Can I safely cut this small section of birdcage for a speaker?
#1
Racer
Thread Starter
Can I safely cut this small section of birdcage for a speaker?
So I'm trying to install a new sound system on my car. Got my tweeters mounted nicely under the dash. The woofer, though, is hitting the cage right where my finger is in the first pic. Wondering if I can grind away a tiny bit of the steel without compronising the structure? Maybe about as much as shown drawn in red on picture #2.
Last edited by Shdggsdv; 11-05-2017 at 02:45 PM.
#2
Team Owner
Member Since: Sep 2006
Location: Westminster Maryland
Posts: 30,173
Likes: 0
Received 2,878 Likes
on
2,515 Posts
Hi S,
If you're really only going to cut that much I'd say you're fine considering how solid the cage appears to be!
Regards,
Alan
If you're really only going to cut that much I'd say you're fine considering how solid the cage appears to be!
Regards,
Alan
Last edited by Alan 71; 11-05-2017 at 02:52 PM.
#4
Racer
Thread Starter
#5
Le Mans Master
Member Since: May 2003
Location: Fernandina Beach FL
Posts: 8,481
Received 3,220 Likes
on
1,732 Posts
2023 Restomod of the Year finalist
2020 C3 of the Year Winner - Modified
Rather than cut- why don't you turn it in/reshape it with a hammer.
Richard
Richard
#8
Race Director
Really?
You want to cut the birdcage to fit a speaker?
Really?
How about find a different speaker?
You want to cut the birdcage to fit a speaker?
Really?
How about find a different speaker?
#10
Pro
I would do what I've done on two C3s with great sounding systems: put aftermarket 4x6s in the dash.
The woofers in the kick panel will be directing sound at your feet and will be muffled and not give a good sense of sound placement. They also won't provide decent bass because of the open compartment they'll be in.
Mounting a pair of 2-way 4x6s in the dash will get you the nice highs of the tweeter, and give you good frequency response down to just below 150Hz or so. On the 78-82 cars, the dash acts a bit like a sealed compartment. On my 79, the bass response from the 4x6s improves significantly as soon as the speaker is put in place.
For a pre-78 car, you might have to use plate speakers in case the tweeter sticks up too high on a standard 4x6 and hits the mounting bracket. I used plate speakers on a 75 I'm restoring (I had to remove the curved piece of metal joining the speedometer and tachometer due to interference) and they sound great. Some foam around the edge of the speaker mount might help create more of a sealed compartment and improve bass response.
To get good bass response, you're going to need to install some kind of speakers to be used as a sub in the rear. In my 79, I have a box with two 6x9s, and a 10 inch sub I bought off of eBay. It sounds fantastic and has frequency response down to 40Hz or so. In the 75, space was a concern, so I used two 6x9 mounts that the vendors sell. These aren't sealed enclosures, so bass frequency response drops off below 70Hz or so. In both cases, I have the rear speakers low passed so that the mids and highs only come from the front speakers (bass sound is non-directional). The front speakers can be driven directly off of the head unit, but the rear speakers/sub that handle the bass will need an external amp.
The woofers in the kick panel will be directing sound at your feet and will be muffled and not give a good sense of sound placement. They also won't provide decent bass because of the open compartment they'll be in.
Mounting a pair of 2-way 4x6s in the dash will get you the nice highs of the tweeter, and give you good frequency response down to just below 150Hz or so. On the 78-82 cars, the dash acts a bit like a sealed compartment. On my 79, the bass response from the 4x6s improves significantly as soon as the speaker is put in place.
For a pre-78 car, you might have to use plate speakers in case the tweeter sticks up too high on a standard 4x6 and hits the mounting bracket. I used plate speakers on a 75 I'm restoring (I had to remove the curved piece of metal joining the speedometer and tachometer due to interference) and they sound great. Some foam around the edge of the speaker mount might help create more of a sealed compartment and improve bass response.
To get good bass response, you're going to need to install some kind of speakers to be used as a sub in the rear. In my 79, I have a box with two 6x9s, and a 10 inch sub I bought off of eBay. It sounds fantastic and has frequency response down to 40Hz or so. In the 75, space was a concern, so I used two 6x9 mounts that the vendors sell. These aren't sealed enclosures, so bass frequency response drops off below 70Hz or so. In both cases, I have the rear speakers low passed so that the mids and highs only come from the front speakers (bass sound is non-directional). The front speakers can be driven directly off of the head unit, but the rear speakers/sub that handle the bass will need an external amp.
#11
Race Director
I'm not fond of cutting structural parts of the car - even though it probably will be fine if cut.
I would just make a wood or composite board spacer - paint it and enjoy the sound system. With a little careful shaping of the insert you can tilt the speakers toward the seat for better sound.
I would just make a wood or composite board spacer - paint it and enjoy the sound system. With a little careful shaping of the insert you can tilt the speakers toward the seat for better sound.
The following users liked this post:
Shdggsdv (11-09-2017)
#12
Racer
Thread Starter
I would do what I've done on two C3s with great sounding systems: put aftermarket 4x6s in the dash.
The woofers in the kick panel will be directing sound at your feet and will be muffled and not give a good sense of sound placement. They also won't provide decent bass because of the open compartment they'll be in.
Mounting a pair of 2-way 4x6s in the dash will get you the nice highs of the tweeter, and give you good frequency response down to just below 150Hz or so. On the 78-82 cars, the dash acts a bit like a sealed compartment. On my 79, the bass response from the 4x6s improves significantly as soon as the speaker is put in place.
For a pre-78 car, you might have to use plate speakers in case the tweeter sticks up too high on a standard 4x6 and hits the mounting bracket. I used plate speakers on a 75 I'm restoring (I had to remove the curved piece of metal joining the speedometer and tachometer due to interference) and they sound great. Some foam around the edge of the speaker mount might help create more of a sealed compartment and improve bass response.
To get good bass response, you're going to need to install some kind of speakers to be used as a sub in the rear. In my 79, I have a box with two 6x9s, and a 10 inch sub I bought off of eBay. It sounds fantastic and has frequency response down to 40Hz or so. In the 75, space was a concern, so I used two 6x9 mounts that the vendors sell. These aren't sealed enclosures, so bass frequency response drops off below 70Hz or so. In both cases, I have the rear speakers low passed so that the mids and highs only come from the front speakers (bass sound is non-directional). The front speakers can be driven directly off of the head unit, but the rear speakers/sub that handle the bass will need an external amp.
The woofers in the kick panel will be directing sound at your feet and will be muffled and not give a good sense of sound placement. They also won't provide decent bass because of the open compartment they'll be in.
Mounting a pair of 2-way 4x6s in the dash will get you the nice highs of the tweeter, and give you good frequency response down to just below 150Hz or so. On the 78-82 cars, the dash acts a bit like a sealed compartment. On my 79, the bass response from the 4x6s improves significantly as soon as the speaker is put in place.
For a pre-78 car, you might have to use plate speakers in case the tweeter sticks up too high on a standard 4x6 and hits the mounting bracket. I used plate speakers on a 75 I'm restoring (I had to remove the curved piece of metal joining the speedometer and tachometer due to interference) and they sound great. Some foam around the edge of the speaker mount might help create more of a sealed compartment and improve bass response.
To get good bass response, you're going to need to install some kind of speakers to be used as a sub in the rear. In my 79, I have a box with two 6x9s, and a 10 inch sub I bought off of eBay. It sounds fantastic and has frequency response down to 40Hz or so. In the 75, space was a concern, so I used two 6x9 mounts that the vendors sell. These aren't sealed enclosures, so bass frequency response drops off below 70Hz or so. In both cases, I have the rear speakers low passed so that the mids and highs only come from the front speakers (bass sound is non-directional). The front speakers can be driven directly off of the head unit, but the rear speakers/sub that handle the bass will need an external amp.
I will also be installing a MiniDSP to get good timing and EQ control as well as a vacuum tube pre-amp I bought off a guy that builds them over on a car audio forum.
Overall - this build sounds deceivingly amazing and will only get better once I tune with a DSP and use the pre-amp. The only thing that sucks imo is my woofer. The 5.5" woofers are a little small for my taste (Some frequency spikes and brightness in the midbass, but nothing too bad). I'd love to get custom kickpanels made for a Stereo Integrity 6.5" woofer set to get crazy clean SQ over all the mid and low frequencies. Cool thing though is that with just a tiny, tiny bit of fiberglass in the channel of the birdcage, it makes a very good enclosure for small woofers. I may even eventually add in a small 3" driver of some sort in the dash to turn it into a 3-way system later down the road if I do end up craving more soundstage, but who knows
My issue with 4x6s come in multiple zones. No matter how high end you get, you will always be muddying the mids and highs with the nature of a compact passive speaker. I've never been a personal fan of the brightness that seems to exists with what seems to be every non-active tweeter's sound as well (Nothing wrong with brightness, just not my preference)
Last edited by Shdggsdv; 11-09-2017 at 02:27 PM.
#13
Had a 1976 L-82, 4-sp
Member Since: Mar 2011
Location: Some days your the dog and some days your the hydrant.
Posts: 5,338
Received 1,199 Likes
on
925 Posts
Royal Canadian Navy
I have shallow mount Infinity 6-1/2" round behind my kick panels gor a nice stock look. I don't have any dash speakers because the sound from the kick panels isn't felt at the floor so to speak. You are right using a component system with tweeters only in the dash because thats all the dash area is good. for imo. I did need to trim the speaker frame a small bit for fit but as others have said, buy different woofers before cutting the structure of the cage.
#14
Racer
Thread Starter
I'm not fond of cutting structural parts of the car - even though it probably will be fine if cut.
I would just make a wood or composite board spacer - paint it and enjoy the sound system. With a little careful shaping of the insert you can tilt the speakers toward the seat for better sound.
I would just make a wood or composite board spacer - paint it and enjoy the sound system. With a little careful shaping of the insert you can tilt the speakers toward the seat for better sound.
#15
Racer
Thread Starter
I have shallow mount Infinity 6-1/2" round behind my kick panels gor a nice stock look. I don't have any dash speakers because the sound from the kick panels isn't felt at the floor so to speak. You are right using a component system with tweeters only in the dash because thats all the dash area is good. for imo. I did need to trim the speaker frame a small bit for fit but as others have said, buy different woofers before cutting the structure of the cage.
Last edited by Shdggsdv; 11-09-2017 at 02:18 PM.
#16
Had a 1976 L-82, 4-sp
Member Since: Mar 2011
Location: Some days your the dog and some days your the hydrant.
Posts: 5,338
Received 1,199 Likes
on
925 Posts
Royal Canadian Navy
Yes because it was a two-way shallow mount type Infinity had at the time. I have a set of Focal 6-1/2" but are deeper which will require a 1/2" spacer. Buy them on Amazon for $10/pair or less. But the Focals may need to be mounted on the outside of the kick panel. A few guys are using Polk speakers this way. Spacers would be the way to go, imo as I said in an earlier post. I also have a JL Audio class D 400 wrms 4-channel amp mounted in the tray above the jack storage hidden out of sight. The amp's rear two channels are bridged powering a 10" Alpine sw in a custom enclosure behind the seats. System is near useless with my sidepipes lol but it sounds great with the engine shut down. Sorry, no pics I can find at the moment.
Last edited by resdoggie; 11-09-2017 at 03:09 PM.
#17
Team Owner
Here's my .02....
We're talking about an audio system for the INSIDE of a sports car. If the hole is too small for the speaker, you have too large a speaker! Find the best substitute that will fit in the space available.
More to your point:
If you have a single flat surface, you might be able to get away with whittling some out to make space for the speaker. If you are dealing with a "box" member (load bearing piece), don't screw with it. (You can screw INTO it, but don't cut into it).
We're talking about an audio system for the INSIDE of a sports car. If the hole is too small for the speaker, you have too large a speaker! Find the best substitute that will fit in the space available.
More to your point:
If you have a single flat surface, you might be able to get away with whittling some out to make space for the speaker. If you are dealing with a "box" member (load bearing piece), don't screw with it. (You can screw INTO it, but don't cut into it).
#18
Melting Slicks
I would avoid cutting the birdcage.
Investigate using a plate to space the speaker out slightly that will give you some relief from the speakers cage getting in the way.
I wanted my speakers behind the kick panel covers so did shallow spacers. But If you don’t care about that you could go thicker.
Investigate using a plate to space the speaker out slightly that will give you some relief from the speakers cage getting in the way.
I wanted my speakers behind the kick panel covers so did shallow spacers. But If you don’t care about that you could go thicker.
Last edited by CraigH; 11-10-2017 at 04:37 AM.