When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.
I thought I saw a thread on this but can't find now. But a discussion was started on Facebook in the BMW owners thread(bikes) about no warmup, crank and ride off.
I thought I saw on the dry sump engines they need to warm up??
Dry sump versus wet sump makes no difference concerning warm-up.......I warm-up all my cars before I drive.....I wait till I have 100F coolant temp before I move....I know "old school"...but I think its better for the engine.....I have done this for about 10 cars in the last 30 years...never any oil consumption issues, and I drive these cars for at least 100,000 miles.
The origin of the "don't let it idle to warm it up" are the environmentalists.....
Last edited by ersatz928; Dec 15, 2016 at 08:36 AM.
I disagree. All modern cars are designed to start it up and move it out. As long as you take it easy, you won't hurt anything and it actually warms up faster, which is better for the engine and transmission both.
Having it sit and idle until warm does nothing for the tranny, differential, etc.
I drive very conservatively until the yellow disappears from the display. I do let the engine idle for about 1 minute in an effort to prevent the jerk when I put the tranny in R or D. So far it seems to work.
Dry sump versus wet sump makes no difference concerning warm-up.......I warm-up all my cars before I drive.....I wait till I have 100F coolant temp before I move....I know "old school"...but I think its better for the engine.....I have done this for about 10 cars in the last 30 years...never any oil consumption issues, and I drive these cars for at least 100,000 miles.
The origin of the "don't let it idle to warm it up" are the environmentalists.....
And you would be wrong. But I"m only an engineer, so what do I know.
Dry sump versus wet sump makes no difference concerning warm-up.......I warm-up all my cars before I drive.....I wait till I have 100F coolant temp before I move....I know "old school"...but I think its better for the engine.....I have done this for about 10 cars in the last 30 years...never any oil consumption issues, and I drive these cars for at least 100,000 miles.
The origin of the "don't let it idle to warm it up" are the environmentalists.....
I agree. I always idle for 30-60 seconds until the fluids get up to what I consider minimum operating temperatures. Understand operating temperatures to me is when the fluids move normally thru the car engine. This is not maximum operating temperatures which is around 190F degrees. My garage in Texas never gets below freezing and rarely below 50 but a few seconds to warm up can never hurt. I prefer letting it idle till coolant is at 100F degrees if possible. Likewise I have never had engine or shift issues outta the garage in my 16 1LT base A8 coupe.
And you would be wrong. But I"m only an engineer, so what do I know.
And I too am an Engineer....what does that add to this discussion?....
There is no hard evidence to support either side of this discussion, my opinion only because as an Engineer it makes sense to me (to warm it up), but I think it is clear that not warming it up saves gasoline...which is why I say that it is for environmental reasons that you should not idle it, and just drive....I am willing to use a little more gas to reduce wear in my engine.....
Last edited by ersatz928; Dec 15, 2016 at 10:43 AM.
My cars sit at idle in the morning for about 15 secs, enough time to put my seatbelt on and get the Bluetooth working.
Yup! I sit until all the stuff quits blinking and loading. I'd guess 15-20 seconds and then I drive off. When the yellow bars disappear, I have full throttle range (if I want it).
And I too am an Engineer....what does that add to this discussion?....
There is no hard evidence to support either side of this discussion, my opinion only because as an Engineer it makes sense to me (to warm it up), but I think it is clear that not warming it up saves gasoline...which is why I say that it is for environmental reasons that you should not idle it, and just drive....I am willing to use a little more gas to reduce wear in my engine.....
I start and go because then all of the components of the car warm up in unison, instead of just the engine getting warm with the rest of the drive train and tires remaining cold.
start it, put it in gear, go, and take it easy.
Nothing to do with wasting gas.
Last edited by Thunder22; Dec 15, 2016 at 01:10 PM.
Makes no difference
Best to get it moving as soon as possible.
In the "old days" with heavier weight oil there was some "warm it up" logic. Today with 5 weight oil when cold best to move out and let the engine switch from that rich idle mixture as fast as possible. The Vette tells be on the tac when I can start increasing the rev's.
As mentioned, the tach displays a very conservative redline until fully warmed up. This display is so progressive you can see the redline creeping back up to 6500. So your technically good to go right from startup, and considering 98% of the time, this is in the summer, there is no problem. Probably a good idea to let it run for 30 seconds.
I do notice the engine is a bit bitchy until run for about 2-3 minutes but i have the manual so it doesn't mask any surging like an auto does.