What's your Deductible?
#1
What's your Deductible?
This is my first joy-ride car and I'm pricing out insurance. Here is the monthly pricing for my C8 with identical coverage to my 2 daily drivers (Raptor and Odyssey). $500 comp/coll = $120.99/Month
$1,000 comp/coll = $111.08/Month
$2,000 comp/coll = $95.83/Month
Wondering if there is a theory on what the deductible should be on a car you're limiting the risk exposure on by not driving it daily.
$1,000 comp/coll = $111.08/Month
$2,000 comp/coll = $95.83/Month
Wondering if there is a theory on what the deductible should be on a car you're limiting the risk exposure on by not driving it daily.
#2
Pro
With cars costing so much now. I have My deductibles as high as I can. It lowers My Yearly insurance payment. If You do wreck it. Does it matter if the deductible is $500 or $2000 when the repair will probably be $20,000 or more?
i hit a Deer in Our Mustang. Needed a fender one headlight and a hood. And a couple brackets. That was almost $9000.
The savings in My Premiums more than offsets the difference in the deductible. That most Body Shops will pay anyways so They can get the work.
i hit a Deer in Our Mustang. Needed a fender one headlight and a hood. And a couple brackets. That was almost $9000.
The savings in My Premiums more than offsets the difference in the deductible. That most Body Shops will pay anyways so They can get the work.
#3
Pro
$1,000 on all our vehicles for decades now. Saved a lot.
The following users liked this post:
Fast Dawg (04-30-2024)
#4
Race Director
I don't know what others are doing is very relevant as everyone's tolerance for risk, amount of deductible they can afford to pay in the even an accident and how much mileage they expect to put on their C8 is different.
Personally I opt for a higher deductible as I don't put that many miles on my C8 since I drive two other vehicles as well as my C8 and I can afford to pay a high deductible if I have an accident.
Personally I opt for a higher deductible as I don't put that many miles on my C8 since I drive two other vehicles as well as my C8 and I can afford to pay a high deductible if I have an accident.
#5
Burning Brakes
My insurance company here in Canada has a mandatory $2000 deductible for any car over $100,000. This was news to me when I bought my most recent C8 with an MSRP of $109,000
#6
Moderator
Member Since: Dec 2002
Location: Lakewood Ranch, FL
Posts: 40,116
Received 3,598 Likes
on
1,632 Posts
$1000
#7
Race Director
#8
Le Mans Master
I moved from $500 to $1k last fall.
#10
Safety Car
$500 all around, maybe I should look into raising it to save some $$ too
#11
Melting Slicks
Other than your ability to pay the deductible out of pocket (which is hopefully not an issue for anyone owning a C8 at this juncture) it's pretty much math.
For the OP, the difference in premium (Ignoring inflation and interest which do change the math some) get him from the $500 deductible to the $1000 deductible in about 4 1/4 years. So, if you think (guess) you are going to have a claim in the next 4.25 years, you should stay with the lower deductible. If not, go higher. For the $1k to $2k deductible, that's another 6.5 years (so 6.5 years from the $1000 or 10.75 from the 500). The insurance companies have all the data to make this math work, so from their end, it probably washes either way, which means it probably does for you as well. That said, if it were me, looking at the math I'm probably at the $1000 deductible, for a non-daily car is the odds of a claim in 4 years doesn't seem great, but the odds of one in 10.75 seems more likely.
For the OP, the difference in premium (Ignoring inflation and interest which do change the math some) get him from the $500 deductible to the $1000 deductible in about 4 1/4 years. So, if you think (guess) you are going to have a claim in the next 4.25 years, you should stay with the lower deductible. If not, go higher. For the $1k to $2k deductible, that's another 6.5 years (so 6.5 years from the $1000 or 10.75 from the 500). The insurance companies have all the data to make this math work, so from their end, it probably washes either way, which means it probably does for you as well. That said, if it were me, looking at the math I'm probably at the $1000 deductible, for a non-daily car is the odds of a claim in 4 years doesn't seem great, but the odds of one in 10.75 seems more likely.
The following users liked this post:
Khaberst (04-30-2024)
#12
I'm paying $478/year CAD for my 22 C8 ... BUT deductible is $6500 ...
I have been told by every insurance company that any vehicle over $100k , must have a deductible of 5% of purchase value. I have verified this with friends also. Might be an NB thing, but in any case my reality.
ALL my other vehicles I run at a $2000 deductible, as anything lower I'm not putting through insurance.
#14
Le Mans Master
Member Since: Apr 2018
Location: Dove Mountain, AZ
Posts: 5,150
Received 7,010 Likes
on
2,700 Posts
2023 C8 of the Year Finalist - Unmodified
$1000
The following users liked this post:
VNAMVET (04-30-2024)
#17
Other than your ability to pay the deductible out of pocket (which is hopefully not an issue for anyone owning a C8 at this juncture) it's pretty much math.
For the OP, the difference in premium (Ignoring inflation and interest which do change the math some) get him from the $500 deductible to the $1000 deductible in about 4 1/4 years. So, if you think (guess) you are going to have a claim in the next 4.25 years, you should stay with the lower deductible. If not, go higher. For the $1k to $2k deductible, that's another 6.5 years (so 6.5 years from the $1000 or 10.75 from the 500). The insurance companies have all the data to make this math work, so from their end, it probably washes either way, which means it probably does for you as well. That said, if it were me, looking at the math I'm probably at the $1000 deductible, for a non-daily car is the odds of a claim in 4 years doesn't seem great, but the odds of one in 10.75 seems more likely.
For the OP, the difference in premium (Ignoring inflation and interest which do change the math some) get him from the $500 deductible to the $1000 deductible in about 4 1/4 years. So, if you think (guess) you are going to have a claim in the next 4.25 years, you should stay with the lower deductible. If not, go higher. For the $1k to $2k deductible, that's another 6.5 years (so 6.5 years from the $1000 or 10.75 from the 500). The insurance companies have all the data to make this math work, so from their end, it probably washes either way, which means it probably does for you as well. That said, if it were me, looking at the math I'm probably at the $1000 deductible, for a non-daily car is the odds of a claim in 4 years doesn't seem great, but the odds of one in 10.75 seems more likely.
#20
Race Director
Member Since: Nov 2017
Location: Prosper TX/Austin TX
Posts: 11,066
Received 8,986 Likes
on
4,328 Posts
2020 C6 of the Year Winner - Modified
My Corvette is on an agreed value policy with Grundy & $0 deducible. My other vehicles have $500 deductibles.