When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.
if the outer diameter of the tires are close to the same (something like 26.x") active handeling will be fine.
From a pure performance standpoint, 17" wheels would be better b/c the weight of the wheels is closer to the center, that is assuming that they will clear whatever brakes you've got on the car, which may require an 18" wheel.
for the size wheels you listed a 265/35R18 front and 295/35R18 rear would be perfect.
The main thing to worry about is the weight of the wheels. Some of the fancy chrome wheels weigh as much as 5-10lbs more and would be like adding a 100lb. weight to the car. However, unless you're serious about racing the car, it won't make much difference on the street
I went with C5 chrome aftermarket thin spokes 18 x 9.5 front and 18 x 10.5 rear. They are a little heavier but I did not buy runflats which are heavy tires so I lost some on the tires and gained some on the wheels. net weight gain could not me more than 20 lbs total. For tire I bought Pirelli Pzero Corsa competition tires 285/30/18 front and 315/30/18 rear. These sizes were on sale at tirerack.com for 764.00 shipped for all four tires. The wheels from bobs house of wheels for 1000 shipped. The stock rear tire is .98 of an inch taller than the stock front, my tires work out to .71 of an inch difference back to front slope. So far no problem with active handling, no rubbing problems either. The footprint of the tires is almost perfectly flush with the outside of the fenders giving it a very square flush and wide footprint. Looks good. Here is a tire calculator link that you can use to check tire diameters and speedometer issues. I use a hypertech III to set my speedometer and it also adjusts the A4 shifting to match the new tire sizes. http://www.discounttire.com/dtc/broc...o/tireMath.jsp
I have just bought a set of Iforged Senekas:
18" x 10" front
18" x 11" rear
I also just placed an order for the Pirelli Pzeros from Tirerack
285/30-R18 front
315/30-R18 rear
I did a lot of research and it seems that the size wheels front-rear offer the best overall handling when the suspension is set up the same. The main reasons though that I didnt get a 19" rear wheel was:
1. Limited tire choice (primarily width) and no R-compound tires
2. Wheel weight (inertia)
3. Better handling