When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.
I replaced my thermostat with a 160 degree one in my 1970 350/300hp A/C, automatic car and I found out later a 195 was original, will anything happen other that the thermostat opening at 160 versus 195? It never went above 160 anyway and it had a 180 in it.
Last edited by JIMS1970VETTE; May 3, 2009 at 10:53 AM.
Yes, too cold is no good for a number of reasons. One being you need it warm enough to gas off the moisture that builds up otherwise corrosion can set in over time.
That car came with a 180F stat...not a 195F. Cars weren't forced to go to higher 195F temps until later EPA demands. The higher temp stats caused engines to run hotter and to burn some more hydrocarbons at idle and low speeds. I agree that your 180F stat was defective [stuck open] or your temp gauge reads low. Putting a 160F stat in your car won't hurt it; it will stabilize at whatever temp your engine/cooling system requires (which is usually hotter than 160F). It will just take a bit longer to get there. The thermostat doesn't 'set' the temperature of the system...it merely establishes the minimum temp possible; if your system needs to run hotter, it will.
Thanks for the reply and I always thought that the high temp thermostats were for newer cars with the smog equipment. Mine being a "base" motor I didn't think it would hurt. When I buy a new one I will get the 180 degree thermostat. Thanks!
I run a 160 degree stat in my built 327 and when moving, the car runs a consistant ~165 (on the gauge). The engine makes good power and I've never had a problem with condensation.
If I'm sitting at idle for an extended period (e.g., in line at a show with limited ambient air flow), it will climb and can go over 200. Sit long enough, and it may puke (at least it used to). The radiator is good and all seals are in place.
One advantage of a lower operating temperature is that the engine is just that much cooler when you are forced to idle for an extended period, so you have a little longer before you start getting worried. :o
The cooling system should keep the engine running at or near the same temperature regardless of load or car speed. My L36 runs around 185 in traffic, on the freeway, or pretty-much whenever. It is basically stock: 160* stat, flow-kooler pump, thermo clutch, ac fan and re-cored 41 year old Harrison radiator. And I live in sunny CA. If my car heated up in traffic, or on the freeway, I would sort it out. Just my 2 cents...
That car came with a 180F stat...not a 195F. Cars weren't forced to go to higher 195F temps until later EPA demands. The higher temp stats caused engines to run hotter and to burn some more hydrocarbons at idle and low speeds. I agree that your 180F stat was defective [stuck open] or your temp gauge reads low. Putting a 160F stat in your car won't hurt it; it will stabilize at whatever temp your engine/cooling system requires (which is usually hotter than 160F). It will just take a bit longer to get there. The thermostat doesn't 'set' the temperature of the system...it merely establishes the minimum temp possible; if your system needs to run hotter, it will.
if your not concerned about using the heater, and you live in a hot climate I would keep the 160, the stat only sets the min. temp for the system to run at,
the other componets control or limit how hot it will actually run.
! run a 160 for my 454 but I am in Texas.
If your heating up in traffic, you need to check out the radiator or pump/fan.
Good point on outside temps as it will get above 100 degrees here in Reno, and in traffic at Hot August Nights it can drive up the temp while you are cruising, thanks to everyone and for this forum, it really helps!
Durability tests done in industry have shown that colder engine temperatures INCREASE wear. The wear curve DECREASES as the operating temperature goes up and reaches a minimum at 180 degrees and remains flat to 230 or more, although the wear at upper temperature is probably a function of the high temperature capability of the motor oil (synthetics are better here).
BTW, a colder thermostat will NOT increase the cooling capacity of the system since all thermostats (160, 180, and 195) will be full open above 200 degrees - they only change the minimum operating temperature.
Durability tests done in industry have shown that colder engine temperatures INCREASE wear. The wear curve DECREASES as the operating temperature goes up and reaches a minimum at 180 degrees and remains flat to 230 or more, although the wear at upper temperature is probably a function of the high temperature capability of the motor oil (synthetics are better here).
When were these tests performed..., back when these old engines were new?
Back then people ran straight 30 weight. 10-40, 5-30, synthetics, etc. were unheard of. Sure, a low temp could have wear consequences if the oil is too thick. But I run 10-40 synthetic and not 30 weight like I did 30 years ago.
BTW, a colder thermostat will NOT increase the cooling capacity of the system since all thermostats (160, 180, and 195) will be full open above 200 degrees - they only change the minimum operating temperature.
I have never seen a more misunderstood concept thrown around over and over as I have regarding this on this forum.
Your coolant temp directly impacts your oil temp. Since water vaporizes at 212~, your oil needs to run at 212 or higher or liquid water (and other combustion wastes) will foul the oil causing a myriad of problems. A 160 stat won't get the oil temp to 212 unless your cooling system is maxed and runs hotter than the stat's rating.
That's the main reason hot oil is a much better lubricator than cool oil and that's the main reason engines will live longer with a higher operating temp.
Secondly, it's no secret hot oil flows better than cold.
My oil temp gauges on my newer Vettes (I wish all my cars had oil temp gauges) run about 20* hotter than the coolant temp. My 96 LT-4 has a 195* factory stat and the oil temp stays at a pretty contant 215* which is perfect. The engineers at GM know what they're doing.
On an all-iron engine, 180* is probably fine assuming you don't have an 8 qt pan.
I bought a 180 degree stat, just have to install it and that was a very informative article on oil temp and water temp, everyone should read it, Thanks 73 Dark Blue 454!!!