIONAL drive on a track still 99% of mileage is racked up on the street.
We all like to think we drive race cars in our minds but they are nothing but street cars occassionaly some see the track.
and what if you do some spirited driving and your rotor cracks? Not racing is certainly not a guarantee that a drilled rotor won't crack, there was a topic about it some time ago with no shortage of pictures of cracked rotors, do you really think none of those are street cars? I'm willing to bet that a good percentage of them never saw the track.
and what if you do some spirited driving and your rotor cracks? Not racing is certainly not a guarantee that a drilled rotor won't crack, there was a topic about it some time ago with no shortage of pictures of cracked rotors, do you really think none of those are street cars? I'm willing to bet that a good percentage of them never saw the track.
Well as far as I know, these are the 1st american made drilled rotors for C3's. Others have been offshore brands and they are not cryoed. Sorry I missed that thread. I would be willing to bet that a good percentage of those rotors were offshore though. I believe Power Slots makes a drilled and slotted rotor but they are offshore and not cryoed either. I had them on one of my other cars and they did crack but I didn't know they were not treated before hand or else I would have done them myself.
and what if you do some spirited driving and your rotor cracks? Not racing is certainly not a guarantee that a drilled rotor won't crack, there was a topic about it some time ago with no shortage of pictures of cracked rotors, do you really think none of those are street cars? I'm willing to bet that a good percentage of them never saw the track.
Marck they are only rotors. They won't break you if you need to replace them. I could just as easily blow the motor, transmission or rearend. We are talking about nickles and dimes here. Not bankrupcy.
I like to drive spirited too and have made 3 panic stops in a row from 100 mph just for testing. I was really driving spirited last night and put about 160 miles on the car over the last 2 nights.
They are only rotors, if they fail replace them. My front 14 inch rotors are about the most expensive on this forum at over $700 plus hours of machining and drilling. If they crack I will just replace them.
I also 4 for rotors with about 960 holes in total that have not cracked. I did use performance friction metalic pads on them for a while until I watched them getting chewed up so I went back to organic.
Again they are really only a throw away item anyway.
Those rotors are well over 200$ a pop here, maybe as high as 300$ since they're heavy. Not really nickles and dimes. However when it comes to cracking, it's not the rotor being junk that worries me but what if you don't spot the crack and the whole thing comes flying apart.
Got any pics? These might be just what I am looking for since the only other ones I have seen look like they were gold cad plated. I sure wish someone wold make a larger setup that wouldn't get lost in larger wheels. I wonder if chevrolet might have done any testing on the C-6 with the drilled rotors. Yea they probably all cracked but they said let's just run em anyway. Right.
Got any pics? These might be just what I am looking for since the only other ones I have seen look like they were gold cad plated. I sure wish someone wold make a larger setup that wouldn't get lost in larger wheels. I wonder if chevrolet might have done any testing on the C-6 with the drilled rotors. Yea they probably all cracked but they said let's just run em anyway. Right.
No pics but these are also gold cad plated. I've seen other gold cad plated ones but they were dimpled not drilled.
All C6's w/the Z51 package come w/drilled rotors. I was just at the plant 3 weeks ago and saw them.
and what if you do some spirited driving and your rotor cracks? Not racing is certainly not a guarantee that a drilled rotor won't crack, there was a topic about it some time ago with no shortage of pictures of cracked rotors, do you really think none of those are street cars? I'm willing to bet that a good percentage of them never saw the track.
Norval is better than any of us at keeping a well maintained car. He is not going to cause a rotor to explode in one session. I am confident that if some cracking developed he would be right on top of it.
I don't think anybody here abuses their car enough to crack a drilled rotor so we are worring about something that will never happen for 99.9 % of us.
gkull, myself, clutchdust and maybe a few others are the only ones who put their car on a roadcourse for 20 minute sessions and drive the car to the limit without cooling ducts. You can't possibly abuse your car to that extent on the street. Autocross doesn't even come close to heating up the brakes, only high speed events.
I posted this already under metalic pads but it applies here as well
I always feel driving is about smoothness. You try to maintain as much smoothness as possible. I don't go into corners if I can help it and then jam on the brakes. I try to straighten the corner out and at the same time maintain as much speed as possible. This is good smooth driving with less wear and tear on the engine and brakes.
I also don't come up to stop signs and hit the brakes really hard. Sure I am moving and usually take the stop at a 2nd gear roll but agian I am trying for smoothness.
While turning the rotors in the lathe I found the 32 curved vanes really pumped the air. The air comming off them was like a strong fan. They really do pump air from the center out.
As for maintaining the car I seem to go over it almost weekly to try and spot a problem and that includes a visual brake rotor inspection.
With all my holes in the old stock rotors I would have zero life expectance out of pads if that was true.
I never have a problem with premature pad wear. Never.
Cheese-grater effect is only present with certain brake pad compounds, and if you track your car. You are running organics on the street, so the cross-drilled rotors are okay. I wanted to run a pad with the newer, more aggressive compound. (Axxis Ultimate). http://www.stoptech.com/axxis_pads/ These pads run and wear best with a standard or slotted rotor surface.
Taken from StopTech's FAQ:
Which is better, slotted or drilled rotors?
StopTech provides rotors slotted, drilled or plain. For most performance applications slotted is the preferred choice. Slotting helps wipe away debris from between the pad and rotor as well as increasing the "bite" characteristics of the pad. A drilled rotor provides the same type of benefit, but is more susceptible to cracking under severe usage. Many customers prefer the look of a drilled rotor and for street and occasional light duty track use they will work fine. For more severe applications, we recommend slotted rotors.
I'm happy with my setup, you're happy with yours.
BTW: I agree with your smoothness comment. Smoothness = speed.
"IMPORTANT REMINDER: Slotted, drilled or dimpled rotors offered as OEM replacements should not be considered appropriate for high-speed track use.
While grooved, drilled and slotted rotors offer an enhanced appearance and add some resistance to the boundary layer of gasses that can build up between the pad and rotor, they are not designed to withstand the extreme temperatures that are produced on the racetrack. If they are used on the track, it is very important that the rotors be carefully inspected and should not be driven on if even minor signs of deterioration are seen. Note, too, that if these products are used on the track they are not warrantable."
I don't think anybody here abuses their car enough to crack a drilled rotor so we are worring about something that will never happen for 99.9 % of us.
gkull, myself, clutchdust and maybe a few others are the only ones who put their car on a roadcourse for 20 minute sessions and drive the car to the limit without cooling ducts. You can't possibly abuse your car to that extent on the street. Autocross doesn't even come close to heating up the brakes, only high speed events.
I run at Brainard raceway. It's a 3.5 mile high speed course with some dang shapr corners. Lot's of braking, lots of cranking on the steering wheel left AND right
My stock brakes completely lost it my last time up there on them the pads were worn into a football shape, thin on the ends, thick in the middle. They were also boiling the fluid. I've been on the Wilwood wagon since ( now if I can just iron out a few issues with other things I can go thrash the car again up there