Crank / No Spark problem
joe
Last edited by joe paco; Jul 25, 2011 at 09:24 AM. Reason: brain error:**
Last edited by corvettecpl; Jul 24, 2011 at 04:34 PM.
6d4-9 in my 91 has details to check pickup coil.
I hope you marked the distributor housing and TWO rotor positions before removing it? makes dropping it in easy and accurate.
saludos, joe
Test the current module to see if its good or not before buying a new one.
The Best of Corvette for Corvette Enthusiasts
I would first establish that there is 12 volts at the hot lead going into the distributor. May or may not be likely but it's an easy check and costs nothing. It's possible with no spark at all there's no power going to it. I would then examine the distributor for a frayed wiring harness. If the harness is frayed then the module probably shorted out. Whether or not its frayed I'd have the module tested. Autozone can do that for free.
Last edited by corvettecpl; Jul 27, 2011 at 07:06 AM.
having a young grandson experience it is further blessed, as you know.
the systematic, rational approach is best, but generally is not followed. the fsm leads to a conclusion, and you may notice that the very last recommendation was "replace module."
also, the Haynes -which most people ridicule- shows how to verfy the pickup coil with a meter, but the fsm does not -at least, not on that chart. it does give resistence values on page 6d4-12 in the 91 book.
as I said, never had reason to tear the HEI down, but have removed distr several times in the 91, for various reasons, and once to verify the components with a meter, pre-emptive checks, for the day it should fail. I like to learn somethng every day.

thanks for sharing your experience.
saludos, joe
having a young grandson experience it is further blessed, as you know.
the systematic, rational approach is best, but generally is not followed. the fsm leads to a conclusion, and you may notice that the very last recommendation was "replace module."
also, the Haynes -which most people ridicule- shows how to verfy the pickup coil with a meter, but the fsm does not -at least, not on that chart. it does give resistence values on page 6d4-12 in the 91 book.
as I said, never had reason to tear the HEI down, but have removed distr several times in the 91, for various reasons, and once to verify the components with a meter, pre-emptive checks, for the day it should fail. I like to learn somethng every day.

thanks for sharing your experience.
saludos, joe
Joe I was one of the guys who said module. I have been in this business for ove 35 years. Running a fleet of over 200 vehicles. I have only seen about 2 Gm pick up coils fail in my life and they both were for the broken wires coming off them. Some resopnces you get on this form are from people who have been there and done that. Whet he desribed was tipical for GM module failure. For about 15.00 it really should have been part of his tune up anyway. And honestly not trying to knock the OP but he replaced 2 parts a one time so how are we sure it was the pick up coil? Hanes and the other manules are fine for gerneic things. But when it comes to testing, removing parts. chaseing wireing faults and diagrams. there is no replacement for FSM.
I didn't suggest what it might be because I have no experience working on HEI's. I was reading the book at the time, and advised him about the first test for no spark. I have to stick with my comment, since the fsm leads the way, and I don't know for sure if the module "normally" causes no spark, or other symptoms.
Your experience may point you to the module 90% of the time, but one can get a dozen suggestions on what it might be. The fact is that it is a leap of faith, and could be expensive, depending on the component. The first reply he got was to verify the problem by checking, not throwing parts at it.
Seems like he did that. I would have no choice, since I have changed parts and recently checked some components but never verified a defect in HEI.
I had the Haynes when I got the car, and know its limitations. It covers too many years. The FSM, on the other hand, is meant for GM trained techs, not guys like us, and leaves out a lot of stuff. What could be a paragraph often is a sentence.
I also wondered about replacing two parts, but he said the coil had insulation off the wires. One day, he can put the module back in to see what happens. Also the coil

saludos, joe
I had no idea until now what a module cost. saw one in Echler's for about $115.
my curiosity is why the fsm does not suggest the most likely causes, so that can be looked at first, as it does on "no crank no click," going directly to the purple wire on solenoid.
as I said, being truthful, I was commenting on the general approach, rather than your or Calderone's remarks. my point should have been that the systematic approach will work better for the problems with which we are not familiar.
in hindsight, I should have left the comments out. one of the big limitations of e mail and internet is that words appear harder than intended most of the time, because we don't see the "body language." that's the reason for the smileys.
Last edited by joe paco; Jul 27, 2011 at 09:43 PM. Reason: spelling
Last edited by corvettecpl; Jul 27, 2011 at 10:16 PM.
there is an interesting, old thread posted today, by My1st, "injectors no pulse." very similar to your problem.
the posts were intelligent, and pointed the guy to the most likely solutions. evidently, someone convinced him to change to a small dist with a remote coil, after he had -eventually- verifed that the pickup coil was defective.
no subtle message here, just thought it was interesting.
saludos, joe
there is an interesting, old thread posted today, by My1st, "injectors no pulse." very similar to your problem.
the posts were intelligent, and pointed the guy to the most likely solutions. evidently, someone convinced him to change to a small dist with a remote coil, after he had -eventually- verifed that the pickup coil was defective.
no subtle message here, just thought it was interesting.
saludos, joe
Once the guy heard of the "divorced" coil, he had to have it, even tho' he had replaced the entire HEI except for the defective component!

Thought you'd remember.
saludos,
joe














