Harmonic Balancer replacement
#1
Instructor
Thread Starter
Harmonic Balancer replacement
Well after our first significant rain yesterday, when I started my car after work, I hear the birds chirping under the hood. It quit by the time I got home,but I opened the hood and could see HB wobble, so I have to drop it off at the chevy dealer after work tomorrow.
They gave me a guestimate over the phone of around $850+, it really chaps me that I'm replacing a balancer at 53,000 miles on a $50k car. I've owned a lot cars since 1973 and I've never had to replace a harmonic balancer GM should be ashamed, I've been a Ford man all my life, so this leaves a sour taste in my mouth though I love my Vette.
I know all makes have their problems at times, but this is ridiculous......as much as this has happened on these LS2/3 engines there should be a class action lawsuit. Oh well, I pray it holds up for a bit.
They gave me a guestimate over the phone of around $850+, it really chaps me that I'm replacing a balancer at 53,000 miles on a $50k car. I've owned a lot cars since 1973 and I've never had to replace a harmonic balancer GM should be ashamed, I've been a Ford man all my life, so this leaves a sour taste in my mouth though I love my Vette.
I know all makes have their problems at times, but this is ridiculous......as much as this has happened on these LS2/3 engines there should be a class action lawsuit. Oh well, I pray it holds up for a bit.
#3
Tolero Apto Victum
OP: I had the wobbles on my 07 LS2 so I had it replaced with these two items and never looked back.
http://store.katechengines.com/bille...sioner-p2.aspx
http://store.katechengines.com/ati-s...ts-v-p230.aspx
Good Luck!
http://store.katechengines.com/bille...sioner-p2.aspx
http://store.katechengines.com/ati-s...ts-v-p230.aspx
Good Luck!
#4
Instructor
Thread Starter
#5
Instructor
Thread Starter
OP: I had the wobbles on my 07 LS2 so I had it replaced with these two items and never looked back.
http://store.katechengines.com/bille...sioner-p2.aspx
http://store.katechengines.com/ati-s...ts-v-p230.aspx
Good Luck!
http://store.katechengines.com/bille...sioner-p2.aspx
http://store.katechengines.com/ati-s...ts-v-p230.aspx
Good Luck!
#6
Le Mans Master
Here's what I replaced the stock harmonic dampner on my LS2 with: http://www.byunspeed.com/product_inf...oducts_id=4545
It's a great pulley for the money. Byun speed also has a Powerbond available in stock size (7.4) if you call them.
If you (or dealer tech) press-on another POS GM supplied pulley, you risk the issue arrising again:
http://forums.corvetteforum.com/c6-t...000-miles.html
http://forums.corvetteforum.com/c6-t...ned-crank.html
It's a great pulley for the money. Byun speed also has a Powerbond available in stock size (7.4) if you call them.
If you (or dealer tech) press-on another POS GM supplied pulley, you risk the issue arrising again:
http://forums.corvetteforum.com/c6-t...000-miles.html
http://forums.corvetteforum.com/c6-t...ned-crank.html
Last edited by DSOMC6; 09-20-2011 at 11:33 PM.
#7
Le Mans Master
Member Since: Aug 2005
Location: Pacific Northwest
Posts: 6,709
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
St. Jude Donor '06
Forgive me if this is a stupid question.
As I understand the stock pulleys are balanced to the engine/crank and when replaced the stock weights must be re-installed in the exact same locations to maintain proper balance.
How is the balancing handled with the aftermarket pulleys?
As I understand the stock pulleys are balanced to the engine/crank and when replaced the stock weights must be re-installed in the exact same locations to maintain proper balance.
How is the balancing handled with the aftermarket pulleys?
#8
Drifting
Well after our first significant rain yesterday, when I started my car after work, I hear the birds chirping under the hood. It quit by the time I got home,but I opened the hood and could see HB wobble, so I have to drop it off at the chevy dealer after work tomorrow.
They gave me a guestimate over the phone of around $850+, it really chaps me that I'm replacing a balancer at 53,000 miles on a $50k car. I've owned a lot cars since 1973 and I've never had to replace a harmonic balancer GM should be ashamed, I've been a Ford man all my life, so this leaves a sour taste in my mouth though I love my Vette.
I know all makes have their problems at times, but this is ridiculous......as much as this has happened on these LS2/3 engines there should be a class action lawsuit. Oh well, I pray it holds up for a bit.
They gave me a guestimate over the phone of around $850+, it really chaps me that I'm replacing a balancer at 53,000 miles on a $50k car. I've owned a lot cars since 1973 and I've never had to replace a harmonic balancer GM should be ashamed, I've been a Ford man all my life, so this leaves a sour taste in my mouth though I love my Vette.
I know all makes have their problems at times, but this is ridiculous......as much as this has happened on these LS2/3 engines there should be a class action lawsuit. Oh well, I pray it holds up for a bit.
#9
Melting Slicks
Member Since: Feb 2011
Location: Canaveral Groves Florida
Posts: 2,101
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
St. Jude Donor '11-'12-'13
Replaced mine 1000miles ago with an slp 25% underdrive. Had it done ar Corvette Masters in Mainland Fl. $375 for labor!
I've had no issues with the ac or charging my ORIGINAL battery. The pully spins as true as can be.
I've had no issues with the ac or charging my ORIGINAL battery. The pully spins as true as can be.
#10
CF Senior Member
Member Since: Feb 2006
Location: Tucson Arizona
Posts: 23,313
Likes: 0
Received 19 Likes
on
18 Posts
Is the crank-pulley bolt loose? Are the belts fraying? A small amount of wobble may be within acceptable parameters. If they need to replace the harmonic balancer (and I hope not) I think the $850 estimate is a bit optimistic. I'm guessing the replacement cost would be around $1,100.00. I hope its not as bad as you think. Good luck and let us know what happens.
I agree and the problem isn't limited to 2005 models....the problem affects cars from all model years. Why GM ever abandoned the keyway I'll never know but all of the Gen III and Gen IV V8 engines use a press-fit damper with no keyway. This has been the case since the LS1 was introduced in 1997. As a 'fix' there was a diamond-embedded friction washer introduced as a production part in the 2006 LS2 and LS7 motors (and I suspect in the late model 2005's as well).
The problem may only affect a small minority of cars but it's a problem that doesn't need to happen at all. The only real fix is to pin the crank. Pinning the crank is essential with forced induction applications and I think GM would be well-advised to pin the crank on their high power, naturally aspirated engines as well...on the Corvette. Prior to the press-fit damper GM probably built 100 million engines without this problem. I'd love to know why they changed.
The problem may only affect a small minority of cars but it's a problem that doesn't need to happen at all. The only real fix is to pin the crank. Pinning the crank is essential with forced induction applications and I think GM would be well-advised to pin the crank on their high power, naturally aspirated engines as well...on the Corvette. Prior to the press-fit damper GM probably built 100 million engines without this problem. I'd love to know why they changed.
#11
Le Mans Master
Forgive me if this is a stupid question.
As I understand the stock pulleys are balanced to the engine/crank and when replaced the stock weights must be re-installed in the exact same locations to maintain proper balance.
How is the balancing handled with the aftermarket pulleys?
As I understand the stock pulleys are balanced to the engine/crank and when replaced the stock weights must be re-installed in the exact same locations to maintain proper balance.
How is the balancing handled with the aftermarket pulleys?
Is the crank-pulley bolt loose? Are the belts fraying? A small amount of wobble may be within acceptable parameters. If they need to replace the harmonic balancer (and I hope not) I think the $850 estimate is a bit optimistic. I'm guessing the replacement cost would be around $1,100.00. I hope its not as bad as you think. Good luck and let us know what happens.
I agree and the problem isn't limited to 2005 models....the problem affects cars from all model years. Why GM ever abandoned the keyway I'll never know but all of the Gen III and Gen IV V8 engines use a press-fit damper with no keyway. This has been the case since the LS1 was introduced in 1997. As a 'fix' there was a diamond-embedded friction washer introduced as a production part in the 2006 LS2 and LS7 motors (and I suspect in the late model 2005's as well).
The problem may only affect a small minority of cars but it's a problem that doesn't need to happen at all. The only real fix is to pin the crank. Pinning the crank is essential with forced induction applications and I think GM would be well-advised to pin the crank on their high power, naturally aspirated engines as well...on the Corvette. Prior to the press-fit damper GM probably built 100 million engines without this problem. I'd love to know why they changed.
I agree and the problem isn't limited to 2005 models....the problem affects cars from all model years. Why GM ever abandoned the keyway I'll never know but all of the Gen III and Gen IV V8 engines use a press-fit damper with no keyway. This has been the case since the LS1 was introduced in 1997. As a 'fix' there was a diamond-embedded friction washer introduced as a production part in the 2006 LS2 and LS7 motors (and I suspect in the late model 2005's as well).
The problem may only affect a small minority of cars but it's a problem that doesn't need to happen at all. The only real fix is to pin the crank. Pinning the crank is essential with forced induction applications and I think GM would be well-advised to pin the crank on their high power, naturally aspirated engines as well...on the Corvette. Prior to the press-fit damper GM probably built 100 million engines without this problem. I'd love to know why they changed.
The following users liked this post:
Scottp3 (04-21-2022)
#12
#14
Melting Slicks
Member Since: Feb 2011
Location: Canaveral Groves Florida
Posts: 2,101
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
St. Jude Donor '11-'12-'13
[QUOTE]I think the $850 estimate is a bit optimistic. I'm guessing the replacement cost would be around $1,100.00.
See my post right above yours.
2005 had a problem with the bolt backing out that would not be an issue if it was pinned, but the majority of the problems are do to the stock balancer coming apart or delaminating and causing it to wobble.
Just my 2 cents.
See my post right above yours.
2005 had a problem with the bolt backing out that would not be an issue if it was pinned, but the majority of the problems are do to the stock balancer coming apart or delaminating and causing it to wobble.
Just my 2 cents.
#17
I'm having a hard time believing the amount of wobble I see in mine is acceptable. If so, it's a ****-poor design. It's worth it to me for peace of mind to install an ATI.
#18
Instructor
Thread Starter
I hope it is a tensioner or pulley bearing, but there sure is quite a bit of wobble there.....more than I'm comfy with lol. Engine feels good and smooth while accelerating and cruising, but I don't like that wobble and then when it was raining hearing the birds under the hood. I should find out tomorrow. Thanks y'all for your responses.
#20
I would like to see this thread, the engines are externally balanced at the factory with the flywheel and crank pulley. While it may not be "necessary" not swapping over weights and indexing the parts will certainly lose some of the balance performed.
The following users liked this post:
h8snow (06-12-2020)