Need engine advice
a few few months ago I bought a used c5 vet with a lot of miles (172k). I am looking to replace the motor in the car with something that will hold 550hp safely. I have been looking at motors from TMS but cruising through the forums I have seen other suggestions. Looking for some advice. My budget is $4000. With that 4K hoping for a long block with an upgraded cam and head. Looking to stay N/A not boosted. Thanks!
There are always cheaper ways to do things, but just go into it with your eyes open. Definitely calculate the costs before you dive in. (and decide if the rest of the car is in a condition to warrant that level of investment)
Are you going to reuse a 172k mile water pump, probably not. New radiator hoses? Thermostat? How about plug wires? Are you going to add heat boot over the plug wires? Obviously new spark plugs. Are you going to reuse the OE harmonic balancer (known to separate and wobble), or are you going to a Powerbond or an ATI? Are you going to reuse all the drivebelt pulleys and tensioner? New belts? New O2 sensors? New oil pressure sensor? If you're adding big hp, then you'll be getting to the limit of the factory fuel injectors. Even if you don't need bigger injectors, sending the factory ones out to be cleaned and flow balanced would be smart if they have 172k miles on them. Are you going to keep the stock PCV setup, or swap to the 04+ LS6 valley cover/pcv? Are you going to add a catch can? You can easily spend several hundred dollars in new gaskets for the entire engine.
As mentioned, if you have a manual transmission, an upgraded clutch is going to necessary. If you have an automatic, you'll probably need a different TC to match the bigger cam.
If you're pulling the motor, then that's also a good time to pull the torque tube and inspect the couplers, etc. At that mileage, you will likely need to replace them.
I don't say all this to scare anyone but I do want to share accurate information. Sometimes engine building gets over simplified. I kept very details records of what I spent during my build... and honestly it's pretty depressing, haha. but I had counted the costs ahead of time and knew what I was getting into.
Been down this road before, cheaper to purchase a car already done and work out bugs that surface.
Last edited by Andrew; Jun 1, 2018 at 09:19 AM.
This is a lesson often learned the hard way (well at least I continue learning the hard way). Plus you only get a fraction of your investment back when you sell the car. And it's even worse on a high mileage car.
PS: I feel like we've been very discouraging... but please don't take it that way. Congrats on the new (to you) Corvette. It's a fun car, and I hope you're enjoying it!
The Best of Corvette for Corvette Enthusiasts
Remember, when it comes to hotrods, there's a saying: "Cheap, fast, reliable - pick any two."
Will the below short block block be good for cams, heads, intake, headers, exhaust?
https://rover.ebay.com/rover/0/0/0?m...2F281137769411
get the bump up package with the cam and parts.
find a set of good condition heads in the for sale section.
What parts/ sensors would you recommend that I replace?
thanks again guys. Love this car and can’t wait to get it on the road






I looked back over their customer ratings and in over a year's time only saw customer feedback for one engine and that was a much more expensive engine than the short block shown in this listing. Could be a nice rebuild, but if it was me, I'd wonder why no feedback on the short block.
Not the end of the world but remember the iron block is going to be almost 50 pounds heavier than the LS1 block. For street driving you'll probably never notice it, but if you decided to road race it you probably would.
Also check to see if there are any good shops in your local area. Get to know the people there. Explain what you want to do to your car and why. Have them give you build ideas and pricing.
If the car is running ok for now, try to save as much as you can so that when you're ready to build it up you can give it the first class job you want. As several others have mentioned, you can spend a good part of your budget just on the replacement parts. They won't make your car go any faster, but you don't want to do much horsepower improvement in a 172k mile engine without replacing the balancer, oil pump, water pump, checking pulleys, replacing belts, gaskets, hoses, plug wires, plugs, etc, etc.
Please let us know what you do.
Been down this road before, cheaper to purchase a car already done and work out bugs that surface.
Those motors tolerate 500-750 horsepower and cost $500 each.
Just need a turbocharger, plumbing is what the $$ goes into.
This way you torch an $500 engine, instead of a $6500 engine each time.
You can go through five engines and still cost less than that one you had built.
Those motors tolerate 500-750 horsepower and cost $500 each.
Just need a turbocharger, plumbing is what the $$ goes into.
This way you torch an $500 engine, instead of a $6500 engine each time.
You can go through five engines and still cost less than that one you had built.
There are 999 modifications you need inside an engine which are far more difficult to produce properly than anything you could do outside of an engine.
To put this another way, rebuilt engines typically go 1/8 to 1/30 the mileage of a factory engine because of all the mistakes professional engine builders make, including those passed on by the owner who does not understand for example what a larger than stock bearing clearance entails in a rebuild using standard bearings.
Rebuilding the engine puts you at nearly 1000% more risk of losing expensive parts. And everything is custom. This whole hobby is one big fat custom job. Anyone that comes on a Horsepower-Car oriented forum and claims "I dont want anything custom" then drops $6000 on a fully custom engine that takes 4 months to get back from the machine shop and goes 5,280 miles over the course of 2 years and then fails is pretty damn typical, novice failures, and this is what Novices need to avoid but don't for some reason.
This thread is an excellent example of what one may face when attempting the rebuild routine.
I suspect the owner has a high amount of experience by the way the post is detailed.
This mistake can happen to those even with high amounts of experience, if only because it is difficult to build an engine properly. He knew better than to attempt it himself so like many had a trusted builder do it.
Mains were set to .002" Rods .0023". Piston to bore .005". Rings .024 and .028.
Stock crank.
With no change in the tune or boost (18psi at the time) the car was 3 mph slower....
2. https://www.corvetteforum.com/forums...e-parts-2.html
This thread is a great example because this is what you normally do not get to see. Usually you buy an engine, and run it right away. And then when it fails you can't tell from the exposed/ruined surfaces what caused it. Did the thrust wear come first and THEN this nasty finish? Or the other way around?
Nobody buys an engine and takes it apart right away to inspect all the work done first. But this guy does exactly that to a brand new purchased rebuilt engine from a popular distributor and finds a LOAD of mistakes.
IMO if you want to buy an engine you need to buy two of them identical. Take one apart and if it isn't absolutely perfect in every surface you get more I guess. I mean what else do you want? A factory where the assembly procedure is written down, millions of engines are turned out a year, and computer controlled machines do most of the machine work? The closest thing I can think of to that is the OEM. The expensive forged parts aren't the problem; but they are not really an easy solution either apparently. the lack of attention to detail in every particular surface is critical to performance. And so is cleanliness. Clean and exact is just hard to come by.
This thread is an excellent example of what one may face when attempting the rebuild routine.
I suspect the owner has a high amount of experience by the way the post is detailed.
This mistake can happen to those even with high amounts of experience, if only because it is difficult to build an engine properly. He knew better than to attempt it himself so like many had a trusted builder do it.
2. https://www.corvetteforum.com/forums...e-parts-2.html
This thread is a great example because this is what you normally do not get to see. Usually you buy an engine, and run it right away. And then when it fails you can't tell from the exposed/ruined surfaces what caused it. Did the thrust wear come first and THEN this nasty finish? Or the other way around?
Nobody buys an engine and takes it apart right away to inspect all the work done first. But this guy does exactly that to a brand new purchased rebuilt engine from a popular distributor and finds a LOAD of mistakes.
IMO if you want to buy an engine you need to buy two of them identical. Take one apart and if it isn't absolutely perfect in every surface you get more I guess. I mean what else do you want? A factory where the assembly procedure is written down, millions of engines are turned out a year, and computer controlled machines do most of the machine work? The closest thing I can think of to that is the OEM. The expensive forged parts aren't the problem; but they are not really an easy solution either apparently. the lack of attention to detail in every particular surface is critical to performance. And so is cleanliness. Clean and exact is just hard to come by.
Last edited by Andrew; Jun 2, 2018 at 02:47 PM.
I do agree that there are ways of building cheap hp. Find an iron block take-out motor that's in good shape, throw a turbo on it, and run it until it blows up, and then repeat. However, I personally just don't have the time to keep pulling the driveline out of a C5 in my garage. I also like road course racing more than drag racing, so my engine goals are different.
I personally found it cheaper to reuse my existing block and crankshaft vs buying a short block. plus I got to pick what parts I wanted to use. but it would have been faster to just have a new short block show up, vs waiting on a machine shop. There's no such thing as a fast machine shop. They work on their own time, and you'll get your engine back on their time schedule. And a good machine shop will have all the work they can handle. you're just happy to get on their list.
when picking a machine shop, definitely check around. I learned a tough lesson the first time I had the engine in my 4.6L mustang built. I used a top notch shop that has been in the business of building race engines for the last 40 years. However, I later realize that my modular 4.6L motor was not their specialty, in fact it might have been one of the first they did. that motor lost oil pressure at 1500 miles because the bearing clearances weren't right. If I had a SBC motor, they were the best shop around... but not for a modular ford.
So the first question I asked my engine builder for the C5 was how many LS motors have you built. Turns out he did almost exclusively LS motors and has 5-10 builds going at any given time. Most of the speed shops in the area use him, and often drop off multiple engines at a time. You really want someone who builds your type of engine on a regular basis, and really knows the engine well.
Attached is a rough list of the parts that went into my build. You can see how quickly it adds up. And I really searched the internet to find the best price on things, find any holiday sales, plus I work for an auto parts retailer, so a lot of a basic gaskets/sensors/etc I could buy with an employee discount.
If you don't do track events you wouldn't need the oil pan baffles, and instead of the ATI balancer you could save a few bucks with a powerbond. But those are minor savings in the grand scheme of things. And not listed is a new water pump because I was able to reuse mine. And the list doesn't include an upgraded intake manifold.
I also decided this was the right time to install an upgraded DeWitts radiator. I also did new tires/wheels/tpms sensors. I also did Z06 springs and DRM Bilstein shocks. basically this one crack-addict saying to a future crack-addict... Be careful what you start! It's a slippery slope, haha.













