When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.
I had the same problem in my 2014 M7 Z51 (the yellow bars would come back ON on the highway after the engine had warmed up in the city and the yellow bars had extinguished), and it was NOT the OEM thermostat nor its OEM replacement, both of which tested fine.
In my case, it was a very small leak from an aftermarket larger radiator from the PO. Once I replaced the radiator with a stock, new radiator (only change), all such problems went away.
I had the same problem in my 2014 M7 Z51 (the yellow bars would come back ON on the highway after the engine had warmed up in the city and the yellow bars had extinguished), and it was NOT the OEM thermostat nor its OEM replacement, both of which tested fine.
In my case, it was a very small leak from an aftermarket larger radiator from the PO. Once I replaced the radiator with a stock, new radiator (only change), all such problems went away.
Hmm, ok, a radiator leak made the car show cold temperatures. Sorry, I'm at a loss here. Coolant loss would not allow the car to get colder or cooler. Coolant loss would have the engine go hot and lock up the engine. Sorry to have to ask this, but was your problem overheating or did the tach bars show up because the coolant temp went down?
Hmm, ok, a radiator leak made the car show cold temperatures. Sorry, I'm at a loss here. Coolant loss would not allow the car to get colder or cooler. Coolant loss would have the engine go hot and lock up the engine. Sorry to have to ask this, but was your problem overheating or did the tach bars show up because the coolant temp went down?
Elmer
I did not have overheating problems (apart from the known 2014 radiator fan has a bug).
I had a consistent, "Car runs too cold at highway speeds" problem, over several months, from the day I bought it. Eventually I fixed it by replacing the (3x larger) aftermarket radiator (that had a small leak) with a stock radiator. Prior tests of the thermostat all showed that the thermostat was functioning properly. No other components were changed.
It seemed to me like the larger, "race" radiator's cooling capacity was simply overwhelming the system as a whole, despite the fact that there is a thermostat in there that ought to regulate things properly.
I did not have overheating problems (apart from the known 2014 radiator fan has a bug).
I had a consistent, "Car runs too cold at highway speeds" problem, over several months, from the day I bought it. Eventually I fixed it by replacing the (3x larger) aftermarket radiator (that had a small leak) with a stock radiator. Prior tests of the thermostat all showed that the thermostat was functioning properly. No other components were changed.
It seemed to me like the larger, "race" radiator's cooling capacity was simply overwhelming the system as a whole, despite the fact that there is a thermostat in there that ought to regulate things properly.
Sounds like your car was ran hard by PO if it needed that much extra cooling capacity.
I did not have overheating problems (apart from the known 2014 radiator fan has a bug).
I had a consistent, "Car runs too cold at highway speeds" problem, over several months, from the day I bought it. Eventually I fixed it by replacing the (3x larger) aftermarket radiator (that had a small leak) with a stock radiator. Prior tests of the thermostat all showed that the thermostat was functioning properly. No other components were changed.
It seemed to me like the larger, "race" radiator's cooling capacity was simply overwhelming the system as a whole, despite the fact that there is a thermostat in there that ought to regulate things properly.
Ok, I still have a problem with my logic on this.
First, what temperature was the thermostat? I'm guessing it might not have been stock and if that is the case, the "cold" signals on the tach were from a t-stat that was for racing (150° or 160°) and not normal driving.
Second, even with the huge radiator, an OEM t-stat (195°) would keep the car warm enough so the tach "cold" bars would not reappear. The t-stat would open, but not fully, to control the temp.
Third, a leaking radiator would not cause the engine to "overcool". Low coolant will overheat an engine, so for a cold engine condition, it should not be in the conversation at all except it definitely was cause to replace the radiator.
17 GS with the exact same issue. Wasn't as bad in the hot temps, but cooler temps keep it too low.
Same year GS here, stock tstat, similar problem. Last summer I noticed coolant temps were running 180-185° and was keeping an eye on the gauge during that period. Drove it yesterday in coolish (for us in S. LA) 50° temps and didn't take notice as I should have. Mine is not stuck open, as this summer it climbed up predictably and peaked at the temp mentioned, but should stop higher, around 195°. Will watch more closely in next drives.
First, what temperature was the thermostat? I'm guessing it might not have been stock and if that is the case, the "cold" signals on the tach were from a t-stat that was for racing (150° or 160°) and not normal driving.
Second, even with the huge radiator, an OEM t-stat (195°) would keep the car warm enough so the tach "cold" bars would not reappear. The t-stat would open, but not fully, to control the temp.
Third, a leaking radiator would not cause the engine to "overcool". Low coolant will overheat an engine, so for a cold engine condition, it should not be in the conversation at all except it definitely was cause to replace the radiator.
Elmer
I agree it's odd, but the facts are as I presented them. Stock thermostat (tested & verified), really oversize aluminum radiator with a pinhole leak, car would always overcool after reaching temperature.
All was fixed solely by replacing the radiator with a stock radiator.
When my builder built my engine with the Magnuson 2650 supercharger one of the other things they did was replace the stock thermostat with a 160 degree thermostat. I’m not a builder so I don’t know why but I assume it’s to keep the engine running cooler.
I have the same issue described by other posters where my engine according to the tach gage won’t warm up or it does and then drops back down where those yellow bars will show up for a while.
my builder said that is normal and to not worry about it.
When my builder built my engine with the Magnuson 2650 supercharger one of the other things they did was replace the stock thermostat with a 160 degree thermostat. I’m not a builder so I don’t know why but I assume it’s to keep the engine running cooler.
I have the same issue described by other posters where my engine according to the tach gage won’t warm up or it does and then drops back down where those yellow bars will show up for a while.
my builder said that is normal and to not worry about it.
It is normal for a build that will do a lot of racing on the track. If the bulk of your driving is day to day stuff with highway travel, then the t-stat will give you the tach lights when it's cold out. I had a 735 rwhp twin turbo ls6 in my 98 camaro (now my son's) and I had a stock t-stat in it. Never overheated, allowed me to drive in the cold with a nice warm heater output and gave me the freedom to kick it in the *** every now and then to check out the traction (or something). If you want heat and no returning tach lights, put in a stock t-stat and tweak the fan settings a little. I also had a 2007 ls2 Corvette that I added an edelbrock SC to the engine. It got 550 to the wheels and I had a stock t-stat in it. Never got the "return of the tach lights" with it in cold weather.
It's probably true, ignoring it is fine BUT, I would twitch a little if the tach lights came back on after warming up the car.
I bet my 2019 has this issue too. I just bought it a month ago and always noticed it takes forever to get warmed up. It will eventually get up to temps but only after 15mins of idle warm up and 3-4 miles of easy driving. If I park and go into a store for a bit the bars will be back when I restart it. I noticed the other day it took forever to warm up on a 50 degree day. I had to drive my Nissan Titan somewhere that day and it warmed up in 5 mins.