When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.
From: Some where in Amerika, sadly watching how is turned into a Socialist Republic.
Originally Posted by schilitj
Lifter started ticking about a month ago, took it in for a check and we were going to do an oil pressure check to see about the oil pump. 2 days later on the way to work, going 15mph around a 90 degree corner, car lost power, engine stopped, car backfired. The rest is history.
Something is wrong with this picture, I just can't see how a collapsed lifter doing all that damage, I gould get a second opinion. A colapse lifter? valves bent? timing chain gone. I can understand the damage from over reving, but not from a collapsed lifter, or maybe it was explained wrong.
I agree...collapsed lifter doesn't mean damaged valves, pistons etc...dropped valve though might...
Just got the call. Lifter collapsed and got stuck in the bore hole (my ignorance is showing, I have no idea what that is). Several valves are bent, pistons are nicked, timing chain is shot, cam is suspect AND the block is gone
So, looks like a new short block for my C6.
sorry to hear of the engine failure but you must have had fun up to that point given the mods you have on the car. do me a favor though, just don't start a new thread on how the General denied your warranty claim
From: Some where in Amerika, sadly watching how is turned into a Socialist Republic.
Originally Posted by schilitj
Just got the call. Lifter collapsed and got stuck in the bore hole (my ignorance is showing, I have no idea what that is). Several valves are bent, pistons are nicked, timing chain is shot, cam is suspect AND the block is gone
So, looks like a new short block for my C6.
I don't know who builts your engines in Boca, but do your self a favor and look at MESA BALANCING here in Miami, his engines are bullit proof, it may be worth the drive. I've assembled some of his short blocks for some of my customers, great stuff, never seen one let go.
I agree...collapsed lifter doesn't mean damaged valves, pistons etc...dropped valve though might...
Here we go... lifter collapses and then valve(s) in that cylinder hit piston. Valve snaps off or is bent to one side and piston comes up and smacks it and comes to a violent stop (bent rod). Other cylinders keep trying to spin crankshaft and timing chain, but cam can not spin because rocker arms for the bad cylinder can not move. Timing chain now shears off teeth and the rest of the valvetrain begins to come apart, go out of time and other valves hit other pistons and the block quickly turns to junk. Lucky the crank did not snap in half. And all the above just happened in the blink of an eye. Yes, a collapsed lifter can destroy and engine.
Here we go... lifter collapses and then valve(s) in that cylinder hit piston. Valve snaps off or is bent to one side and piston comes up and smacks it and comes to a violent stop (bent rod). Other cylinders keep trying to spin crankshaft and timing chain, but cam can not spin because rocker arms for the bad cylinder can not move. Timing chain now shears off teeth and the rest of the valvetrain begins to come apart, go out of time and other valves hit other pistons and the block quickly turns to junk. Lucky the crank did not snap in half. And all the above just happened in the blink of an eye. Yes, a collapsed lifter can destroy and engine.
If the lifter collapses the valve doesn't open......so it won't hit anything....
If the lifter collapses the valve doesn't open......so it won't hit anything....
Not true, it just may not open as much and if slack is in the pushrod, then the pushrod could bend and away we go. When the valvetrain fails, just about anything else can happen.
Not true, it just may not open as much and if slack is in the pushrod, then the pushrod could bend and away we go. When the valvetrain fails, just about anything else can happen.
yes it is true....if it is collasped the valve spring keeps it against the head...it won't move. The engine will rotate the cam will rotate and that cylinder won't fire...because that valve won't move.
Not true, it just may not open as much and if slack is in the pushrod, then the pushrod could bend and away we go. When the valvetrain fails, just about anything else can happen.
The push rod would bend because....?
This was a blown, cammed motor. It could have been over revved, a keeper could have come loose.... most likely, a valve spring busted because it was used for 40K miles w/o replacement.
Lots of things could have happened.
But, IMHO, simple loss of a lifter ain't what started this chain of events.
Quote:
Originally Posted by ucfmike79
Yea I dyno'd...here are mods 05 C6 mn6 :
AFR 205
Kooks 1 7/8 LT w cats
Bassani exhaust
Halltech intake
G1 228/232 113 cam springs rated up to .650 lift
Jeremy Formato tune (good guy...was pleased with his work)
schilitj: Our numbers are almost identical: mine 443/399. Have AFR 225, 224/231 581/592 cam, dynatech 1 7/8 headers and corsa exhaust.
Here is the $1.98 question: what about the springs?
918's?
26918:
• Extended .625” max lift, 125 lbs seat pressure at 1.800” installed height for aggressive cam designs
• Incorporates 10+ years of Beehive™ Valve Spring development and refined manufacturing processes
• Designed with GM Gen III/LS engines in mind – for use with hydraulic and solid roller camshafts
• Features manufacturing processes found in exotic race springs, providing a unique silver satin finish
St. Jude Donor '05-'06-'07-'08-'09-'10-'11-'12-'13-'14
Originally Posted by corvette pilot
Sorry to hear it Jeff, what are you replacing it with? Another LS2, or LS3 or crate LSX?
Mike, not sure, talking with Roger at Horsepower Sales to determine what will work best with the heads, headers, and supercharger. The cam will probably need to be replaced.
Originally Posted by TrackNoob
The push rod would bend because....?
This was a blown, cammed motor. It could have been over revved, a keeper could have come loose.... most likely, a valve spring busted because it was used for 40K miles w/o replacement.
Lots of things could have happened.
But, IMHO, simple loss of a lifter ain't what started this chain of events.
When the engine let go I was doing 15mph around a 90 degree corner. I heard a lifter start ticking about a month ago, was just getting ready to take it in for service and replacement as needed. My car is only worked on by vette specialist, Horsepower Sales, the group that did all the mods.
Like you, I'd love to know what started the chain of events, unfortunately I don't think I'll ever find out.
yes it is true....if it is collasped the valve spring keeps it against the head...it won't move. The engine will rotate the cam will rotate and that cylinder won't fire...because that valve won't move.
Let's work through this one. I do agree with your comment, but if the lifter is collapsed, then the preload on that end of the pushrod is now gone. The pushrod can move up and down as there is no longer any tension on it to hold it firmly against the top of the lifter or the bottom of the rocker arm. Spinning at only a few thousand rpm, the lifter goes up (it is not stuck, just collapsed) and slaps the end of the pushrod and then the pushrod slaps the bottom of the rocker. Since the preload is gone, this all happens at the wrong timing sequence and you can end up with a bent pushrod and/or a valve hitting a piston as the geometry is now all thrown off. I have seen this exact failure on a few Harleys. And the LS engines are still nothing but fancy pushrod engines, just like Harley's.