When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.
If it just clicks, you either have a poor connection, or a dead battery, or both. Start with the connections on the battery itself.
Even if it shows the correct voltage, it may not have enough remaining ampacity to start your car.
Can you hook up a multimeter and watch the voltage dip during an attempted start?
Like I say I have been working on this problem for about 6 months and have replaced the battery and starter and had an old car electrician examine it. Nothing has changed.
This morning I tried to start it (55 degrees) and all I could get were clicks with 10 tries. Then I charged up the battery but it was fully charged anyway. I tried it after doing that and only got clicks. Then a couple hours later I tried again and it started up nice and crisp with gusto.
Most of the time it starts up fine but occasionally it only clicks until I try it again a while later. This is not making any sense to me. The electrician says it’s well grounded.
What your describing sounds like a bad connection. Your electrician says it's grounded properly. I wouldn't go on that at all. I would triple check both ground cables myself! Are they green inside, under the cable insulation? Good , CLEAN connection under battery at the frame connection? Engine ground cable, the same, CLEAN, secure connection's at the engine block and frame connection.
Do not count on someone else's assessment. Check it your self! Then condition of battery positive cable! With all the issues you have had that all SCREAM Bad connection. I would be looking at replacing all 3 cables!
If your getting clicking. It's absolutely NOT in your switches.
Battery to frame, clean and tight on both ends, proper gauge cable, engine block, just above starter to frame at idler arm. Clean and tight both ends. Proper size cable. Positive cable, clean and tight. Both ends. All solenoid hardware, also, clean and tight.
Clicking at solenoid shows power is getting to solenoid. So it clearly is NOT your clutch switch. Clicking at solenoid shows solenoid is not sending power to the starting motor. Bad disc inside solenoid? 2 in a row? Possible. Poor Battery cables? Also possible. Age? Quality?
also possible, bad spot on commutator of starter motor armature.
Battery to frame, clean and tight on both ends, proper gauge cable, engine block, just above starter to frame at idler arm. Clean and tight both ends. Proper size cable. Positive cable, clean and tight. Both ends. All solenoid hardware, also, clean and tight.
Clicking at solenoid shows power is getting to solenoid. So it clearly is NOT your clutch switch. Clicking at solenoid shows solenoid is not sending power to the starting motor. Bad disc inside solenoid? 2 in a row? Possible. Poor Battery cables? Also possible. Age? Quality?
also possible, bad spot on commutator of starter motor armature.
Thanks for the recommendations but wouldn’t there be some sputtering starts if ground cables were marginally bad connected? Or a start that quits in the middle? As it is now it’s either a totally perfect clean start up or just a click. Just curious if that is possible. Thanks again.
A simple test for bad ground between battery & starter is to attach a jumper cable to the negative post of the battery and attach the other end of the cable to a clean (unpainted) point on your engine block. Then see if this improves/eliminates your starting issue.
I have a 70 454 vette (have owned it since 1973) with Hooker Ceramic Coated Side Pipes. Stock compression ratio (10.75 if I remember right). I fought the slow cranking problem when the engine was hot for years using the stock Delco Remy starters. Replaced a lot of starters and solenoids. I tried the wraps but not much help. Finally went to a mini starter a few years ago and put the wrap around it just to be on the safe side. Seems like I had to do a minor wiring change (I'm no electrician) but no problems since then.
I have a 70 454 vette (have owned it since 1973) with Hooker Ceramic Coated Side Pipes. Stock compression ratio (10.75 if I remember right). I fought the slow cranking problem when the engine was hot for years using the stock Delco Remy starters. Replaced a lot of starters and solenoids. I tried the wraps but not much help. Finally went to a mini starter a few years ago and put the wrap around it just to be on the safe side. Seems like I had to do a minor wiring change (I'm no electrician) but no problems since then.
Thanks but lately it’s not starting when it’s cold either so I guess that eliminates overheating as the main cause.
There may be problem with oil dropping on one of the cables that is on one of the hold down bolts for the starter. Dripping directly down from the oil pan ( I need to replace the oil pan gasket with a one piecer). The other cable on the other hold down is very clean and they both go to the frame near the engine mount. That is clean but not be the best location possibly to bolt down.
A simple test for bad ground between battery & starter is to attach a jumper cable to the negative post of the battery and attach the other end of the cable to a clean (unpainted) point on your engine block. Then see if this improves/eliminates your starting issue.
I suppose I could just connect a remote starter switch I have to check if it is a ground wire problem for certain but I really don’t think it is at this point because of the pattern of starts and no starts. A no start is just a click sound in this case. The reason I doubt it is a grounding problem is because it will start if I continue to try starting it after many series of clicks.
Could this mean the key switch is faulty and is intermittently connecting with the contacts?
It appears the ignition switch is worn out. The key doesn't make a buzzing sound anymore when inserting and other contact problems. This was replaced in 2018 ...do they not last as long after replacing? A Chevy dealer replaced it last time and was not cheap.