When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.
I need to have my transmission cooler lines re-routed (the cooler in the radiator was bypassed when my auxiliary cooler was installed and I need to have it re-connected). My tuner recommended that I have a transmission fluid flush performed at the same time to clean out the system.
I know some believe that this is a bad idea, and some swear by it. I'm doing it because my fluid's been way too hot a couple times and also because the coolers are definitely going to need to be cleaned out after being disconnected for 6 months. If you really think this is a bad idea, I'd really like to know why before I bring it in and potentially blow something up.
Has anyone done this, and if so what do I need to look for in the shop that does the job? Am I better off going to the dealership or finding a local shop? The only shop around here that does it is some 10-minute oil change place and that's not very confidence inspiring.....haven't talked to the dealer about it yet but I'm hesitant to bring a modified car to a dealer for service.
Obviously just my opinion but I think many of us recommend against trans flushing for no good reason, like "it has 50k miles on it", or "I like to do preventative fluid changes", etc. If the fluid looks good, doesn't smell burned and the trans is working correctly then there is no reason to do a flush. There have been too many stories here of problems after flushing.
That is certainly not your case and a flush in conjunction with your other work, and considering the prior heating issue, is appropriate, again in my opinion.
Sounds like the dealer is going to be your best bet. I wouldn't trust a quick lube type place. Talk to the service manager and get the best assurances you can that they know what they're doing and have the latest equipment. If you aren't convinced then keep looking.
I found another shop in the area that will do a flush; I will go by this afternoon and discuss the process in detail. I want to see which type of machine they have and how much experience they have using it. If I'm not satisfied, I'll be sitting down with a service advisor at the dealer later.
Just under 20,000 (twenty thousand) miles. The fluid was changed once when the auxiliary cooler was added, but it was not flushed to my knowledge. That would've been somewhere around 10-12k miles ago. Both sets of fluid have seen 240+ temps (Fahrenheit) on track and 200+ driving in town regularly.
Personally, I'd never do a flush. Dropping the pan to clean it and change the filter will require about 6.5 quarts of fluid. In your case, you might want to pump a little fluid in the cooler while it's not connected to anything else and then blow it out to get rid of any dirt accumulation. Look at the fluid coming out for dirt and repeat if necessary.
Then after you drive it a couple hundred miles, siphon out as much as possible (probably 6-7 quarts) and refill with fresh fluid. You'll end up with 75-80% new fluid and a fairly clean filter.
I don't know where you are, but I'd avoid a dealer, even if I had to drive hundreds of miles to find someone knowledgeable.
Learning how to do it and then doing it yourself is the best way to know it got done right. The bonus is not only the cost, but the self-satisfaction.
BTW, the 200 degrees in town is not a big deal, but continuous running at 240+ is a problem.
I had my A4 flushed at the dealer about 1000 miles ago for under $200. It was at 50K miles. I expressed my concern to the SA about horror stories I've heard about and he swore it would be ok. Well it has been. No problems at all.
Well, really doesn't matter anymore because today I discovered that no one will touch my car because it isn't 100% stock anymore. Meineke told me to go to the dealer to make sure that I don't have any kind of real issue with the trans, and the dealer won't even look at the thing because they "don't mess with anything that's modified".
So at this point I'm scheduled to bring it in to the shop that initially installed the cooler and they're gonna re-run the lines, drop the pan, and run a few sets of fresh fluid through the system. The lines on the radiator are capped off so there shouldn't be any debris in there. They don't have a flush machine, and honestly from what I've read it probably isn't necessary to flush it anyway.
I would absolutely love to do this myself but as it's more complicated than turning a wrench I don't feel like having my only vehicle on jack stands for more than an hour or four.
It's really not very hard and any decent mechanic should be able to do it if they can follow instructions. What looks like a drain plug is actually how you set the fluid level with the car level and the motor running.
Dropping the pan to clean it and change the filter will require about 6.5 quarts of fluid.
I've read this on here many times. 6-7 qts seems to be the general consensus. But...I have dropped my pan twice. Once to do a converter swap (with fluid and filter change), and again this weekend to fix another problem. Both times, mine has taken WAY more than 7 qts to get the fluid to run out of the plug. This weekend mine took 10.5 qts to get fluid to dribble out of the check plug. It also had been checked just 6 weeks ago, and the fluid level was correct. When I changed the converter, I didn't think I was EVER going to get that thing filled up! I forget how much it took exactly, but it was a bunch!
240 shouldn't be much of a problem. The transmission will go into cool down mode about 280 I think. I had mine to 240 a few times before upgrading my radiator, had the dealer install the aftermarket radiator and flush the transmission and change its filter. The mechanic told me the transmission fluid looked like new. The car ran great for the remainder of the hpde season last year and all of this year.